EurActiv.com

EU news and policy debates across languages

28/09/2016

Schulz brushes off National Front fraud counter-claim

Justice & Home Affairs

Schulz brushes off National Front fraud counter-claim

Le Pen's National Front, which has accused European Parliament President Schulz of fraud, is enjoying a surge in the polls in France.

[David Oranje/Flickr]

European Parliament President Martin Schulz today (13 March) brushed off accusations of hypocrisy made by Marine Le Pen’s National Front, after he reported the far-right party to anti-fraud investigators.

Le Pen’s Brussels office said Schulz – who it branded a “hate-filled socialist” – was breaking rules over European Parliament accredited assistants.

Schulz’s spokesman Armin Machmer said the “accusations were unfounded”. The president had asked the institution’s services to prove that and would publish the results of their investigation, he said.

Schulz had previously told OLAF, the bloc’s anti-corruption agency, that 20 National Front officials were being paid from the EU budget as MEPs’ assistants. In fact, according to NF documents, they were functionaries in the party’s national organisation, a Parliament statement released Monday (10 March) said.

A parliamentary source said the alleged fraud cost €7.5 million. OLAF must now decide whether or not to investigate, a process that can take months.

>>Read: EU Parliament calls in fraud squad over National Front suspicions

Le Pen yesterday (12 March) sent out a press release, headlined “The boot is on the other foot”.

“Martin Schultz [sic], without any evidence and through pure calculating bias, slandered our assistants and threw them to the lions,” the National Front said.

The party would make a formal complaint against Schulz, the release said, before calling on the media to give its “fraud” allegation attention.

Schulz had made the accusation a few days before France’s local departmental elections at the request of “his friend” Manuel Valls, it said. Valls is France’s socialist prime minister and has warned against the risks of the National Front’s growing popularity.

Rant

In a diatribe full of ranting rhetoric, and apparently based on a Google search, it claimed Schulz assistant Herbert Hansen was working for a travel agent. Euregio Tours was an agency connected to the SPD, the German party that Schulz belongs to, it alleged.

“The first page of Google search results shows that he […] will not deal with European affairs, nor even policy, but tourism,” the release, sent by Le Pen’s assistant Ludovic de Danne, said.

“Martin Schulz is a good illustration of these hate-filled, pathetic socialists who are so predictable across Europe,” it continued, before calling on Schulz to refer himself to OLAF.

Hansen was not based in Brussels, Luxembourg or Strasbourg, as parliamentary rules required, but in Aix-la-Chapelle, according to the National Front.

Schulz spokesman Machmer said Hansen is an accredited parliamentary assistant, living and working in Brussels. One of his tasks is managing visiting groups to the Parliament. According to the institution’s rules, that cannot be done by members of the president’s cabinet, he added.

The Euregio Tours connection was separate from his parliamentary work. “In his free time and on a benevolent basis, Mr Hansen has also been in charge of study visits for a number of years,” Machmer said.

Elections in France

French Prime Minister Manuel Valls warned Sunday that the National Front could win the next presidential election in 2017, saying their policies were a “disaster” for the country.

The National Front is leading in some French opinion polls, benefiting from discontent with President François Hollande and with high levels of unemployment.

Polls showed that it could win an “unprecedented” score in forthcoming local elections on 22 March and 29 March, Valls said.

Positions

National Front press release in full and unedited.

The boot's on the other foot ... Martin Schulz's 'tour operator' accredited assistant!

Martin Schulz's accredited assistant, Herbert Hansen according to the European Parliament site, will combine tourism and socialism from Aix-la-Chapelle.

In contrast to a local assistant, an accredited assistant must be based in one of the European Parliament's three places of work: Brussels, Strasbourg or Luxembourg.

The first page of Google search results shows that he, in contrast to all accredited parliamentary and local assistants for the FN/RBM, will not deal with European affairs, nor even policy, but tourism through Euregio Tours GmbH & Co. KG, a travel agent connected to the SPD.

Martin Schulz is a good illustration of these hate-filled, pathetic socialists who are so predictable across Europe. It is clear, according to the criteria presented to the media by Mr. Schulz, that he should call upon OLAF to investigate his own case and that of his accredited assistant.

Martin Schultz, without any evidence and through pure calculating bias, slandered our assistants and threw them to the lions, upon the request of his friend Manuel Valls a few days before the Departmental elections.

They will obviously lodge a complaint against the President of the European Parliament and will be paying close attention to how the institution deals with this case.

Finally, they hope that the media will give as much attention to this crucial information as they felt able to give to the sleight of hand by Messrs Schultz and Valls.

Background

France's far-right party, the National Front (FN), had its best ever electoral performance in the European elections of May 2014, wining almost a quarter of the total votes cast.

The National Front is now France's largest delegation in the European Parliament, with 24 MEPs out of a total of 74. Since winning the election, the National Front has been seeking to form a political group in the European Parliament, but has so far failed.This has deprived them of numerous advantages, including European funding.

The far-right party has been trying to ride the wave of momentum they built up during the European elections to become the most important political party in France. 

It has stirred controversy recently for taking significant loans from a Russian bank.

>> Read: National Front's Russian loans cause uproar in European Parliament

Timeline

  • 22 March and 29 March: Local elections in France

Further Reading