EXCLUSIVE / Better insulation could shave 4% off European industry’s total fuel consumption and emissions bill, a sum worth €3.5 billion a year, says an unpublished report by the Ecofys consultancy.
The total cost-effective energy savings potential amounts to 620 petajoules (PJ), the equivalent of 37 million tonnes of CO2 emissions, according to the paper, ‘Climate protection with rapid payback’, which is due to be published next week.
"The lack of awareness of the energy savings potential of industrial insulation is surprising all around,” said Andreas Gürtler, director of the European Industrial Insulation Foundation, which commissioned the research.
He added: “To tap this large economic potential delivering competitive advantage combined with energy and CO2 savings, a dedicated implementation of article eight of the energy efficiency directive on energy audits is inevitable.”
The study estimates the initial investment costs of insulating bare industrial surfaces and repairing damaged industrial insulation at about €900 million. But the payback times for the majority of such investments were under one year, and sometimes just a few months.
Around 10% or more of the industrial insulation in Europe’s industrial plants is estimated to be uninsulated or covered with damaged insulation. Remedying this would slash industrial energy consumption by 3%.
"When we talk about insulation people usually think about buildings and fridges but a lot of heat is lost in industrial processes because piping and other equipment are not insulated at all, or are insulated insufficiently," said Kornelis Blok, a science director for Ecofys.
"If you look at it from the energy conservation perspective, a much higher degree of insulation – sometimes double or triple the original amount – is justified on a cost-benefit basis alone," he told EurActiv. "It makes economic sense."
Currently, insulation levels typically follow minimum investment decisions, based around requirements such as the maximum surface temperature needed to avoid personal injuries, minimum process needs, or generic maximum heat loss rates.
But this means that the maximum energy efficiency or cost-effectiveness of insulation systems are rarely considered.
Energy efficient lighting
Some firms have publicly embraced the cost-effectiveness of energy savings as part of an industrial competitiveness strategy. At the Warsaw climate summit last week, Philips announced that iLED lighting would use 30% less energy in 2020 than they had in 2006.
The company also plans to halve the number of incandescent light bulbs on the global market from 12 to 6 billion by the decade's end.
“We should remember that Europe will never produce the cheapest energy so we should lead in consuming the least energy,” Harry Verhaar, the director of Philips Lighting’s energy and climate change division told EurActiv.
According to Philips, a global switchover to LED technology had brought an average 40% energy savings since 2006, the equivalent of €128 billion a year and 670 million tonnes of avoided CO2 emissions.
When fuel prices were lower, energy efficiency would not have brought such large cost savings but their current levels increase the money that energy efficiency can save.
Best industrial practice
Industrial insulation and upgrading in particular would avoid about 66% of current industrial heat loss, the Ecofys report says. If insulation experts were involved in the planning process of new builds early in the process the increase in space entailed would help the industrial renovation process.
As examples of best industrial practice, the report cites:
- A chemical plant in France which could save 12.6 million kWh/a and €505,000 a year with a 2-4 month payback period
- An Italian refinery which could save over 1 million kWh/a and €75,000 a year with a 1-3 year payback period
- A German processing plant which could save 1.4 million kWh/a and €47,800 a year with a 3 months payback
The Ecofys methodology involved establishing a minimum cost-effective pathway between increasing investment costs due to insulation, and decreasing costs from heat loss.
Ecofys is a Dutch consultancy specialising in renewables, energy efficiency and carbon emissions, which has produced research for the European Commission, national governments and several private sector companies.
Europe aims to reduce its primary energy use by 20% by 2020, a target which is not legally binding.
The European Commission proposed the Energy Efficiency Directive in mid-2011 as part of the effort to achieve this goal. The European Parliament and Council, together with the Commission, reached a deal on the proposed directive in June 2012.
- Proposes individual measures for each of the sectors that could play a role in reducing energy consumption - apart from transport, which is voluntary. This includes a controversial obligation on energy companies to achieve 1.5% energy savings per year on their customer's bills.
- Asks member states to develop long-term strategies for the energy-efficient refurbishment of Europe's building stock.
- Obliges authorities to renovate public buildings, although this only applies to those "owned and occupied" by national governments, not regional or local authorities.
Member states must present their energy efficiency targets and the set of measures they will implement to reach their targets by April 2013. If member states do not collectively set the EU on its path to achieve 20% energy savings by 2020, they will have to re-assess their measures and targets or risk penalties.
- 2014: Energy Efficiency Directive due to come into effect.
- April 2014: First National Energy Efficiency Action Plans (NEEAPs) to be submitted to the Commission by member states.
- May 2014: EU member states must prepare schemes for their energy companies to deliver annual energy savings of 1.5%.
- 30 June 2014: Review of progress towards meeting the 2020 energy efficiency target.
- 2016: European Commission to review the Energy Efficiency Directive.
- 2020: Deadline for EU's aspirational target of cutting energy use by 20% of 2005 levels, according to a baseline projection
EU official documents
- European Commission: Energy Efficiency Directive
- European Commission: Energy Efficiency
- European Parliament: Compromise text on the proposed energy Efficiency Directive
- French environment ministry: Position on energy efficiency directive [in French] (12 June 2012)
NGOs and Think-Tanks
- Friends of Earth Europe: Website
- Climate Action Network Europe: Website
- The Coalition for Energy Savings: Website
- WWF: Website
- European Environmental Bureau (EEB): Website
- Social-Democrats: "Best possible deal" on energy efficiency reached last night
- Liberal-Democrats: Breakthrough on energy efficiency deal
- European Conservatives and Reformists: Energy Efficiency Directive agreed
- Greens: Deal on new EU rules a boost for economic and energy goals but more needed to reach 2020 target
- European People's Party: Energy Efficiency Directive: 2020 targets can be met flexibly according to national requirements. Markus Pieper MEP
- BusinessEurope: Energy Efficiency Directive - how to create an efficient policy framework?
- Cefic: Pushing back the limits of energy efficiency
- EurActiv Slovakia: IEA: Energetická ú?innos? je jedna z posledných možností
- EurActiv Czech Republic: Hlavní ekonom IEA: Energetická ú?innost je po Kjótu jednou z mála možností
- EurActiv Germany: Drei EU-Länder gegen Briten-Rabatt bei Energieeffizienz