Juncker seen rejecting Cameron’s EU Commission reform plan

Jean-Claude Juncker [European Council]

The leading candidate for the European Commission presidency, Jean-Claude Juncker, has rejected a request by UK Prime Minister David Cameron that the next British commissioner be given charge of a “cluster” of key portfolios, EurActiv has learned.

Cameron, who opposes Juncker's Commission bid, has requested last week that the future British Commissioner be given the post of Commission Vice-President in charge of overseeing a “cluster” of portfolios comprising the internal market, competition, trade and energy.

In addition, London wants the strategic post of Commission Secretary General for a British national, and other “small things”, two sources told EurActiv. The proposal was presented as a trade-off in which Cameron would accept that Juncker gets the Commission President seat.

>> Read: Cameron warming up to Juncker

However, according to sources, Juncker has rejected Cameron’s demand, while German Chancellor Angela Merkel is reportedly pushing for a decision by qualified majority vote in the Council, in which Cameron is expected to be out-voted.

At least 55% of EU countries representing at least 65% of the population is required to obtain a qualified majority, a threshold which would be easily attained without the UK and the few other countries which could decide to back London.

Juncker’s position is likely to please most EU leaders, who fear “clusters” of Commissioners could dwarf their national representatives.

Junior Commissioners without a cabinet?

The “clusters” would give a super-commissioner status to four or five Commissioners, while the rest would be relegated to junior Commissioners. A junior commissioner would be answerable both to the Commission President and the respective “cluster Commissioner”.

According to the advocates of the “cluster Commissioners” some junior Commissioners would not even have a cabinet, which normally have a staff of around 30 people.

While some smaller EU countries could accept the status of “junior Commissioners”, bigger countries are likely to see this as an offense.

“Just imagine a French “junior Commissioner” working under a British “cluster Commissioner” – no way”, a diplomat said.

The idea of “clusters of Commissioners” or "super Commissioners" has already been raised during the formation of the first Barroso Commission in 2004 but did not materialise. 

Cameron has threatened that Britain would advance a referendum on the UK's EU membership if Juncker is appointed Commission President.

EU leaders are expected to make a decision on the next Commission President during a summit on 26-27 June. The European parliament will hold a confidence vote on the chosen candidate, possibly as early as on 15 July.

  • 26-27 June: EU leaders meet for regularsummit;
  • 14-17 July: European Parliament session.


Mike Parr's picture

The new UK Commissioner could be put in charge of a "cluster of toilets" - given it is likely to be Lansley - this would thus match his capabilities, experience and performance to date. It would also reduce corruption possibilities (Walkers crisps anybody?).

an european's picture

Take in mind that who will be then the Commissioner President when if in any circumstances the President will be "out of service" ?
The English vice President of the commission ?

I would be very careful !!

an european's picture

Besides Cameron At least the leaders (Council) seems respecting the citizen's and the E.U. parliament votes !
In future the European Union needs some federal approvements from the Council with an directly elected E.U. President which could be candidates from E.U. parliament for more democracy !
As well ending the 6 Years moron economy we still are facing !