Berlin tells CIA station chief to leave in spy scandal

German Chancellor Angela Merkel at a European Council meeting. December 2011 [EU Council/Flickr]

Germany told the CIA station chief in Berlin to leave the country on Thursday (10 July) in a dramatic display of anger from Chancellor Angela Merkel at the behaviour of a close ally after officials unearthed two suspected US spies.

The scandal has chilled relations with Washington to levels not seen since Merkel's predecessor opposed the US invasion of Iraq in 2003. It follows allegations that Merkel herself, who grew up in Stasi-ridden East Germany, was among thousands of Germans whose mobile phones have been bugged by American agents.

"Spying on allies ... is a waste of energy," the chancellor said in her most pointed public remarks yet on the issue. "We have so many problems, we should focus on the important things."

Senior conservative supporters denounced US "stupidity" and some Americans said spying on their friends had backfired. But both sides stressed their need to go on working together.

"In the Cold War maybe there was general mistrust. Today we are living in the 21st century. Today there are completely new threats," Merkel said in Berlin, once a key CIA listening post behind the Iron Curtain during the superpower duel with Moscow and now the reunited capital of Europe's most powerful economy.

Her spokesman said the request for the top US intelligence official in the Berlin embassy to leave was made in response to questions raised in recent months on US intelligence activity in Germany and by prosecutors' investigations.

In guarded comments, a White House spokeswoman declined to comment on "reports" of "a purported intelligence matter" but she stressed, "Our security and intelligence relationship with Germany is a very important one and it keeps Germans and Americans safe ... It is essential that cooperation continue."

US government sources said the official - whom neither side named - was Berlin station chief for the CIA, the Central Intelligence Agency. A German source said the man would face possible forcible expulsion if he did not leave voluntarily.

Washington's embassy and Merkel's office sit a few hundred metres apart. They lie east and west of what was the Berlin Wall.  Many Germans still give great credit to their U.S. ally for the fall of the Wall, deepening today's sense of betrayal.

Interior Minister Thomas de Maiziere said, "The Americans are our closest allies in all security questions.

"We're aware of our shared past. But we do not approve of this way of dealing with each other and today's measure, which was reasonable and appropriate, is a clear indication of that."

On Wednesday, Berlin said it had discovered a suspected US spy in the Defence Ministry. That came just days after a German foreign intelligence worker was arrested on suspicion of being a CIA informant and admitted passing documents to a US contact.

The scale of public outrage at these revelations has put pressure on Merkel to take action against the United States, an ally whose defence of West Germany in the Cold War long assured Americans a warmer welcome there than elsewhere in Europe.

However, there is a limit to what she can do and both sides stressed the need to continue to work closely together. They have done increasingly in recent years, on issues from Iran to Ukraine, as Germany shakes off its postwar reticence in foreign affairs and takes on a role more suited to its economic weight.


Experts said that talks on a free trade deal between the European Union and United States, called the Transatlantic Trade and Investment Partnership (TTIP), may be affected; Berlin may push harder on some aspects of the deal in areas such as data protection - long a major concern for Germans after the abuses of the Nazi Gestapo and East German Stasi secret police.

"But the idea that Merkel would somehow try to torpedo TTIP is not really likely," said Germany expert Hans Kundnani at European Council on Foreign Relations in London.

John Kornblum, a former U.S. ambassador to Germany who still lives in Berlin, said: "I believe the Germans are telling the Americans, 'We want to continue close cooperation but you've pushed us too far and have forced us to react'."

Merkel's government poured scorn on the alleged espionage.

Interior Minister de Maiziere said the information the United States appeared to have obtained was "laughable", contrasting that with the "disproportionate and serious political damage" the scandal had caused.

Merkel was "not amused", Finance Minister Wolfgang Schäuble said, adding: "This is so stupid, it can only make you weep."

Tensions have risen since revelations last year stemming from documents leaked by Edward Snowden, a contractor with the US National Security Agency (NSA). Those caused Berlin to demand a mutual "no-spy deal" which Washington has resisted.

"Ever since the NSA disclosures broke last year, the issue of US spying has been an extremely sensitive issue in Germany," said Karen Donfried, president of the German Marshall Fund of the United States, which promotes US-European ties.

Some Americans asked whether the espionage activities were worth the bother: "I am not troubled that the United States conducts espionage, even against friendly states," said one former senior US intelligence official.

"I am troubled when we attempt espionage and do not do it well. We learn nothing and we embarrass a friend and ourselves."



Mike Parr's picture

I'd be more worried about the CIA and its industrial espionage in Germany and in the rest of Europe.

The Enercon case in the 1990s is a good example of this - the CIA obtained (illegally) industrial secrets covering variable speed wind turbines and passed these on to a US wind company (eventually taken over by General Electric).

The USA competes with Europe in the economic sphere - they are not & never have been "partners" in a real sense. The TTIP is aimed at addressing what the USA sees as the "problem" of "socialism" in Europe (based on the point of view that Europe is one of the few regions offering an alternative (however weak) to the way in which the USA "does things".

Antoine's picture

Good comment!

But this economic union is simply for us a step towards a political union, then the Yanks will feel how we "do things".

an european's picture

The USA competes with Europe in the economic sphere by SPYING bit it doesn't end there ...worsens it we "have" considered Americans as allied !
The Citizen's of America aren't to blame but merely the Obama Admin which has the total Power of the NSA !
What about an anti-spy act between E.U. and the U.S !
Now if there doesn't exist one then Europe should spy the U.S. too and re-steal competition Info's back !

A Londoner's picture

If I lived in Estonia or Latvia I would be feeling slightly nervous. Both countries border on Russia, both contain significant Russian minorities some with grievances and during the last 200 years both have been part of Russia for three times as long as they have been independent.

At present Latvia and Estonia rely on NATO for their defence but within NATO the Europeans are free-riding. The US pays, we benefit.

Not paying your fair share but taking the moral high-ground sounds like a risky combination to me. And would sound even more so if I lived in Estonia or Latvia!