Merkel advises against hasty EU penalties to Switzerland


German Chancellor Angela Merkel warned today (18 February) against rushing to retaliate against Switzerland for its vote to curb immigration, saying Europe's own interests were best served by waiting to see how the Swiss implement the referendum result.

"It can't be that because one side did something in one specific area that the other side says nothing works in other areas," Merkel said after talks with Swiss President Didier Burkhalter, who is also the country's foreign minister.

"First of all we need to see how Switzerland implements this vote over the coming three years. I would advise against deciding on consequences at the very beginning and not waiting for the implementation process in Switzerland," she said.

The Swiss narrowly backed curtailing immigration from the EU in a vote backed by the right-wing Swiss People's Party which tapped into concerns that the country's culture is being eroded by foreigners, who account for nearly a quarter of the population.

Since 2002, Switzerland has had a treaty with the European Union which allows for the free movement of labour. The recent vote threatens that pact, and with it a package of other accords that cover economic and technological cooperation, public procurement, and a host of other areas.

European Commission President José  Manuel Barroso has warned the 9 February vote will have "serious consequences" for ties with the 28-member EU, which has already postponed talks with the Swiss on multibillion-dollar research and educational schemes.

Switzerland, in turn, has already said it cannot sign a labour market pact with new EU member Croatia.

Taking a more strident stance than the Germans, France's industry minister said the Swiss vote amounted to "collective suicide". Arnaud Montebourg said Swiss exports would be hit by retaliatory tariffs and "Switzerland will impoverish itself".

French Foreign Minister Laurent Fabius has said Paris would review diplomatic relations, without specifying how.

Swiss business leaders fear access to foreign professionals will be shackled by red tape and bilateral accords with the EU, the country's biggest trading partner, will be undermined.

Burkhalter, speaking at a news conference with Merkel, said trade between Switzerland and Germany, at 75 billion euros, was worth about half the volume of German trade with China and that about 350,000 Germans currently work in Switzerland.

"The challenge will now be that we deal with the results in a way that relations between the European Union and Switzerland remain as intense as possible with respect for the referendum," said Merkel, promising to work for a solution that respects the Swiss vote "but does not further damage the EU's own interests".

The Swiss president said his country had three years to work out how to implement the legally-binding referendum result in a way that was "non-discriminatory" to Croatia.

"There is no reason to stop everything because of a decision that is not yet in force," said Burkhalter, adding that it was in nobody's interests to suspend cooperation on areas like research or power generation that affected competitiveness.

The EU has stopped talks with Switzerland on a cross-border electricity agreement which had been aimed at closer power trading ties with the country.



André Clodong's picture

Wise heads are urgently needed to calm the waters. The Swiss proposal ressembles the immigration policy in many major States around the world. My view is that the Swiss proposal is not a bad template for others to follow. Unchecked immigration is the mother of many ills.


@ André Clodong

"Unchecked immigration is the mother of many ills"

maybe for Swisself and yourself!

"The implement the legally-binding referendum result in a way that was "non-discriminatory"!
- The indicates Swiss is mega racists

The E.U. should show balls and stand on It's based principle of freedom at least in the Eurozone an NOT that of the The E.U. Dominated SS Merkel !

Gerry's picture

Calm heads are needed indeed. Although free movement is a basic European right, the resulting flow of people utilizing the right of free settlement has upset many in different countries. Europe is not yet another America, where freedom of movement is a basic necessity, as the cultural difference between member states is still so big. Perhaps the opinions will change after the election results, or perhaps people will just mellow out a bit.