EurActiv Logo
EU news & policy debates
- across languages -
Click here for EU news »
EurActiv.com Network

BROWSE ALL SECTIONS

Commission seeks to tighten pollution controls

Printer-friendly version
Send by email
Published 02 November 2007, updated 28 May 2012

Most member states have missed a deadline to issue pollution permits for industrial installations as mandated by a 1996 directive. The Commission, which is currently drafting a proposal to revise the directive, may impose stricter rules and has warned that the implementation delay could lead to infringement proceedings.

The Commission's services, notably the Directorate-Generals (DGs) for Environment and Enterprise, are currently finalising a difficult inter-service consultation on the revision of the IPPC Directive.

According to EU industry group BusinessEurope, which is following the discussions closely, DG Environment is pushing for a tougher measures in order to cut down on industrial emissions as part of wider efforts to meet EU CO2 reduction commitments.

One idea on the table is to make the BREFs binding documents rather than non-binding reference texts, which means that certain pollution prevention and control techniques agreed at EU level would become harmonised and mandatory rather than suggestive. 

This would represent a significant departure from current rules, which state that "technical characteristics of the installation concerned, its geographical location and the local environmental conditions" can be "taken into account" by member-state authorities when permits are drawn up.

The Commission, which laments a "constraint on the use of more flexible instruments such as NOx and SO2 emissions trading systems", is also considering adding an emissions trading component for pollutants not considered to be greenhouse gases.

Due to "important shortcomings in the implementation of the current legislation that hinder the full exploitation of the environmental potential originally intended by the directive", the Commission has stated that it will pursue "all necessary actions to ensure that the directive is correctly transposed, including through infringement cases to ensure full and correct transposition of the legislation".

Positions: 

BusinessEurope, the Confederation of European Business, believes the BREFs "should remain guidance documents", arguing that "industrial installations are different from each other even in the same sector and are situated with varying conditions. This fundamental principle of the IPPC Directive was the basis for cooperation between the Commission, member states and industry, and [this] needs to be preserved and cannot be the exception". 

In a 31 October contribution to the Commission's inter-service consultation, BusinessEurope also expressed "strong reservations" about the expansion of the EU's Emissions Trading Scheme (EU ETS) to include non-greenhouse gases. "NOx and SO2 should be regulated under the IPPC Directive, using tools which are already available", the paper said.

The European Engineering Industries Association Orgalime  also argued against limiting flexibility and imposing BREFs as mandatory rather than guidance documents. In a 31 October letter sent to EU Industry Commissioner Günter Verheugen, the organisation asks the Commissioner to "ensure legal certainty for companies operating in the EU, rather than significantly changing requirements without awaiting the full implementation and effectiveness of existing legislation". 

Orgalime furthermore opposes expanding the powers of competent authorites to determine the best pollution reduction techniques, as this would "lead to arbitrary discrimination and be detrimental to the EU internal market", the letter said.

Next steps: 
  • Week beginning 5 Nov. 2007: Close of inter-service consultation.
  • 17 Dec. 2007: Commission expected to present proposal for revised IPPC Directive.
Background: 

The 1996 Directive on Integrated Pollution Prevention and Control (IPPC) introduces a permit system to prevent and limit pollution from large-scale industrial installations. Sectors covered include everything from metals, chemicals and paper to processed food, oil refineries and large-scale pig and poultry farms.

The permits include precise emission limit values and are to be issued by the competent authorities in the member states. When drawing up the limits, the authorities are required to take into account reference documents (BREFs) compiled on the basis of Best Available Techniques (BATs), agreed upon at EU level. 

Although the transposition of the IPPC directive into national law was due in 1999, member states were given a transition period until October 2007 to ensure that their existing industrial installations are fully compliant.

More on this topic

More in this section

Advertising

Sponsors

Videos

Sustainable Development News videos

Euractiv Sidebar Video Player for use in section aware blocks.

Sustainable Development Promoted videos

Euractiv Sidebar Video Player for use in section aware blocks.

Advertising

Advertising