EurActiv Logo
EU news & policy debates
- across languages -
Click here for EU news »
EurActiv.com Network

BROWSE ALL SECTIONS

Surprise US-China climate pact meets with scepticism

Published 29 July 2005 - Updated 29 June 2007
Printer-friendly versionSend by email

A group of six nations, including the US, China, India and Australia, have announced a surprise pact to fight climate change mainly based on technology transfers. The deal was cautiously welcomed by the EU.

The USA, together with China, India, and three other Asia-Pacific nations, on 28 July signed a joint energy and climate pact which they say has the potential to significantly reduce global greenhouse gas emissions.

The announcement came as a surprise in Brussels where it emerged that senior staff, and even Environment Commissioner Stavros Dimas himself, learned about the initiative in the press. It comes as a setback for the Commission, which is currently trying to build an international consensus on future climate action after 2012 that includes major emerging economies such as China and India (see related LinksDossier).

The pact is a non-binding agreement largely based on technology transfers between the six signatories - the USA, China, India, Australia, Japan and South Korea. It was officially unveiled in the margins of the meeting of the ASEAN countries at Vientiane, Laos. 

Signatories account for about half of the world's global GDP, population, energy use, and greenhouse emissions. As the countries were making the official announcement at a press conference on 28 July, Australia's Foreign Minister Alexander Downer said that "our collaboration can make a significant impact". 

The agreement is the first of its kind to include the USA and China, the world's two largest emitters of greenhouse gases responsible for man-made global warming.

"It is very clear to me that it is vital to be able to build on mutual interests of developed and developing countries together if one is going to take on global challenges," said Deputy Secretary Robert Zoellick at a press conference.

The 'vision statement' unveiled by the group of six nations explicitly recognises that initiatives to be taken under the pact will come as a complement to the 1997 Kyoto Protocol on climate change and will not seek to replace it. It also states that initiatives would have to be consistent with the UN Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC).

But contrary to the Kyoto Protocol, the vision statement does not list formal commitments nor does it oblige signatories to reduce greenhouse gas emissions in a legally-binding manner.

The scope of the arrangements is still to be defined but will chiefly focus on the development and roll-out of technologies.  These include the whole range of existing and emerging technologies including energy efficiency, renewables, hydrogen, biotechnologies and nuclear fission.

"We will consider establishing a framework for the partnership, including institutional and financial arrangements and ways to include other interested and like-minded countries," said the statement.

The pact follows the launch of discussions this year on how to take the fight against climate change to the next stage, after 2012 and the expiry of the targets agreed under the Kyoto Protocol.

Positions: 

In a statement, US President George W. Bush said that the pact will allow signatories "to develop and accelerate deployment of cleaner, more efficient energy technologies to meet national pollution reduction, energy security, and climate change concerns in ways that reduce poverty and promote economic development".

Australian Prime Minister John Howard was enthusiastic about the deal. "This is a historic agreement for the cause of reducing greenhouse gas emissions. The fairness and effectiveness of this proposal will be superior to the Kyoto Protocol," he assured, arguing the pact will avoid destroying Australian jobs and penalise Australian industries in the way the Kyoto Protocol would have done. 

The agreement was cautiously welcomed by the European Commission who said in a statement it was "encouraged" by the initiative. "It underlines the growing awareness of the seriousness of climate change and the need to address it," the statement said.

But others at the Commission were more sceptical: "We are not fully convinced that a voluntary agreement of this kind will have the significant impact necessary to combat climate change," said a spokesperson for Environment Commissioner Stavros Dimas. "We have always supported clean technologies but they cannot be a substitute to commitments such as those made under Kyoto," the spokesperson added.

Canada's Foreign Minister, Pierre Pettigrew, a staunch supporter of Kyoto, said that the partnership lacked substance. "When you want to complement something, you recognise that the real substance is somewhere else. A complement normally is something that adds on to something which is the real thing."

Environmental NGOs were extremely sceptical of the agreement. In a press statement, Friends of the Earth said "a deal on technology, supported by voluntary measures to reduce emissions, will not address climate change. This is yet another attempt by the US and Australian administrations to undermine the efforts of the 140 countries who have signed the Kyoto Protocol". 

At a joint press briefing on 28 July in Vientiane, Laos, US Deputy Secretary Robert Zoellick said "one can't just command other parties to do things. You can try, but it's not going to be effective, so you need to try to develop interests and incentives".

Next steps: 
  • The six signatories to the pact will hold their first meeting in November in Adelaide, Australia
  • Formal talks for a post-Kyoto climate change regime will officially kick-off in Montreal at the 11th conference of the parties to the UNFCC (COP-11) from 28 November to 9 December 2005.
Background: 

The six signatories of the Asia-Pacific Partnership on Clean Development are the USA, China, India, Australia, Japan and South Korea. The USA and Australia are the only two countries in the pact that have not signed up to Kyoto. However, in view of their status as emerging economies, China and India are exempt from taking legally binding measures under the protocol.

More on this topic

More in this section

Advertising