Airlines set to win carbon credits from biofuel flights
The European Commission has asked airlines to report on "the amount of biomass" they use so that biofuels can be accounted as "zero emission" in the greenhouse gas emissions reports they are requested to produce each year under the EU's carbon scheme for the aviation sector.
The plan, detailed in a set of two draft EU regulations on verification and monitoring of greenhouse gases, comes amid an ongoing controversy over the potential negative effects of biofuels on the environment.
It also comes amid growing concern that Europe's cap-and-trade scheme for airlines could trigger a full-scale commercial war with the US and China, which are opposed to the airline charge.
The draft legislation gives European industries details on how they should report about greenhouse gases covered by the EU's flagship emissions trading scheme (EU-ETS).
Among those is a requirement for airlines to list "the amount of biomass used as a fuel," broken down on a yearly basis. The airlines' biofuel consumption should come "as an annex to the annual emission report," the draft reads.
The two draft texts still need approval by EU member states and the European Parliament before they become law.
Isaac Valero Ladron, European Commission spokesperson for climate change issues, told EurActiv that the aim is to provide incentives for airlines to use more biofuels, assuming that those have "a zero-emissions factor".
"Under the EU ETS we provide a financial incentive for the use of biofuels in aviation, as use of biofuels has a zero-emissions factor, which means that no allowances need to be surrendered," Ladron told EurActiv in e-mailed comments.
"This means the biofuels have a subsidy equivalent to the prevailing carbon price," he explained, describing the scheme as "a cost-effective incentive as the subsidy for biofuels is equivalent to the cost of reducing emissions in other sectors."
Carbon reduction pledge
Airlines see biofuels as a crucial part of their commitment to achieving "carbon-neutral growth" by 2020. The International Air Transport Association (IATA) has set a target of ramping up biofuels use to 10% of all consumption by 2017, saying that they have the potential to reduce the industry's carbon footprint by up to 80%.
For US planemaker Boeing, biofuels will be essential to achieving the airline's pledge for carbon-neutral growth.
"Without biofuels, we cannot get there. It is a vital contribution," Antonio De Palmas, Boeing's president for EU and NATO relations, said in a 2011 interview with EurActiv.
Land use issue still not resolved
The Commission indicates that the European aviation carbon-reduction scheme will only account biofuels that respect the EU-certified sustainability schemes.
"Sustainable biofuels are fuels which achieve higher greenhouse gas savings compared to the average fossil fuel, and are not be cultivated on the land with high biodiversity value or on the peatland which has a high carbon stock," Ladron said.
However, green activists warned there was no guarantee that biofuels used in planes will not contribute to so-called Indirect Land Use Change (ILUC) – a process whereby displaced human activity caused by converting forests and grasslands to biofuels production results in additional CO2 emissions.
"It's good that the sustainability criteria have been extended to cover the ETS, but as long as ILUC is not included there is no guarantee of actual emissions reductions," said Dudley Curtis, from Transport & Environment, a green NGO.
Ladron acknowledged this shortcoming in the EU's biofuels policy, telling EurActiv that "discussions ILUC are still going on" within the European Commission.
The EU executive has postponed several times its proposal on ILUC, which is now expected in the spring.
As of January 2012, all airlines flying in Europe are included in the EU's Emissions Trading System for greenhouse gases, which imposes a cap on CO2 emissions for all planes arriving at or departing from EU airports (see EurActiv LinksDossier on aviation's inclusion in the EU-ETS).
The International Air Transport Association (IATA) has set a target of ramping up biofuels use to 10% of all consumption by 2017, saying that they have the potential to reduce the industry's footprint by up to 80% (see EurActiv LinksDossier on aviation biofuels).
Aviation accounts for around 3% of mankind's greenhouse gas pollution. The Internantional Civil Aviation Organization predicts the number of air passengers will hit 6 billion a year on scheduled services by 2030, roughly double today's level.
Dudley Curtis, Communications Manager at Transport & Environment, a green NGO, said it was "good that the sustainability criteria have been extended to cover the ETS".
However, he warned that "as long as ILUC is not included there is no guarantee of actual emissions reductions. There is also a danger that the aviation industry is getting distracted with swapping the fuel rather than using less of it."
Curtis also stressed the importance of fuel efficiency standards in tackling the aviation sector's growing carbon emissions and called on the International Civil Aviation Organisation (ICAO) to address the issue.
"In recent years, engineering improvements have been used for flying farther and faster with heavier payloads – with a trade-off for fuel efficiency. A thirty-year-old Boeing 757-200 holds its own with the most popular modern jets. Clearly we need a meaningful fuel efficiency standard to be agreed by ICAO as soon as possible. It's worth pointing out that IMO, the shipping regulator, agreed its energy efficiency design index (EEDI) for new ships last year, so ICAO has some catching up to do."
- The two regulations will become law after receiving approval EU countries and the European Parliament under the so-called "comitology" procedure.
- 2013: Two regulations due to come into force, coinciding with the third trading period of the EU ETS.