EurActiv Logo
EU news & policy debates
- across languages -
Click here for EU news »
EurActiv.com Network

BROWSE ALL SECTIONS

Commission waters down CO2 proposal for vans

Printer-friendly version
Send by email
Published 29 October 2009

The European Commission has caved in to industry and member-state pressure and significantly backtracked on earlier ambitions to introduce legally-binding CO2 cuts for new vans and minibuses.

The Commission presented a draft EU regulation to reduce average CO2 emissions from new vans yesterday (28 October). 

According to the EU executive, vans account for around 12% of the market for light-duty vehicles and should therefore be covered by its strategy to reduce vehicle emissions. 

Yesterday's proposal follows similar legislation governing CO2 emissions from passenger cars, which was agreed last year and came into force in April 2009 (EurActiv 02/12/08).

The draft proposes a 175g CO2/km limit for new vans registered in the EU from 2016. While the proposed limit is the same as in earlier drafts, manufacturers have been given four more years to comply, with earlier proposals imposing the target from 2012. CO2 emissions from vans currently average 200g/km. 

A further intermediate limit of 160g/km for 2016 was also dropped.

The 2020 target is set at 135g CO2/km, but may not be mandatory as suggested by previous drafts. 

Phase-in period

The Commission is proposing that the 175g CO2/km target be phased in from 2014 according to indicative emissions established for each van according to its weight, based on an emissions limit curve in the draft regulation. Each manufacturer's target will be calculated "as the average of the indicative emissions of all the vans for which it is responsible in a given year," the proposal reads. 

The draft proposes that from 2014, manufacturers must ensure that 75% of their vehicles have average emissions below their target of 80% as of 2015. 

Only fleet average regulated

The draft regulation's limit value curve is set in such a way that a fleet-wide average of 175g CO2/km is achieved for the EU as a whole. 

This means that only the fleet average is regulated, allowing manufacturers to make vehicles with emissions above the limit value curve "provided these are balanced by other vehicles which are below the curve". 

Lower fines 

The proposal foresees penalties for auto makers that fail to comply with the regulation. But "most manufacturers are expected to meet the target set by the legislation, so significant penalties should be avoided," the Commission stated.

The fines will vary according to "the degree of exceedance" of a manufacturer's average emission limit levels. Fines are proposed amounting to €5 for the first excess gramme, €15 for the second, €25 for the third and €120 for subsequent grammes. 

An earlier draft had set the fine at €120 per excess gramme.

Industry lobbying pays off 

Earlier this month, France, Germany and Italy called on the EU executive to weaken or delay the proposals, arguing that the time was not right to impose such measures (EurActiv 14/10/09). EU Industry Commissioner Günter Verheugen also backed powerful automakers' calls to soften the proposal.

The industry had also hoped to see the dossier handed over to the next Commission, but environmental NGOs like Greenpeace and Transport & Environment (T&E) lobbied heavily for it to be published by the current one.

Positions: 

The European Automobile Manufacturers' Association  (ACEA) argued that the Commission should have left the dossier to the next team, instead of seeking to introduce "new, costly regulation during the crisis".

ACEA stated that the proposal "disregards the economic reality as well as the specific characteristics of the vehicle segment concerned," stressing that it "must become much more tailored to the specific vehicle segment concerned and take into account the major differences with passenger cars". 

ACEA Secretary-General Ivan Hodac regretted the proposal's focus on technologies "regardless of the market situation or customer needs" and its ignorance of "the different uses of the vehicles concerned".

Environmental NGO Transport & Environment  (T&E) regretted that the Commission had bended to industry and car-producing countries' pressure and backed down from its earlier ambitions.

It said that the 175g CO2/km target for 2016 represents only "a 14% reduction over nine years on the 2007 level of 203g/km" while "the best diesel cars have improved by up to 27% over the last two years". T&E argues that the technology developed for cars can also be used for vans to make quicker savings.

It also criticised the 2014-2016 phase-in period, which "effectively allows van manufacturers to only declare their cleanest models".

Another NGO, Greenpeace, described the proposal as "bitterly disappointing" and accused the Commission of "blatantly ignoring its own decarbonisation strategy". 

Background: 

In July 2008, the European Commission announced it would present legislation on reducing the CO2 emissions of new vans and minibuses as part of a new package on 'Greening transport'

A February 2007 strategy paper sets "the objective of reaching 175g/km CO2 by 2012 and 160g/km CO2 by 2015". In 2007, the average emissions level from vans was 203gr/km. 

An EU deal on binding CO2 cuts from new passenger vehicles was reached late last year (EurActiv 02/12/08). The new law sets a target of reducing the average CO2 emissions from new cars to 130g/km by 2015 and to 95g/km by 2020. 

More on this topic

More in this section

Advertising

Sponsors

Videos

Video General News

Euractiv Sidebar Video Player for use in section aware blocks.

Transport Promoted videos

Euractiv Sidebar Video Player for use in section aware blocks.

Advertising

Advertising