EurActiv Logo
EU news & policy debates
- across languages -
Click here for EU news »
EurActiv.com Network

BROWSE ALL SECTIONS

EU to fast-track 'single sky' after a week of air travel chaos

Published 26 April 2010
Printer-friendly versionSend by email

European Transport Commissioner Siim Kallas will this week present recommendations building on the lessons learned from a week of aviation chaos caused by the eruption of volcanic ash from an Icelandic volcano.

Unifying Europe's airspace will top the list of proposals ahead of an extraordinary meeting of EU transport ministers on 4 May.

The meeting, to be held in Brussels, will address the economic impact of the crisis on the airline industry and other economic sectors such as tourism, the Spanish EU Presidency said.

"We need a fast coordinated European response to such crises," said Kallas. "Instead we have a fragmented patchwork of 27 national airspaces. Without a central regulator, Europe was operating with one hand behind its back."

Kallas' predecessors have been trying to unite Europe's airspace for the last decade under the 'Single Sky' package, which would streamline the 27 national airspaces to just nine by June 2012.

"I don't think we can afford to wait that long," said Kallas. "I want to start work to fast-track the Single Sky project."

Previous efforts have been hampered by member states' reluctance to cede control.

Passenger rights

Airlines have reluctantly swallowed the lost revenues and their own heavy fixed costs over the last week, but low-cost airlines are less compliant about EU laws forcing them to pick up hotel and restaurant bills for stranded passengers.

Ryanair's combative chief executive Michael O'Leary initially challenged the EU passenger rights law "EU 261".

But he later backed down once it became clear that EU lawyers had gone into painstaking detail to force airlines to provide everything a passenger might need, right down to "two telephone calls, telex or fax messages".

"The airlines are required by regulation to meet potentially unlimited expenses," O'Leary complained, as Ryanair announced on Thursday it would be reimbursing expenses after all.

"We will continue to work [...] to persuade the European Commission and the European Parliament to alter this regulation to put this reasonable limit on these reimbursement claims," he added.

At the time the law was set in 2004, airlines warned it could have painful consequences if airspace was shut down as it has been in the last week, but politicians ignored them, says the European Low Fares Airlines Association (ELFAA).

"Its application now is transforming a crisis into an economic catastrophe," ELFAA said in a statement.

No discount

But Kallas rejected the challenge by low-cost airlines. "EU law must be respected," he told reporters. "There are no discount passenger rights for discount airlines."

Regulation EU 261 does relieve airlines of their obligations in "extraordinary circumstances". "Such circumstances may, in particular, occur in cases of [...] meteorological conditions incompatible with the operation of the flight concerned," it says.

But close examination of the legal small print reveals that exemptions only apply to cash compensation, not to cost of caring for passengers. That is inescapable.

The proper channel for airlines to recover their costs would be by applying for state aid, just as they did after the flight disruption in the wake of the Sept. 11 attacks.

But Kallas warned that the European Commission would not blindly wave through overblown state aid claims.

"I am an economist, and I see the immense creative force that has been put behind calculations of losses," he said. "This is normal. If I were on the side of those suffering, I would go to maximum efforts to show my trouble is as big as possible."

Economic consequences

Last week, the EU's competition chief Joaquin Almunia, said the European Commission may allow European Union governments to provide aid to airlines hit by a severe loss of revenue due to the volcanic ash cloud.

Some are talking about a bailout package to rescue the airline industry similar to the one agreed for the banking sector in 2008.

"The scale of the economic impact [on aviation] is now greater than 9/11, when US airspace was closed for three days," International Air Transport Association (IATA) head Giovanni Bisignani said. "This crisis is costing airlines at least $200 million a day in lost revenues and the European economy is suffering billions of dollars in lost business," he added.

Globally, the airline industry says the crisis had cost it about $1.7 billion in lost revenue, though it also saved some $660 million in costs such as fuel.

(EurActiv with Reuters.)

Positions: 

The International Air Transport Association (IATA) said it fully supported moves to fast-track the implementation of the Single European Sky. "The volcanic ash crisis that paralysed European air transport for nearly a week made it crystal clear that the Single European Sky is a critical missing link in Europe's infrastructure," said IATA Director General and CEO Giovanni Bisignani.

"We have been discussing the Single European Sky for decades. It was a priority of the European Commission as far back as the early 1990s when I was chairman of the Association of European Airlines. The technical plans are in place. The 4 May meeting must back up the technical preparations with an implementation time line for a fully integrated Single European Sky and the political will to achieve it."

According to IATA, the Single European Sky is much broader than a crisis management mechanism. "It will improve Europe's competitiveness and environmental performance.  The inefficiency of the current system is a €5 billion burden on Europe's economy and wastes 16 million tonnes of CO2 in delays and indirect routings."

The European Low Fare Airline Association (ELFAA) said it believes that a "disruption on this scale, for this duration and involving so many disrupted passengers, should probably only be addressed by governments".

"It was governments which took the decision to close airspace for nigh on a week and governments must assume their responsibilities to citizens, directly affected as a result of their decisions."

The Association of European Airlines (AEA) said common sense must prevail in compensating stranded passengers for accrued costs, such as hotel nights. "European airline passengers benefit from an extraordinarily generous package of rights," said AEA Secretary General Ulrich Schulte-Strathaus, "more generous than in any other part of the world, and more generous than for other modes of transport. But these rules, which AEA airlines respect, were designed for an event horizon encompassing isolated incidents, involving individual airlines, not a prolonged disruption of all services".

"Common sense must prevail”, he said. "Industry passengers are suffering from the consequences of a natural phenomenon. What is required, as with any other similar natural event, is EU solidarity. Passengers affected by this crisis should be recompensed through appropriate public funds".

European airline associations have called for urgent relief measures to help the industry cope with the crisis. In a joint statement, the European Low Fares Airline Association (ELFAA), the European Regions Airlines Association (ERA) and the International Air Carrier Association (IACA) called for governments and the EU to "give a firm commitment to support" their industry.

"European governments cannot ignore the massive economic consequences of their decisions on airlines. Airlines are doing their utmost to take care of passengers and assist with the safe repatriation of passengers, according to their obligations under Regulation 261/2004. However, airlines need further support to assist them with this huge task and European governments cannot shirk their responsibility to passengers affected by their decision."

In the European Parliament, a row broke out last week over compensation to the airline sector. The Socialists and Democrats (S&D) group called on the EU to show solidarity with stranded passengers, not just airlines. "This is the moment for the EU to show that it is there to help its citizens and that it is a union about people, not just about markets," said Said El Khadraoui, transport spokesman for the S&D group.

The S&D group said it would call on the European Commission to reconsider its decision not to use the EU solidarity fund to help repatriate stranded passengers around the globe.

Christine de Veyrac, a centre-right French MEP (European People's Party), criticised the attitude of airlines in addressing the crisis, some of which have asked for European airspace to be reopened immediately. She stressed that aid to companies, if granted, "should be conditioned to exemplarity in passenger compensation". 

For the Alliance of Liberals and Democrats (ALDE), the air transport chaos of last week "presents an opportunity to strengthen European coordination". "For 20 years we have been discussing the completion of a single market for transport and a Single European Sky but there is nothing like a crisis to stimulate change and reform," said Gesine Meissner MEP (FDP, Germany).

"For many years the Council has resisted greater European involvement in the management of airspace yet the air transport sector, above all, transcends national boundaries and demands a coordinated approach," added Dirk Sterckx MEP (OpenVLD, Belgium). "It must now be obvious to all that no single country can find an adequate response alone."

"European airspace coordination consequently needs to be strengthened and a European centre, preferably within the framework of the European Air Safety agency, established where all data on airspace can come together and emergency plans can be drawn up and coordinated."

Next steps: 
  • 4 May 2010: Extraordinary meeting of transport ministers in Brussels to address economic fallout of crisis. 
Background: 

The eruption of a volcano in Iceland provoked mass disruption on Thursday 15 April as a cloud of ash brought air traffic in Northern Europe to a standstill (EurActiv 15/04/10).

Flights started to resume slowly on Tuesday 20 April, under a deal agreed by the European Union to gradually free up airspace (EurActiv 20/04/10).

But the economic fallout of the crisis is still uncertain and will be the main topic on the agenda of a meeting of transport ministers on 4 May.

More on this topic

More in this section

Advertising