EurActiv Logo
EU news & policy debates
- across languages -
Click here for EU news »
EurActiv.com Network

BROWSE ALL SECTIONS

India, 25 others oppose EU airline carbon charge plan

Printer-friendly version
Send by email
Published 04 October 2011

European Union plans to charge airlines for carbon emissions are "discriminatory" and violate global laws, a group of 26 countries including the United States and China, according to a joint declaration.

India, which hosted a two-day meeting in New Delhi this week, said delegates from the non-EU countries, which are also members of the U.N.'s International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO) executive council, agreed to lodge a formal protest against the EU's new rules at the council's next meeting.

"There was wide concern expressed by all countries present, without exception, that the unilaterally imposed EU (emissions trading scheme) measures were inconsistent with the international legal regimes," the statement said.

"The legal infirmities in the EU laws were pointed out. It was stated by the various delegates that they were also discriminatory (to) carriers."

The EU says it needs to put a price on carbon dioxide (CO2) emissions to guard against future climate impacts such as crop failures, droughts or flooding.

It has launched an emissions trading scheme ETS.L to help it cut carbon dioxide emissions, which it has pledged to reduce by 20 percent below 1990 levels by 2020.

From January 2012, airlines flying into or out of EU airports will have to surrender permits to cover all the CO2 they emit during the entire flight. They join some 11,000 factories and power plants already in the $100 billion market (roughly €75 bn).

ICAO said the issue of aviation in the EU ETS is on the agenda for the 190-nation body's next meeting in November, where the group of 26 countries said they will submit a working paper along with their joint declaration in opposition of the scheme.

Critics including the 26 opposing governments have called the "unilateral" scheme illegal, saying it violates the Chicago Convention on international aviation as well as some provisions under the World Trade Organisation (WTO).

Three U.S. airlines are currently challenging the EU plans in Europe's highest court, which is due to give its first opinion on the case on October 6.

Not backing down

Although opposition to the EU's aviation rules is getting more vociferous, the bloc's executive shows no signs of yielding.

"The EU is not considering backing down," an EU spokesman told Reuters, adding that the bloc's executive encourages other countries to instead adopt similar emissions reduction goals.

The EU maintains that it could exempt airlines from countries that have adopted climate policies deemed equivalent to Europe's targets.

But some nations have scoffed at the offer and retaliated instead through other means, saying aviation should be regulated on a global level through measures approved by all ICAO members.

China blocked a $3.8 billion (€2.8 bn) aircraft purchase by Hong Kong Airlines from France-based Airbus at the Paris air show in June, sources said, adding to fears of a brewing trade war.

(EurActiv with Reuters)

COMMENTS

  •  Let's be frank - ALL airlines HAVE already registered (a handful "under protest" admittedly) for free allowances within the scope of the EU ETS aviation regulations; they have also invested in all the necessary monitoring and verification software to participate; most are already operating in the carbon market through both in-house and external systems, advisors and traders; and all the airlines of the 26 states who signed up to this pretty meaningless declaration have done so too without exception. One or two airlines have already been fined by EU member state's regulators for missing deadlines in the run-up to the ETS January 2012 start date, so perhaps now is a good time to remind airlines of the heavyweight, some might say draconian, financial penalties for any future non-compliance which could potentially bankrupt even the world's largest airlines. We know that airlines are very aware of these penalties and many of them have said publicly that they do not intend to break any ETS-related laws at several meetings and events I have attended, although they oppose the scheme. There is a substantial degree of desperate last-minute posturing and grandstanding to try and avoid practical and fair market-based environment protection solutions from IATA and countries who should know better - the recent presentation to ICAO in Montreal from the EC's Artur Runge-Metzger, International and Climate Strategy Director, easily found on the web, is a welcome and very clear explanation of where are right now and why the EU ETS is a fair and equitable policy. Using this scheme as the global model is the way forward. Those states trying to avoid the fairly "light touch" ETS regulation in this latest bit of institutionalised moaning, are misguided and out-of-touch with the reality of the urgent need for action to control and reduce the climate change impacts of civil aviation. Which is all the more difficult to understand when many are in the frontline of the fight against climate change right now. The EU is not going to capitulate and has the support of environment NGO's everywhere - covering around a third of aviation's global CO2 emissions is a stunning achievement and needs support and expansion, not arrogant whingeing from the industry's flat earthers. If you can afford the cost of a ticket, you can afford the cost of carbon. Jeff Gazzard Aviation Environment Federation LONDON

    By :
    Jeff Gazzard
    - Posted on :
    05/10/2011
  • Once again, the new world order types want to impose their view of what should happen to the rest of us. Why must the U.S. relinquish its rights & be subject to international law dictated by countries that can't balance their own budget, have rampant riots in their countries. I thought plants used CO2 during photosynthesis so the whole idea of it being a toxic chemical is ridiculous. And Jeff Gazzard, who is getting rich off these carbon offsets? Investigate that.

    By :
    Anonymous
    - Posted on :
    07/10/2011

Advertising

Sponsors

Videos

Video General News

Euractiv Sidebar Video Player for use in section aware blocks.

Transport Promoted videos

Euractiv Sidebar Video Player for use in section aware blocks.

Advertising

Advertising