EurActiv Logo
EU news & policy debates
- across languages -
Click here for EU news »
EurActiv.com Network

BROWSE ALL SECTIONS

Eurosceptics give Cameron 'three cheers' for EU budget win

Printer-friendly version
Send by email
Published 11 February 2013

British Prime Minister David Cameron won praise from his party's anti-EU camp with a successful fight to cut the European Union budget.

For the first time, the EU’s long-term budget will be cut in real terms despite the Union's expanded responsibilities and enlargement from 27 to 28 countries.

Supporters hailed the outcome as an "historic victory" for Cameron, comparing it to former Conservative leader Margaret Thatcher's winning of concessions from Europe at fiercely contested summits in the 1980s.

Cameron, trailing in the polls and threatened by anti-EU rivals before a 2015 election, needed a win in Brussels to restore his authority on Europe and within his fractious party.

The opposition Labour Party said his January pledge to claw back powers from the EU and give British voters a referendum on leaving the bloc had left him "weak and isolated" in the EU.

After leaders secured a deal for a long-term EU budget worth close to €1 trillion, Cameron stressed his success in forging alliances with the Netherlands, Denmark, Sweden, and, to a lesser extent, Germany.

"That is not isolation. That is Britain actually with allies, getting things done in Europe and coming with good results," he told a news conference.

Crucially for a domestic audience, Cameron protected Britain's rebate, a prized refund from the EU to London secured by Thatcher worth €3.5 billion a year.

'Three cheers'

One leading eurosceptic Conservative lawmaker, Douglas Carswell, said Cameron deserved "three hearty cheers".

Taking the gloss off the deal was the news that Britain's net contribution to EU funds will still rise to help pay for new members of the bloc.

While Cameron won this round of the EU debate, it came at the expense of again upsetting France and some other European neighbours. French President François Hollande vehemently opposed Cameron, warning that cuts would damage the recovery.

British officials said Hollande failed to turn up for a scheduled meeting with Cameron at the talks – an assertion promptly dismissed by the French. The denial did not stop British newspapers talking about "Le Snub".

More trouble for the budget lies ahead at the European Parliament, which must approve the plan. Its Deputy President Othmar Karas said it would stifle growth and must be blocked.

Despite offering some support to Britain on the budget, German Chancellor Angela Merkel will be a far more formidable obstacle on the repatriation of powers to London in areas like employment law, crime and social welfare. One of her senior ministers has said Cameron will not be allowed to "cherry pick".

"Merkel thrives on her role as a broker," said Raoul Ruparel, of the eurosceptic think tank Open Europe. "The lesson for the UK is that win enough support for your position among like-minded member states and Germany will back you."

EurActiv.com with Reuters

COMMENTS

  • This is a "win" for NO one! Cameron is a right wing loser!

    Britain ought to LEAVE: then the EU could resume its progress to further integration without the "financial services" parasites(Wall st toadies) of "The City".

    By :
    david tarbuck
    - Posted on :
    11/02/2013
  • @david tarbuck
    The UK will not stand in the way of integration for the Eurozone but you're right that the march to a European superstate is blocked whilst it remains. However, the evidence seems to be that the majority of states prefer the UK in to the superstate.

    Perhaps this is because the UK is quite European minded despite the apparent perception. Go to the ECFR website and look at their scorecard on contributions of different countries to European foreign policy objectives. The UK has one of the highest scores Observe which country was the first to lend assistance to the French in Mali.Notice that the UK has substantially increased its contribution this year to the European state agency.

    The UK does not have a problem with European co=operation. It has a problem with Euro federalism and Brussels.

    By :
    Martin
    - Posted on :
    11/02/2013
  • @Martin. This supposed difference between "federalism" and "European cooperation" is false. With a Union approaching 28, decision making must be streamlined, this is all federalmism really is. A simplification and steamlining of the overall Union. Its sold in the UK as the end of liberty, yet the UK is almost a federal state itself, with devolved Parliaments in Northen Irealand and Scotland, and the Assembly in Wales.

    By :
    Antipopulist
    - Posted on :
    12/02/2013
  • I gotta agree with the UK on this one ... the EU bubble has been blown way out of proportion and is not serving those it was initially meant to serve: EU citizens. Instead, EU taxpayers are forced to sponsor the lavish lifestyles of a European elite that hasn't noticed that there is a financial crisis outside of the walls of the EU institutions going on. EU salaries are a disgrace, the institutions are not transparent in how they conduct their hiring (just having concours doesn't mean people that passed them will get off the reserve lists) and which policies in the EU framework actually benefit European citizens? The main concern should be to combat (particularly youth!) unemployment and strengthen the economy, rather than unilaterally serving the banking and farming industries. The UK is merely expressing the discontent with this arrangement, although admittedly for its own reasons...

    By :
    BM
    - Posted on :
    13/02/2013
  • A defeat for European Union including Britain in favour to Merkameron !

    80 Years and still "pussyfooting" on an equal justice federal europe !
    The U.S. did his Union called the United States with a real federal Budget in ONE DAY in signing a convent in Philadelphia !
    Today they still have a powerfull economy and less employement than here in Europe still raising and an economy which soon falls below it's redline!

    What are the 27 GOV's doing ? Nothing because they don't have that democracially european spirit!
    So the global eu-economie line will continuing to drop even until collapsing !

    There is an example to take from the U.S ! and not anymore from this fable unelected Council with this unanimiously agreement between th 27 Heads of Gov in favour to Britain and bypassing the parliament!

    IT's an European Union ending story If Britain remains "inside" the EU!
    The integration will never push forward with GB .

    So it should be the beginning of an new financial institute inside Europe and not on an island whith such an antieuropean Spirit !

    So finally who is it? Surely It's not about the EU....

    By :
    an european
    - Posted on :
    15/02/2013
  • @an european
    The greatest damage done to your European Dream has not been done by the UK but by the problems in the Eurozone. My impression is that, at least in a mild form, Euroscepticism is widespread in many countries including Germany. The German taxpayer has looked at the implication of a fully federal Europe and has decided that they do not want it. They have paid to support East Germany and they are reluctant to support Club Med as well.

    it's merely convenient to blame the British and avoid confronting more fundamental problems.

    By :
    Martin
    - Posted on :
    15/02/2013
The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
Background: 

After 24 hours of talks, EU leaders struck a deal on the Union's seven-year budget at a meeting on 7-8 February.

The 2014-2020 EU budget is smaller than it was in 2007-2013. It goes down to 1% from 1.12% of EU gross national income (GNI).

It is the first net reduction to the EU budget in the Union’s history. 

The EU leaders’ agreement sets the figure for “commitments” – the maximum amount of money allotted during the seven-year period – at €960 billion, while budget “payments” – the amount of money that can actually be spent – were reduced by €34 billion to €908.4 billion.

More on this topic

More in this section

Advertising

Videos

Video General News

Euractiv Sidebar Video Player for use in section aware blocks.

Video General Promoted 2

Euractiv Sidebar Video Player for use in section aware blocks.

Advertising

Advertising