EU investigates Qualcomm over radio-frequency chips

The European Union is investigating whether Qualcomm engaged in anti-competitive behavior by leveraging its market position in 5G modem chips in the radio frequency chip market. [Shutterstock]

Qualcomm Inc on Wednesday (5 February) detailed the first significant sales gains from a new category of chip it is selling to mobile phone makers, but also disclosed that an antitrust investigation has started around those chips.

The European Union is investigating whether Qualcomm engaged in anti-competitive behavior by leveraging its market position in 5G modem chips in the radio frequency chip market, the San Diego company said on Wednesday in a regulatory filing.

The disclosure comes after the company spent years battling regulators – and paid billions of dollars in fines – over allegations that it engaged in anticompetitive patent licensing practices. Qualcomm last year lost a case brought by the US Federal Trade Commission and remains locked in an appeal.

Qualcomm supplies “modem” chips, also sometimes called baseband processors, that connect mobile phones to wireless data networks.

But the company is also expanding into a related field called radio frequency front-end chips, which have become more complex in phones that use 5G networks.

5G rollout will lead to an 'increased exposure to attacks,' EU says

5G security standards are set to be bolstered across the EU, amid fears that non-EU states may be trying to infiltrate the bloc’s next-generation mobile technology networks. The EU has, however, pledged not to exclude any specific suppliers, despite heavy US pressure against the Chinese telecommunications giant Huawei.

Qualcomm has been trying to persuade phone makers to buy its radio frequency chips, together with its own modem chips, rather than selecting parts from separate vendors and integrating them.

Other major suppliers of radio frequency chips are Broadcom Inc, Skyworks Solutions Inc and Qorvo Inc.

Qualcomm executives said on Wednesday that revenue from the radio frequency market contributed to a sales forecast that beat analyst expectations.

In Wednesday’s filing, Qualcomm said it was in the process of responding to a probe by the European Commission, the EU’s executive branch, after it served a request for information with the company on Dec. 3.

Qualcomm said the commission could impose a fine of up to 10% of its annual revenue if a violation were found.

Qualcomm was fined €242 million by the European Commission in July last year for blocking a rival from the market about a decade ago, its second EU antitrust penalty. The Commission had also fined Qualcomm €997 million during 2018 for paying iPhone maker Apple to use only its chips, a tactic aimed at thwarting rivals including Intel Corp.

Commission fines Qualcomm €242 million over predatory pricing

EU antitrust authority fined €242 million Qualcomm due to the application of predatory prices, resulting in a breach of competition law, Commissioner Margrethe Vestager announced on Thursday (18 July).

Qualcomm has won radio frequency chip contracts with Samsung Electronics Co Ltd, Alphabet Inc’s Google and LG Electronics Inc, among others.

Analysts said the EU investigation was unlikely to slow Qualcomm’s progress in the radio frequency chip market.

“Qualcomm has been penalized many times for anti-competitive practices. It’s one of the risks of the story,” said Chaim Siegel, an analyst at Elazar Advisors. “They have market clout because their technology is much better than the competition.”

The Capitals Special: Europe's 5G dilemma

EU ministers adopted conclusions on Tuesday concerning the importance and security of 5G technology, which stress that an approach to 5G cybersecurity should be comprehensive and risk-based, while also taking into account ‘non-technical factors’.

Subscribe to our newsletters