French minister: A glyphosate ban now would put some farmers out of business

The herbicide glyphosate is still controversial; shown here in the form of Monsanto’s Roundup product. [shutterstock/Pixavril]

France’s Agriculture Minister Didier Guillaume has come out in defence of the decision to postpone the glyphosate ban until 2020, saying that a number of farmers would be unable to carry on if the governemnt had already enforced the ban.

“If we had outlawed glyphosate, today a certain number of farmers would not be able to go on,” Ouest-France quoted Guillaume as saying, adding that his intention was to avoid a “harsh debate” between legislators and the majority of citizens.

In September, French lawmakers refused to add a glyphosate ban in an agriculture and food bill amid lack of an alternative. French President Emmanuel Macron has promised to phase out glyphosate within three years, by 2020.

“Some politicians spoke loudly against glyphosate before their elections but came back to reality later on,” EU Commissioner for Health and Food Safety, Vytenis Andriukaitis, recently told in an interview.

EU health chief: Some politicians spoke too ‘loudly’ against glyphosate before elections

Some politicians spoke loudly before the election proposing to immediately ban glyphosate, but after the election, they were “welcomed to reality”, Andriukaitis said.

Guillaume reiterated the government’s commitment to phase out glyphosate but left the door open for a postponement for some months.

“We are two and a half years from this deadline, if it’s three years and a few months, this is not an issue,” he said.

French MEP Angélique Delahaye warned in October 2017 that it would be very difficult, but not impossible, to find an alternative to glyphosate.

“Member states should not be hypocrites suggesting an immediate ban and simultaneously tell farmers not to be afraid, ‘we will find a solution’ […] this is not pragmatic,” Delahaye told EURACTIV.

Glyphosate is a chemical substance that has created a heated debate in Brussels. It’s the main substance of the world’s most commonly used weedkiller, Monsanto’s Roundup.

Food safety authorities across the world have said glyphosate does not cause cancer if used properly. The World Health Organisation (WHO), the European Food Safety Authority (EFSA) and the European Chemicals Agency (ECHA) have all given their green light for the use of the weedkiller.

The one body that said glyphosate is “probably carcinogenic” is the International Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC). Based on that, several environmental activists have launched campaigns to ban glyphosate use in Europe.

The industry said EU policymakers should base their decisions on scientific evidence and avoid emotionalising a purely science issue, while NGOs point out that the glyphosate case is a cause of conflict among scientists.

Following strong reactions from the civil society, the European Commission and member states decided in November to re-authorise glyphosate for 5 years.

EU renews glyphosate for five years as Germany swings the balance

A much-awaited qualified majority of EU member states was reached today (27 November) for the re-authorisation of the world’s most commonly used weedkiller, glyphosate.

Subscribe to our newsletters