Around a quarter of a million Poles flooded central Warsaw on Saturday (7 May), marching to defend their country’s place in the European Union and protest against moves by the right-wing government, which they claim undermines democracy.
Warsaw city hall said the march drew around 240,000 people, making it one of the largest demonstrations since the 1989 collapse of Communism in Poland.
The mammoth protest came about as an annual pro-EU parade merged with a demonstration called by a coalition of pro-democracy groups and opposition parties.
Shouting “freedom, equality, democracy”, the mass of marchers inched their way through the sun-drenched city centre, brandishing a mix of red-and-white Polish flags with blue and gold EU flags.
“We’re here because we want to fight for Poland’s freedom, for democracy,” former president Bronislaw Komorowski, a liberal, told marchers as the demonstration got under way.
The protest comes amid a mounting political crisis in the central European heavyweight, triggered by changes the populist-oriented right-wing Law and Justice (PiS) government has made to the constitutional court.
In December it pushed through legislation to stack the court and modify its decision-making rules.
The court itself struck down the changes as unconstitutional in March, pitting it against the PiS majority government, which wasted no time in dismissing the ruling.
The resulting deadlock means the court is paralysed, leaving Poland without a fundamental check on government powers.
Poland’s Constitutional Court on Wednesday (9 March) struck down a set of government reforms concerning its judges that have paralysed the EU member state’s top court, sparking a constitutional crisis.
“What’s happening right now is a violation of the rights of Poles, the destruction of the rule of law and a violation of the constitution,” marcher Rafal Zagorowski, a 60-year-old construction worker told AFP, referring to measures taken by the PiS government.
“I’m afraid that (PiS party leader Jaroslaw) Kaczynski will provoke a confrontation, that blood will be spilt.
“He’s a madman who doesn’t listen to anyone, doesn’t listen to Poles or obey the law.”
Although he holds no government post, Kaczynski is regarded as the real dealmaker in the government.
He insisted Saturday “there was no risk to democracy” in Poland and that the protest was due to the opposition’s bitterness over losing both the presidential and parliamentary elections last year.
“Those who are protesting today just want to stir the pot in Poland,” Kaczynski said.
Protester Danuta Grzymkowska however told AFP she was worried the ongoing political crisis could escalate into violence.
“Many believe this will become a Polish ‘Maidan’,” she told AFP, referring to the iconic square in Ukraine’s capital Kiev that was the scene of the country’s bloody pro-EU revolution in 2014 that led to the ouster of a pro-Russia regime.
“I really hope I’m wrong,” she added.
The PiS-led government’s changes to the constitutional court have not only sparked a string of large street protests at home but also drawn sharp criticism from Brussels and the European Parliament, which Warsaw has dismissed as unnecessary interference in its internal affairs.
In January, the EU’s executive Commission launched a “Rule of Law” procedure, which could result in a suspension of Poland’s voting rights.
MEPs passed today (13 April) a non-binding resolution, calling on the Polish authorities to restore the ability of Poland’s Constitutional Tribunal to uphold its Constitution and guarantee respect for the rule of law.
Since it swept to power in October elections, the PiS has also pushed through controversial measures that strengthen state controls over public broadcasters.
Last month, three former Polish presidents including Lech Walesa accused the PiS of destroying the country’s constitution, appealing to citizens to “defend democracy”.
Markets have also reacted strongly to the political turmoil, hitting Poland’s zloty currency and the Warsaw stock exchange.
Ultra-nationalist parties and sympathisers organised a counter-demonstration in the capital Saturday, drawing around 4,000 people, insisting that Poland’s EU membership meant it was subject to the “diktat of Brussels”.
Although recent PiS actions have chilled relations between Poland and European institutions, party leaders including Prime Minister Beata Szydlo and kingpin Kaczynski himself, have never gone so far as to question Warsaw’s membership of the bloc.
Polish President Andrzej Duda defied European Union criticism of his country’s government yesterday (24 April), accusing the bloc of showing “too little solidarity” with its eastern members.
New pro-EU coalition
Saturday’s march was organised by various pro-European groupings and parliamentary opposition parties, including the main centre-right opposition party, the Civic Platform (PO), and the liberal Modern (Nowoczesna) party, led by a former World Bank economist.
The “Liberty, Equality and Democracy” coalition was launched last week (5 May) with the declared aim of safeguarding the rule of law and Poland’s place in the European Union.
Several Polish opposition parties on Thursday (5 May) announced the creation of a coalition with the declared aim of safeguarding the rule of law and Poland’s place in the European Union.
While anti-government rallies are frequent, the PiS continues to enjoy strong popular support. A recent poll put it at 33%, only a few points down from October’s election, and still well ahead of the largest opposition party in parliament, the PO.
The PiS released a video on Saturday in which party leader leader Jaroslaw Kaczynski, twin brother of late president Lech Kaczynski, said that “today, being in Europe means being in the EU”.
“We want to be a member of the European Union, because we want to have an influence on Europe’s fate. But our position depends above all on our strength. We have to gain a strong position, become a strong, European nation,” Kaczynski said.
The European Commission took an unprecedented decision in January to activate the ‘Rule of Law mechanism’ against Poland for breaches to democracy and legal order. The mechanism was set up in March 2014 to tackle “systemic threats” to the rule of law and other cherished European values.
The process was launched after the country’s hard-right government pushed through changes to the judiciary and media over the Christmas break. The changes have triggered an outcry from civil rights watchdogs and prompted escalating warnings from the European Commission that it could intervene.
The European Commission announced on Sunday (3 January) that it would discuss the state of the rule of law in Poland after the country's hard-right government pushed through changes to the judiciary and media over the Christmas break.
A "dialogue" was launched between the Commission and Polish authorities. Ultimately, if there is no satisfactory response, the EU executive can propose invoking Article 7 of the Treaty of the European Union.
Under Article 7 of the Lisbon Treaty, serious breaches to the values of human dignity, freedom, democracy, equality, the rule of law and respect for human rights by a member state can result in a suspension or loss of voting rights in the EU Council of Ministers.
Vice-President of the European Commission Frans Timmermans was optimistic after a series of meetings with the Polish government. Yet Poland will continue to be monitored under the Rule of Law Framework.