German central banker pushes back on calls for ECB to fight climate change

Germany's National Bank President Jens Weidmann during the Economic and Financial Committee Meeting of EU Finance ministers and governors of Central Banks in Bucharest, Romania, 05 April 2019. [EPA-EFE/ROBERT GHEMENT]

Bundesbank chief Jens Weidmann on Thursday (28 November) batted back calls for the European Central Bank to take a bigger role in protecting the environment, saying it was up to goverments and not the ECB to fight climate change.

“Monetary policy that explicitly pursues environmental goals runs the risk of being overburdened,” Weidmann said in Berlin.

“Politicians with democratic legitimacy must decide how society should combat climate change and they must also bear the responsibility this.”

New ECB president Christine Lagarde has promised to discuss sustainability considerations in the bank’s upcoming strategic review.

Activists have also called on the ECB to use its vast purchase power to favour green assets and thus provide firms an incentive to invest in clean technology.

European Central Bank should ‘gradually eliminate’ carbon assets, Lagarde says

The European Central Bank should phase out climate-warming investments by preferring green bonds, Christine Lagarde said as she pitched to become the bank’s first female president. EURACTIV’s media partner Climate Home News reports.

The ECB has so far rejected these calls, arguing that its mandate to keep prices stable requires market neutrality, a premise Lagarde has also affirmed.

But the bank also said that its purchases fuelled a rapid growth in issuance as it bought up close to 20% of the eligible green bonds market, so even market neutral purchases were boosting green finance.

Weidmann, a frequent critic of the ECB’s bond purchases, said the ECB still had a role, for example in understanding the economic impact of climate change since extreme weather events could increase growth and inflation volatility.

He also said that banks, which are supervised by the ECB, must also incorporate climate change into their risk management.

Repeating his criticism of the ECB’s easy money policy, Weidmann said it risked fuelling bubbles and German house prices are now 15-30% overvalued but argued that he did not for now see a dangerous build up of risk in the sector.

Jens Weidmann – the anti-Draghi?

Next year, there will be a change at the helm of the European Central Bank (ECB). Speculation about Mario Draghi’s successor is in full swing. One controversial name is appearing over and over again: Jens Weidmann, the President of the Deutsche Bank. EURACTIV Germany reports.

There are other views on the subject of climate change at the ECB, however.

Even though central banks should not be at the forefront of fighting climate change, they must deal with its effects, such as lower demand for some cars, France’s ECB board member Benoît Coeuré said on Thursday.

“Central banks cannot be at the forefront in fighting climate change,” Coeuré said in Paris. “This is and should remain a political task. But they can help within their mandates.”

He added monetary policy can fight weakness in demand but it was not the right tool to address changing consumer preferences, such as a switch away from fossil fuel-driven cars.

Climate change will affect EU monetary policy ‘one way or the other’, ECB says

Whether humankind fails or succeeds in keeping the rise in global temperatures within manageable levels, central banks will sooner or later be called upon to act, said Benoît Cœuré, a member of the European Central Bank’s (ECB) Executive Board.

Subscribe to our newsletters

Subscribe

Want to know what's going on in the EU Capitals daily? Subscribe now to our new 9am newsletter.