Oil giant Total sued for ‘climate inaction’ in France’s first climate case

According to an evaluation carried out by several NGOs in 2019, French multinationals have only slightly complied with the law's requirement of preparing vigilance plans. EPA/DAI KUROKAWA

French oil group Total is responsible for 1% of the world’s CO2 emissions and failing to respect its so-called ‘corporate duty of vigilance’, according to a group of plaintiffs representing 14 local authorities and four NGOs who are bringing a case against the giant. EURACTIV France reports.

Fourteen French cities*, public establishment Est Ensemble and four NGOs, including Greenpeace and French law association Sherpa, are filing a complaint against the oil company for “climate inaction”.

This is the first time in France that a company has been accused of such an offence. However, it remains to be seen whether this will be recognised under the law, which is not necessarily guaranteed.

For Gérard Cosme, Est Ensemble’s president, “everyone must make this effort; otherwise, there is injustice!”. The public establishment Est Ensemble, which assembles nine cities of Seine-Saint-Denis, continues to multiply initiatives to reduce the carbon footprint of its inhabitants by promoting energy savings, renewable energy sources and waste recycling.

Total said it regretted the legal action and added it was working in compliance with national legal standards and remained “open to constructive talks”.

Dutch climate change ambition is insufficient, court confirms

A Dutch appeals court on Tuesday (9 October) instructed the government to cut greenhouse gas emissions at a faster rate than planned, meaning they will have to be 25% below 1990 levels by the end of this decade.

Cities and NGOs vs Total

The complaint against Total is based both on the Paris Climate Agreement, which France has signed, and on France’s corporate duty of vigilance law, which requires the largest companies to publish ‘vigilance plans’ in which they undertake to adopt measures to prevent human rights and environmental violations.

“Total is legally required to identify the risks that result from its contribution to global warming and to take the necessary measures to reduce its emissions,” according to Sandra Cossart, director of Sherpa, an NGO.

According to the plaintiffs’ calculations, Total has failed to do this, despite being responsible for emitting 1% of the world’s greenhouse gases, i.e. 458 million tonnes, an amount that even surpasses France’s total emissions.

The complaint also aims to force the oil company to align itself with the Paris agreement’s objective of limiting the global average temperature to a maximum of 1.5%.

“The law on the duty of vigilance concerns Total in terms of the risks the company poses to foreign populations,” said François de Cambiaire of the Paris law firm Seattle Avocats.

Total is already being sued for its activities in Uganda, where the company’s destruction of the environment has weakened territories and populations. In particular, the oil company is being sued for its plan to drill hundreds of oil wells in a nature park near Uganda’s Lake Albert.

“Justice can be a tool in these battles,” said Patrick Jarry, the mayor of the Paris suburb of Nanterre, where Total has its headquarters.

Climate campaigners taking on French state

Several NGOs are considering filing an application to the administrative court of Paris in 2019. However, French law may be more rigid than Anglo-Saxon law, which has already convicted several other states on this matter. EURACTIV France reports.

[Edited by Zoran Radosavljevic]

* Arcueil, Bayonne, Bègles, Bize-Minervois, Champneuville, Centre Val de Loire, Correns, Est-Ensemble Grand Paris, Grenoble, La Possession, Mouans-Sartoux, Nanterre, Sevran and Vitry-le-François.


Life Terra

Funded by the LIFE Programme of the EU

The content of this publication represents the views of the author only and is his/her sole responsibility. The Agency does not accept any responsibility for use that may be made of the information it contains.

Subscribe to our newsletters