Court rules Greek government-led auction on TV licences is flawed

Greek Prime Minister Alexis Tsipras opposes more pension cuts. [L'Altra Europa con Tipras/ Flickr]

Senior Greek judges ruled on Wednesday (26 October) an auction of TV licences held by the left-led government in September was flawed, throwing into disarray a crusade by authorities to shake up an unregulated broadcasting sector.

The Council of State, Greece’s top administrative court, ruled that the auction process which handed out four TV licences was unconstitutional, a court official said.

The auction procedure had effectively set a limit on the number of nationwide broadcasters to four, rather than the eight which now exist. Wednesday’s court decision, taken by a majority, said the auction process was flawed from the outset because it sidestepped the official decision making body known as the ESR.

Private radio stations and TV channels emerged in Greece only in the late 1980s, after decades of state media control.

Under the constitution, they are supervised by an independent authority, the National Council for Radio and Television (ESR) and its members are appointed by parliament, by majority.

Greece’s main government party, Syriza, and the main opposition, the conservative New Democracy party, had failed to agree on the composition of the broadcasting authority, leaving their positions vacant.

Tsipras’s closest aide, State Minister Nikos Pappas, has been overseeing the auction and handling media issues since then.

Licensing TV companies has been a rallying cry of Greek Prime Minister Alexis Tsipras’s government since it was first elected in 2015, vowing crack down on corruption and clientilism it perceived was pervasive in the sector.

The European Commission last month said that the Greek government was free to operate licensing regimes in line with domestic requirements, putting an end to an intense controversy in Athens.

Commission reiterates approval of Greek TV license tender

The European Commission reiterated today (27 September) that the Greek government is free to operate licensing regimes in line with domestic requirements, putting an end to an intense controversy in Athens.

According to government officials, the court decision may determine Tsipras’s next political moves. It could lay the ground for a planned cabinet reshuffle, aimed at boosting his Syriza party’s popularity ratings which have been dropping for months.

The cash-strapped government secured €246 million from last month’s auction. Following the decision, authorities are expected to return to the four winning bidders a first tranche already paid to the state.

Government spokeswoman Olga Gerovassili said in a televised statement that the court ruling was binding but was also “taking the country back to the previous unconstitutional situation”.

She said the government would table a bill to parliament on Monday, giving TV channels permissions to operate until new licenses are awarded.

In October 2015, the Greek parliament approved a new media bill, delivering on promises made under the bailout agreed on by Athens and its international creditor last July.

According to the government, the law aims to open up competition in the media market to new players.

New media law sparks intense controversy in Athens

Greek lawmakers are bickering over how to implement a new law which aims to open up competition in the media market.

However, the opposition parties accused Syriza of trying to take control of media.

“Greece is the only EU country that has never launched any licensing process for private TV channels for 25 years, maintaining the lawless regime of temporary licenses,” Pappas stated.

Subscribe to our newsletters