EU blocks merger of South Korean shipbuilders

Both Hyundai and Daewoo are important builders of large LNG carriers. A merger would have led to too much market power, according to the EU Commission. [VladSV (shutterstock)]

The EU on Thursday (13 January) blocked the merger of two South Korean ship-making giants over concerns the deal would restrict the supply of large liquefied gas carriers, posing a threat to Europe’s energy security.

The takeover of Daewoo Shipbuilding & Marine Engineering by rival Hyundai Heavy Industries Holdings, the European Commission said, “would have created a dominant position by the newly merged company and reduced competition in the worldwide market for LNG carriers”.

The veto of the tie-up comes two years after Brussels stopped India’s Tata Steel and Germany’s Thyssenkrupp from merging and three years after it blocked the merger of the train-making businesses of Siemens and Alstom angering France and Germany.

Only ten mergers have been prohibited by the Commission in the past ten years, while more than 3000 mergers were cleared in the same period.

“Given the evidence of negative effects of the merger (and) the absence of remedies, the Commission decided to block the merger,” said EU competition chief Margrethe Vestager at a news briefing.

The EU found that the merged entities would create a group controlling nearly two-thirds of the global LNG cargo ship market and would have grown more dominant over time.

“European customers would be left with few alternatives to the merged entity, only a handful of competitors would remain in the market,” Vestager warned.

The merger comes when energy prices are soaring in Europe and as the bloc tries to pivot away from its dependence on Russian natural gas towards other sources, including LNG (liquefied natural gas).

“Today’s energy situation is a forceful reminder that the diversification of sources of supply is fundamental”, Vestager said.

Both Hyundai and Daewoo are headquartered in South Korea. Nevertheless, they are subject to EU competition authorities, Vestager argued.

“It does not matter where the merging firms are located. What matters is whether they compete for demand in Europe,” she said.

The merger of the two of the largest shipyards in the world had been notified to the EU in November 2019, which opened an in-depth investigation the following month.

Illumina/GRAIL: Testing Vestager’s effort to expand EU merger control

The controversial $7.1 billion acquisition of GRAIL by Illumina is developing into a test of the European Commission’s new guidance on merger control, but also of the EU’s competition chief Margrethe Vestager’s resolve to expand the bloc’s supervision of such mergers.


Subscribe to our newsletters