Germany proposes tough conditions for ‘European IMF’

(L-R) President of the Eurogroup, Portuguese Finance Minister Mario Centeno, French Economy Minister Bruno Le Maire, Italian Minister of Economy and Finance Giovanni Tria and European Commissioner for Economic and Financial Affairs Pierre Moscovici at the start of the Eurogroup meeting in Luxembourg, 1 October 2018. [Julien Warnand/EPA/EFE]

Germany’s plans for a “European Monetary Fund” to help eurozone states in difficulty would set strict eligibility criteria that shut out those who are failing to tackle high national debt.

Many euro zone governments want the existing European Stability Mechanism (ESM) to be built up into a more robust bailout fund to help tackle future crises on the scale of the post-2008 Greek debt crisis, but ideas differ greatly.

German court clears way for ESM rescue fund

Germany's Constitution Court today (12 September) rejected efforts to block the European Stability Mechanism – the eurozone's €500-billion  bailout fund – paving the way for the country's ratification of the fiscal compact.

According to German Finance Ministry proposals seen by Reuters, the fund would be accessible without strings only to countries that had experienced an “asymmetric economic shock outside their political control”.

The proposals, first reported by the newspaper Die Zeit on Wednesday (21 November), do envisage a role for the fund in helping heavily indebted states out of crisis, a task currently carried out by the European Commission. But this would take the form of a more stringent “macro-economic adjustment programme with ex-post conditionality”.

Germany, Europe’s largest economy, has traditionally been among the European Union’s most fiscally hawkish members, and the new proposals sit squarely in that tradition.

The euro ‘hawks’ want bigger say for crisis fund in cuts and reforms

The so-called Hanseatic League of EU countries called for a “strict conditionality” and more powers for the European Stability Mechanism over those countries requesting assistance to avert a full-blown crisis.

Making the fund available to countries with unsound finances would risk creating “moral hazard”, the document says, “where low-interest ESM loans are misused to postpone necessary budgetary adjustments and structural reforms”.

To qualify for no-strings assistance, the country would need to have a budget deficit below 3% of GDP and a public debt below 60% of economic output – or else show that it had cut its public debt by 0.5 percentage point of GDP in each of the three previous years.

Eurozone finance ministers are expected to agree by the end of the year on how they want to develop the zone’s financial stabilisation funds.

Italy, which had a debt-to-GDP ratio of 131% in 2017, is often described as a country whose $2 trillion economy is large enough to endanger the entire region’s economic stability if it ever entered a serious debt crisis.

The European Commission took the first step on Wednesday toward disciplining Italy over its 2019 budget, which Brussels said would not reduce the debt mountain.

Commission launches excessive deficit procedure against Italy, saying it is ‘sleepwalking into instability’

The European Commission hedged its bets and called for the opening of an excessive deficit procedure against Italy on Wednesday (21 November) as Rome refused once again to revise its draft budget plan.

The row, triggered by the expansionary policies of Rome’s new eurosceptic government, has hammered the value of Italian bonds, and also the share price of Italian banks that hold large quantities of those bonds, unnerving Italy’s eurozone partners.

Subscribe to our newsletters