Rutte rejects Commission’s new funds for monetary union

Prime Minister of the Netherlands, Mark Rutte, speaks to the European Parliament's plenary session on Wednesday (13 June). [European Parliament]

Dutch Prime Minister Mark Rutte said on Wednesday (13 June) the EU should use the tools that are already available to support reforms and protect the euro, in his latest criticism of proposals to deepen the bloc’s integration.

Speaking to the European Parliament’s plenary session, the liberal politician made a passionate defence of European unity. But he said that “unity and ever closer union are not the same”.

Rutte and Schulz take the gloves off in front of Davos elite

Dutch Prime Minister Mark Rutte and former European Parliament President Martin Schulz clashed over the strategy to relaunch the Union, illustrating the deep division at Europe’s helm in front of the global audience of the World Economic Forum.

Member states remain deeply divided on how much solidarity there should be among them on issues such as migration or the eurozone.

The Brief: The divisive solidarity of Europe

More than 7.000 refugees in the Greek island of Lesbos know that something is not working with the EU’s response to migration. While they weather winter temperatures in summer tents, with capacity for only 2,300 people, European leaders will hold tomorrow the eleventh discussion over a fancy dinner to try to fix one of their biggest dares, and yet unresolved.

Rutte went against ideas floated by some countries, including France, and the European Commission to strengthen the economic and monetary union.

“The basic promise of the euro was that it would bring us all greater prosperity – not a redistribution of prosperity,” he told MEPs.

“The pleas now being made to establish a transfer union fly in the face of this promise,” he added.

The Dutch prime minister not only opposed proposals that could bring a fiscal union, such as the eurozone budget championed by France, but he also rejected the Commission’s less ambitious proposals to set up a scheme of soft loans to support investment and a new fund to incentivise structural reforms in member states.

Unemployment peaks to trigger new investment shield

A spike in unemployment numbers would give EU countries access to €30 billion of soft loans to maintain investment in times of economic turbulences, according to proposals unveiled by the European Commission on Thursday (31 May).

Although Rutte defended using the resources to achieve a higher level of convergence among the national economies, he argued for using the tools already in place.

“We already have hundreds of billions of euros available in the EU budget to support structural reforms at national level,” he recalled.

EU must under-promise and over-deliver

As divisions among the capitals run deep ahead of the EU summit due later this month, Rutte said that “unity is the bedrock of our strength”.

But in his view, the EU should limit itself to “core tasks” where the Union can promote its “effectiveness, strength and identity”.

“The EU needs to under-promise and over-deliver,” he insisted.

In this regard, he brought to the MEPs a proposal, a demand and few red lines before the crucial meeting with EU leaders.

He called on member states and MEPs to increase the EU’s target to cut CO2 emissions by 55% by 2030, instead of the current 40%.

He urged co-legislators to release the full potential of the single market, in particular in the services sector, because “we can’t pass up an extra trillion euros a year”.

Commission’s 'realistic' budget criticised by member states

The European Commission’s proposal for a moderate increase of EU funds for the next budgetary period (2021-2027) was immediately dismissed as a non-starter by national capitals.

But he said that the EU’s next seven-year budget (2021-2027) must be smaller, even if wealthy states should pay more, “but not disproportionately”.

He also stressed that the EU should focus less on yesterday’s priorities, such as cohesion or agriculture, but also reform “the very substance of these policy areas”.

Against the backdrop of rising tensions with US President Donald Trump after the disastrous G7 meeting in Canada, Rutte agreed that “the relationship with our most important ally is no longer self-evident”.

But contrary to other EU leaders, he said that Europeans “need to keep working as closely as possible with the US”.

The Brief – Trump’s horror show

The “horror” summit finally happened. But contrary to what European Commission top official Martin Selmayr expected two years ago, Donald Trump was enough to throw decades of Western Alliance down the drain.

Looking at the instability and challenges coming from Russia or China, Rutte said that “now more than ever”, Europe must stand united to determine its future.

He recalled the description of Europe as a ‘giraffe’ by Dutch diplomat Johan Beyen: difficult to define because of its diversity, but easy to recognise because of the common values.

“We don’t have to agree on everything – and we probably won’t today – in order to recognise the value of unity in a fast-changing world,” he concluded.


Subscribe to our newsletters