EU parties line up for Brussels top job nomination

Act React Impact photo in Brussels.jpg

The campaign leaders of Europe's four main political parties have pledged to "put a face" on next year's European election by designating their own candidates for the European Commission presidency.

Speaking at an event hosted by the Committee of the Regions on Wednesday (16 October), the campaign leaders of the four main European political parties promised to each designate a candidate to succeed José Manuel Barroso after the May 2014 poll.

All parties now have their selection processes in place, with the Alliance of Liberals and Democrats for Europe (ALDE) the last to reveal their plans, on Wednesday.

The Party of European Socialists (PES) earlier disclosed their own nomination process with a final list of candidates expected on 6 November, while the Greens had earlier announced an "open online primary" that would culminate in February with the nomination of two campaign co-frontrunners.

The centre-right European Peoples Party (EPP) has refrained from big announcements, at least until after the Christmas holidays, but the party has said it will select a candidate at its congress on 6-7 March in Dublin. On 13 November, the party is expected to discuss the profile of potential candidates, with details on the process expected to follow early January.

The nomination processes are part of the European Parliament’s longstanding wish to personalise and politicise the EU elections by showing a clear outcome for voters at the May 2014 poll.

Post-election uncertainty

Yet, the specifics of what will happen after election day are still far from clear.

In the post-election phase, the European Council of heads of states still holds the privilege of nominating its candidate to lead the European Commission, “taking into account the elections to the European Parliament and after having held the appropriate consultations”. The chosen candidate will then “be elected by the European Parliament by a majority of its component members” (Article 17.7).

Despite the vague wording, campaign strategists believe politics can fill the gap. “Sometimes – if you do it right – the political can exceed the legal,” said Brian Synnott, communications coordinator of the PES campaign. “Part of the strategy is to maximise expectations: if people expect their candidate to take on the lead position [of Commission president], it is difficult to turn this around.”

But Synnott also acknowledges that the outcome is unpredictable. In theory, the European Council of heads of states is expected to take the winning party's candidate into consideration for the Commission nomination at a summit on 26-27 June. But they could also decide to circumvent the winning party's candidate, potentially triggering a squabble with the European Parliament that could last all throughout the summer.

“It is a flaw in the system,” said Didrik de Schaetzen, campaign leader at the ALDE. “It could happen… and it would be a bummer.”

Moreover, the procedure itself remains controversial. Herman Van Rompuy, the president of the European Council, who is tipped to play a mediator role in the post-election nomination process, has consistently called into question the Parliament’s attempt to raise the stakes of the EU elections. Last week, he said that looking for "faces" to guide the EU was “not a solution”.

Van Rompuy's says that voters would be disappointed because the Commission's democratic legitimacy does not match its actual powers and competencies.

>> Read: Van Rompuy scorns direct election of Commission president

Former President of the European Commission Jacques Delors has sided with Van Rompuy. In an interview with RTBF last week, he warned: “What will happen if candidate wins the elections but does not please two or three governments [in Council]? We will face disappointment and outcries that we are undemocratic.”

Delors himself stated his preference for former World Trade Organization director general and former EU Trade Commissioner Pascal Lamy to succeed Barroso. Lamy is a member of the Party of European Socialists (PES), which appears likely to nominate Parliament President Martin Schulz as its candidate. Another name that carries weight with EU pundits is the managing director of the International Monetary Fund Christine Lagarde, part of the centre-right EPP political family.

Despite the calls for caution of Van Rompuy and Delors, European Parliament and political parties say they are determined to stick to the process. In the case of post-election disagreement, discussions could heat up considerably.

The European elections will be held in all EU countries in May 2014. The Lisbon Treaty states that the European Parliament shall elect the Commission president on the basis of a proposal made by the European Council, taking into account the European elections (Article 17, Paragraph 7 of the TEU). This will apply for the first time in the 2014 elections.

European Parliament, parties and many others have pushed for these parties to nominate their front-runners in the election campaigns. This would make the European elections a de facto race for the Commission president seat, would politicise the campaigns and could increase voter turnout, they say.

Election campaigns

  • Nov. 2013-Jan. 2014: European Greens' online primaries
  • 13-15 Dec. 2013: Party of European Left Congress in Madrid
  • 1 Febr. 2014: ALDE electoral congress in Brussels, selecting their candidate
  • Feb. 2014: Socialist party PES congress (date not yet confirmed)
  • 6-7 Mar. 2014: EPP (Centre-Right) Congress in Dublin
  • 22-25 May 2014: Elections for European Parliament

Post-elections formation of Parliament & Commission

  • June 2014: Parliament groups start informal negotiations with EU Council on next Commission president.
  • 26-27 June 2014: Nomination of Commission president at the European Council summit.
  • 14-17 July 2014: Parliament votes on European Council’s nomination of Commission president in its plenary session.
  • Sept. 2014: Individual hearings of Commissioners (selected over the Summer) before Parliament
  • Oct. 2014: New Commission is hoped to be confirmed by the European Parliament.
  • 1 Nov. 2014: Target date for new Commission to take office.

Subscribe to our newsletters