Polish lawmakers approved a bill yesterday (1 February) that would impose jail terms for suggesting Poland was complicit in the Holocaust, drawing concern from the United States and outrage from Israel, which denounced “any attempt to challenge historical truth”.
Poland’s ruling Law and Justice party (PiS) says the bill is needed to protect Poland’s reputation and ensure historians recognise that Poles as well as Jews perished under the Nazis. Israeli officials said it criminalises basic historical facts.
The Senate voted on the bill in the early hours on Thursday and it will now be sent to President Andrzej Duda, who has 21 days to decide whether to sign it into law.
Poland's Senate approves Holocaust bill that sparked a row with Israel.
The bill sets fines or a maximum 3-year jail term for anyone who uses the term "Polish death camp" to refer to concentration camps built on Polish soil by Nazi occupiers. https://t.co/zc9n24mQMs pic.twitter.com/K8QGg0ffCu
— dwnews (@dwnews) February 1, 2018
“Death and suffering in German Nazi concentration camps were a shared experience of Jews, Poles and many other nations,” Polish Prime Minister Mateusz Morawiecki said, adding that Poland would never limit debate about the Holocaust.
Deputy Prime Minister Beata Szydło said on Wednesday before the vote that, “It is a duty of every Pole to defend the good name of Poland.”
Duda has not said whether he will sign the bill, but has suggested he sympathises with its aims. He told state television on Monday: “The matter needs to be explained calmly, but we absolutely cannot backtrack.”
The bill would impose three years prison sentences for mentioning the term “Polish death camps”, although it says scientific research into World War Two would not be constrained.
Israel “adamantly opposes” the bill’s approval, the Israeli Foreign Ministry said on Thursday.
— The Times of Israel (@TimesofIsrael) January 27, 2018
“Israel views with utmost gravity any attempt to challenge historical truth. No law will change the facts,” ministry spokesman Emmanuel Nahshon said on Twitter.
Israel opposes categorically the Polish Senate decision. Israel views with utmost gravity any attempt to challenge historical truth. No law will change the facts .
— Emmanuel Nahshon (@EmmanuelNahshon) February 1, 2018
Israeli Housing Minister Yoav Galant, one of several cabinet ministers to denounce the bill, told Israel’s Army Radio that he considered it “de facto Holocaust denial”.
Israel also requested on Thursday the postponement of a planned visit next week by the head of Poland’s National Security Bureau.
The Polish bill has come at a time when right wing, anti-immigrant parties like PiS have been in the ascendancy in Europe, especially in the former Communist countries of the east. EU officials have expressed alarm over the PiS administration in Poland, which they say has undermined the rule of law by exerting pressure over the courts and media.
The socially conservative, nationalist PiS has reignited debate on the Holocaust as part of a campaign to fuel patriotism since sweeping into power in 2015.
The US State Department said the legislation “could undermine free speech and academic discourse” and Washington was concerned about the repercussions it could have “on Poland’s strategic interests and relationships”.
Piotr Buras, head of the Warsaw office of the European Council on Foreign Relations think tank, told Reuters the bill could push Poland further towards nationalism and isolation.
“The president will have to sign it – otherwise it would mean he is giving into international pressure. But the external criticism will, of course, push the government further into the position of a besieged fortress, strengthening both the nationalistic rhetoric…and the nationalistic mood in the country.”
Poland had Europe’s largest Jewish population when it was invaded by both Germany and the Soviet Union at the start of World War Two. It became ground zero for the “Final Solution”, Hitler’s plan to exterminate the Jews.
Opinion: 90% of Polish Jews Died in the Holocaust. So Why Are Poland's Nationalists Chanting 'Get the Jews Out of Power'?https://t.co/82PTr2L2Ye
— Haaretz.com (@haaretzcom) January 27, 2018
More than three million of Poland’s 3.2 million Jews were murdered by the Nazis, accounting for around half of the Jews killed in the Holocaust. Jews from across Europe were sent to be killed at death camps built and operated by the Germans on Polish soil, including Auschwitz, Treblinka, Belzec and Sobibor.
According to figures from the U.S. Holocaust Memorial Museum, the Germans also killed at least 1.9 million non-Jewish Polish civilians.
Many thousands of Poles risked their lives to protect their Jewish neighbours; Israel’s Yad Vashem Holocaust centre recognises 6,706 Poles as “righteous among nations” for bravery in resisting the Holocaust, more than any other nationality.
But Poland has also gone through a painful public debate in recent years after the publication of research showing some Poles participated in the Nazi atrocities. Many Poles have refused to accept such findings, which have challenged a national narrative that the country was solely a victim.
Outrageous. After my grandfather survived the holocaust he faced a Polish pogrom in his hometown. Hear that? Jail me Poland! I have also asked Israeli officials if they intend to condemn this. We’ll see which ‘national interest’ wins this time https://t.co/M86A8xTZ5U
— Noa Landau (@noa_landau) January 27, 2018
A 2017 survey by the Polish Center for Research on Prejudice showed that more than 55 percent of Poles were “annoyed” by talk of Polish participation in crimes against Jews.
I am a son of a Holocaust survivor. My grandmother was murdered in Poland by Germans and Poles. I don’t need Holocaust education from you. We live with the consequences every day in our collective memory. Your embassy should offer an immediate apology.
— יאיר לפיד (@yairlapid) January 27, 2018
Poland has long sought to discourage use of the term “Polish camps” to refer to Nazi camps on its territory, arguing that the phrase implies complicity.
European Council President Donald Tusk, a former Polish prime minister and political foe of the PiS, said the bill had the opposite of its intended effect, tarnishing Poland’s name and encouraging the view of history it aimed to criminalise.
“Anyone who spreads a false statement about ‘Polish camps’ harms the good name and interests of Poland,” Tusk said on Twitter. “The authors of the bill have promoted this vile slander all over the world, effectively as nobody has before.”
Kto rozpowszechnia kłamliwe sformułowanie o „polskich obozach”, szkodzi dobremu imieniu i interesom Polski. Autorzy ustawy wypromowali to podłe oszczerstwo na cały świat, skutecznie jak nikt dotąd. A więc, zgodnie z ustawą…
— Donald Tusk (@donaldtusk) February 1, 2018
BBC managed to do a whole story on the Polish-Israel controversy about Holocaust, and never mentioned word "German" once in discussing "Nazis invaded Poland", "suffering at hands of Nazis" "Hitler's men"…no wonder Polish gov is annoyed at term "Polish concentration camps",
— Seth Frantzman (@sfrantzman) January 30, 2018