China launches largest carbon market in the world

More than 1 million people died in China from dirty air in one year, according to the WHO. More than in any other country. [Shutterstock]

China launched what will become the world’s largest carbon market on Tuesday (19 December), surpassing the EU’s flagship market mechanism to cap and trade emissions. The scheme is part of a host of major policies China is using to peak its GHGs by 2030.

China’s emission trading scheme will cover the sector of power generation, which accounts for 46% of the country’s CO2 emissions. China is the world largest polluter, emitting a quarter of global greenhouse gas emissions.

According to China Carbon Forum, the 1,700 facilities initially covered by the Chinese market are responsible for 3,500 megatonnes of CO2 (33.9% of China’s total emissions).

In comparison, the European Emission Trading Scheme (ETS) covered  1939 megatonnes of CO2 in 2017 emitted by the sectors of power generation and heavy industry. This is almost double the emissions of the EU market. However, it is a large scaleback compared to the original plan.

In 2016, the Chinese National Development and Reform Commission (NDRC – the Chinese macroeconomic management agency) said that it plans to extend this to fight other sectors: petrochemicals, chemicals, building materials, steel, nonferrous metals, papermaking, electric power and aviation – for a total of 6,000 companies.

Yet even a limited carbon market would have a strong impact on carbon prices. China’s pilot carbon markets, initiated in a number of provinces in 2011,  have suffered from over-issue of emission permits and low prices, averaging at ¥30 (€4), much like the European ETS.

According to the Jiang Zhaoli, the deputy head of the NDRC’s climate change department, the price needs to rise to ¥200/300 (between €25 and 40) to put pressure on companies to reduce their emissions – a level he hopes to attain by 2020, when the scheme will become fully operational.

The American environmental agency estimates the social cost of carbon at €35 – but all ETS schemes are currently far below this.

The UK has introduced a price floor of €18 per ton CO2 for power plants that is additional to the EU ETS. Plant operators are obliged to pay the difference between the current price in the EU ETS and the domestic floor price to the tax authorities.

The price of carbon in the EU ETS, which will enter its third phase in 2020, has been fluctuating between €5 and €8 per ton for years, well below the levels needed to trigger  mass investments in low-carbon technologies.

The case for a price floor in the EU ETS

The recently adopted reform of the EU Emissions Trading Scheme (EU ETS) is insufficient to trigger cost-efficient decarbonisation of the economy, argue Christian Flachsland and Anna Leipprand. A carbon floor price that starts at a significant level and rises over time would address the problem, they write.

There have been proposals, notably from French President Emmanuel Macron, to set a carbon price floor – at around €25-30.

Yet the idea is unlikely to gain traction in Europe because, among other things, it will prevent the EU from linking up its ETS with that of other nations – something it has already done with Switzerland and is thinking of doing with California.

EU and California to discuss linking carbon markets

The EU and California are beginning talks to potentially create a common carbon market that could also include China.

The EU has welcomed China’s move especially after the US, the world’s second-largest polluter, has largely abandoned climate action.

“As the US government turns its back on the fight against climate change, China, the EU and many others are forging ahead,” Climate Commissioner Miguel Arias Cañete said in a statement from Brussels.

“With both the EU and China committed to emissions trading, two major international players are championing carbon markets to meet their commitments under the Paris Agreement and curb emissions cost-effectively.”

The EU climate commissioner also announced “enhanced cooperation” between the EU and China on emission trading, possibly with a view to linking the two markets in the future.

The European Council and Parliament reached agreement on the third phase of the EU ETS for the post-2020 period. The deal was heavily criticised for giving free-emission permits to coal-intensive countries (hence continuing the problem of over-issuing and low prices) and failing to establish a floor price.

Poland wins bigger coal transition funds in reformed ETS

The European Union has offered Poland more room to subsidise the coal transition in ongoing talks on reforming the Emissions Trading System (ETS), the EU’s flagship instrument to fight global warming, a move that sent alarm bells ringing among environmentalists.

Subscribe to our newsletters