France calls for carbon price floor to counter oil crash

A display shows the diesel price below one Euro at a petrol station in Muelheim on the Ruhr, Germany, 19 April 2020. The coronavirus crisis and the collapsed oil price make petrol much cheaper, petrol in Germany is as cheap as it was in August 2016. [EPA-EFE/FRIEDEMANN VOGEL]

The COVID-19 crisis should strengthen Europe’s resolve to achieve the climate objectives of the Paris Agreement by triggering policies that maintain fossil fuel prices above a minimum level, French authorities have said.

With oil prices hovering around $20 per barrel, world markets are awash with excess oil that risks putting the clean energy transition in jeopardy, France has warned.

“Extremely low fossil fuel prices” seen recently on world markets “do not reflect their true cost for climate,” the French say in a position paper sent to other EU member states.

“The cost of fossil energies should be proportionate to their true environmental impact,” argues the document, obtained by EURACTIV.

The French paper was circulated to national delegations ahead of an informal video meeting of EU energy ministers on Tuesday (28 April).

“French authorities consider that these market conditions make a clear case for mechanisms ensuring that these energies remain consistently above a certain floor price” from the perspective of both consumers and investors, it states.

Such a mechanism could take the form of “a carbon price floor” that could be implemented either through the EU’s emissions trading scheme or the energy taxation directive, which is up for review as part of the European Green Deal, the paper argues.

The UK has led by example in the European Union, by introducing a carbon price floor in 2013. But the idea is controversial in coal-dependent Poland and other countries in Central and Eastern Europe, which are likely to be hit hardest by the measure.

If adopted, the EU carbon price floor should be accompanied by social policies for regions in transition where jobs will be destroyed, French President Emmanuel Macron said during a visit to Brussels in 2018.

France to push for EU carbon price floor and border tariff

Paris will push for a carbon price floor at EU level, complete with a carbon tariff at Europe’s external border for countries that don’t sign up to the Paris Agreement, French President Emmanuel Macron said in Brussels on Thursday (22 March).

Carbon market reform

The French are also worried about the impact of falling electricity prices on the EU carbon market, saying urgent measures should be taken in order to avoid a glut of emission allowances that would send carbon prices crashing.

“In that regard, French authorities consider that a reinforcement of the EU ETS Market Stability Reserve must be implemented without delay to address the risk of resurgence of structural surplus,” the paper says.

According to the French, “the current situation also calls for a rapid establishment of the carbon border adjustment mechanism” in order to prevent factories from moving out of Europe in the face of higher carbon costs at home.

But these measures on their own will not be sufficient to boost investments in clean energy and secure a green recovery from the coronavirus crisis, the paper argues.

More fundamentally, France expresses worries about structurally low electricity prices, saying they hinder investments in new low-carbon power generation capacity, which is badly needed to meet the EU’s decarbonisation goals.

It says EU policy reforms are needed to “secure the financing of decarbonised electricity production,” which “does not exclude low carbon technologies” – a veiled reference to nuclear power.

EU carbon market 'the first victim' as electricity demand collapses

Every country in Europe has seen electricity demand decrease by 2 to 7% week-on-week as coronavirus-related confinement measures were enforced, according to new research by Ember, a climate think tank. Some analysts are now calling for urgent measures to prevent the EU carbon market from collapsing.

[Edited by Zoran Radosavljevic]

> Read the full paper below or download here.

French position paper

Subscribe to our newsletters