‘It’s complicated’: EU offers political backing but no funding for CCS

European Commissioner for Climate Action and Energy Miguel Arias Canete, speaks at a press conference on 05 December 2018. [EPA-EFE/STEPHANIE LECOCQ]

The European Commission has backed carbon capture and storage (CCS) as a one of the seven key technologies enabling a deep decarbonisation of Europe’s economy by mid-century. But it’s still tangled in bureaucracy when it comes to funding procedures.

Miguel Arias Cañete, the EU commissioner for energy and climate action, gave CCS a shot in the arm when he spoke at the 4th EU-Norway energy conference in Brussels yesterday (4 February).

“CCS is expected to play a vital role in delivering a net-zero emission economy” by 2050, the Spanish commissioner said. “This is why CCS is one of the seven building blocks” of the Commission’s long-term strategy for energy and climate change, he added.

Presented in November last year, just before the UN’s annual climate summit in Katowice, the long-term strategy indeed listed CCS among the seven key technologies that will enable Europe to reach net-zero emissions by 2050.

Despite the rise of cheap wind and solar power, CCS will retain “an important role in power generation,” as back-up for variable renewable power or in cases where fossil-fuel based electricity still needs to be produced because of lack of alternative options, Cañete explained.

“Even more importantly, CCS has a crucial role to close the circle for energy-intensive industries where other alternatives to reduce emissions do not exist,” the Commissioner said, citing cement as an example.

“Moreover, if combined with renewable biomass, it could create negative emissions,” he added, saying this could compensate for CO2 emissions in other sectors of the economy.

Scientists inject new sense of urgency into CCS

Europe – and the warming planet – has lost precious time in developing carbon capture and storage (CCS), a fledgling technology seen as crucial to decarbonise heavy industry, warned scientists in a new report presented in Brussels last week.

“We must make sure that all low-carbon technologies, including CCS, are further developed and become more widely available in the European Union and globally. Otherwise, we’ll reduce our options for the future,” the Spanish commissioner warned, adding: “We need to continue support research and large-scale demonstration projects.”

Norway could be among the first to receive EU funding in support of CCS. For months, Oslo has lobbied the European Commission to get financial support for its latest project, which involves building a permanent infrastructure off the Norwegian coast to transport and store CO2 offshore, in depleted oil and gas fields.

Norway’s latest CCS revival attempt meets lukewarm EU response

The European Commission has given only cautious backing to a project led by Norway that would see carbon dioxide emissions captured at source from industrial installations and shipped offshore to depleting oil and gas fields where they would be buried more than 1,000 metres underground.

The main novelty of the Northern Lights project is that the CO2 collected from industrial facilities would be transported to the storage location by boat instead of pipeline, bringing the costs down considerably.

A cement factory in Southern Norway and a waste incineration plant in Oslo are actively preparing to be the first industrial facilities to benefit from the new infrastructure once it is built.

But crucially, the infrastructure is meant to be scaleable and open to hundreds more industrial sites around Europe, which could join at any moment and ship their CO2 to Norway by boat – a bit like a garbage truck does for household waste.

World’s first zero-emission cement plant takes shape in Norway

Norway is getting closer to building the world’s first carbon-free cement plant, a move that could reverberate across the globe as 197 countries meet for the UN’s annual climate conference in Katowice, Poland.

“Not an easy subject,” Commission says

However, the Commission is hesitant to provide funding for CCS, referring to failed past experiences and the long decision-making timeframe when it comes to making the funds available.

“It’s not an easy subject,” admitted Haitze Siemers, a senior official in charge of new energy technologies at the European Commission’s energy directorate, listing the main difficulties of CCS – “public resistance, high costs, and relatively low private investments.”

Siemers also cited “the hangover from the first wave of carbon capture projects between 2009 and 2011” where the Commission burnt its fingers pouring millions of euros of funding into CCS projects that never got off the ground.

“So we’ve got our work cut out for us, I think,” Siemers said.

“But it’s a complicated story,” he added, saying “it can take decades or more” to get these technologies deployed on a commercial scale. “The issue is therefore how we can accelerate,” he said, adding “it takes time and investment”.

EU officials said hesitations on funding were also related to the bloc’s budget decision-making process. “It relates to the timing of the innovation fund” appended to the EU’s emissions trading system for CO2, explained Megan Richards, director for energy policy at the European Commission.

The innovation fund will indeed only start accepting calls for proposals in late 2020, after the EU’s new long-term budget for 2021-2027 is approved. And the decision-making processes cannot be accelerated.

“That’s where we are right now. We can’t go any further than that,” added Siemers, when pressed by EURACTIV to elaborate on the reason for the EU’s indecision. “We’re in the middle of inter-institutional negotiations on the next multi-annual financial framework. We have to give that a little bit of time to come down to earth and see what the outcomes are.”

Doubts about the technology

The EU’s hesitations on CCS are also related to lingering doubts about the technology itself.

In its long-term strategy, the Commission made clear that CCS should be seen as a fall-back option to “tackle remaining CO2 emissions” after all other options are exhausted.

Even worse for CCS fans, the Commission spoke of the technology in the past tense, saying: “Carbon Capture and Storage (CCS) was previously seen as a major decarbonisation option for the power sector and energy intensive industries. Today this potential appears lower, considering the rapid deployment of renewable energy technologies, other options to reduce emissions in industrial sectors and issues concerning social acceptance of the technology itself.”

When he spoke at the 4th EU-Norway energy conference, Cañete put it slightly differently, suggesting CCS should be seen as a last resort solution.

“CCS is necessary to address emissions that cannot be addressed via other means,” the Spanish EU commissioner told delegates at the conference. “Even more important, we need to develop viable business models,” Cañete continued, saying he was looking with interest at the utilisation of carbon dioxide in areas like plastics manufacturing.

UK-backed report identifies ‘viable business models’ for carbon capture technology

Carbon capture utilisation and storage (CCUS) offers “one of the greatest industrial opportunities” for Britain as the world pivots to a low-carbon economy, said Claire Perry, the UK’s Energy and Clean Growth Minister.

He also challenged oil and gas companies to provide more support for CCS than they are currently doing.

“Oil and gas companies are often seen as being close to the source of the climate change problem. However, if thanks to their engagement, CCS becomes a proven and financially viable solution, they could become part of the solution,” Cañete said.

Final stages of preparation

The European Commission is now “in the final stages” of preparing the ETS innovation fund, he continued, saying the fund “will offer an opportunity to fund big demonstration projects” and breakthrough low-carbon technologies such as CCS.”

Project holders can start submitting applications already in the first quarter of 2020, he indicated. For sure, Norway’s Northern Lights project will be among the first in line.

Subscribe to our newsletters