German farmers protest against green energy grid expansion

German farmers are calling for more compensation for underground cables and power lines being built on their land. However, these are vital for expanding the green energy grid. [German Farmers' Association (DBV)]

Germany’s parliament is looking into a law meant to speed up electric grid expansion and move forward the country’s energy transition. But German farmers are not happy and have called for more compensation from the federal government. EURACTIV Germany reports.

A delegation of farmers gathered in front of the Bundestag on Wednesday (20 February) to hold up their placards. Slogans included “Farmers call for intergenerational justice”.

The protest was in relation to a proposed law on accelerating grid expansion, unveiled by German economic minister Peter Altmaier (CDU) in December.

Time is running short to expand the grid for renewable energies, given the policies to phase out coal and nuclear energy. Without expansion, it will not be possible to quickly transport green electricity from the north of the country to the industry-heavy south.

Farmers’ concern over decades of soil damage

But people are not happy with the construction project, including farmers, who have been up in arms about it for quite some time. They are concerned about considerable encroachments on their arable land and feel ignored by politicians.

“Those most affected were not invited to the expert hearing. Agriculture hasn’t been represented in the whole process, which is just annoying,” complained Holgar Hennies.

Hennies, together with four colleagues, manages around 600 hectares of arable land in the municipality of Uetze in Lower Saxony. In his capacity as deputy chair of the state farmers’ association of Lower-Saxony, he travelled to Berlin to submit a resolution against the bill to some members of the Bundestag.

The fact that farmers were not invited to the committee’s hearing was up to the parliamentary groups, explained Klaus Ernst (The Left) in response to the farmers’ accusations.

“Unlike for consultations on land-use planning, for instance, there’s no general right for those affected to be heard,” Ernst explained.

Germany urged to stand firm on coal phase-out

Minister-President of North Rhine-Westphalia Laschet intends to close fewer coal-fired power stations than envisaged by the coal commission. Three of its members are exerting pressure on the federal government to push forward closures as quickly as possible. EURACTIV Germany reports.

Hennies explained that the problem with the power cables was how they affected farmland because laying them destroys soil structure.

An underground cable connection consists of eight cables, which are driven deep into the ground a few metres apart. Hennies believes that an area of at least 50 metres is required for this.

“The problem is that the soil can’t be repaired as quickly afterwards as it has a long memory. When taking measurements of the areas concerned, we sometimes found 30% yield losses,” Hennies said.

He added that the problem of heat from the cables was also unpredictable, as they would prevent the deep frost needed by the soil to regenerate. Moreover, certain plants, such as asparagus, can only be planted on the electricity lines with permission.

Grid operators buying up land

Overhead lines were less of a problem, Hennies said, even if they do represent a financial risk if they are damaged, for instance.

However, many citizens’ initiatives across Germany are attempting to block the construction of these large power lines, instead calling for underground cables that cannot be seen.

A further problem of expanding the grid is that operators have to provide compensation when extending the routes and also provide land elsewhere.

“Here in Lower Saxony, large areas are already being bought out for the South link connection. This drives up land prices,” Hennies added.

Farmers are calling for higher and, above all, recurrent compensation payments. To date, landowners have only been compensated with one-off payments.

'Merkel deceived us on climate', says Germany’s Energiewende godfather

Berlin lacks the political will to bring the energy transition forward, said Hans Josef Fell, the initiator of Germany’s world-renowned 2000 renewable energy feed-in tariff legislation, in an interview with

“Forty years ago, my father received around 4,000 Deutschmarks for the power lines constructed on his land. But what can my children do if there’s still soil damage in 30 years just because I once agreed to the lines?” Hennies asked.

The German Farmers’ Association (DBV) is now calling for “intergenerational justice” and a corresponding amendment to the proposed legislation, which still does not provide for regular payments.

The farmers calculate that the German federal government would have  to invest around €1 billion in compensation payments across the country for this.

It remains to be seen whether the influential farmers’ lobby will prevail in the case of grid expansion. Committee proceedings for the grid expansion law in the German Bundestag and Bundesrat are ongoing.

But one thing is clear; grid expansion will have to be accelerated considerably for the German energy transition to be achieved on schedule.

[Edited by Sam Morgan and Zoran Radosavljevic]

Subscribe to our newsletters