EU ministers criticise Turkey but not ready to halt membership talks

Federica Mogherini chairing the Foreign Affairs Council on 14 November 2016. [Council]

European Union foreign ministers yesterday (14 November) criticised Turkey’s crackdown on alleged supporters of a failed military coup in July but Austria’s call to suspend Ankara’s EU membership bid failed to garner enough backing.

As the 28 EU foreign ministers met in Brussels, President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan said he was ready to hold a referendum on whether to continue the membership talks and reiterated that he would restore the death penalty – a move sure to scupper the EU talks – if his parliament passed such a law.

Tensions flare as Turks head to referendum on new Erdogan powers

Turkey is heading to a referendum on granting President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan new powers as early as next spring, ratcheting up tensions amid a crackdown on dissent and pro-Kurdish politicians, analysts say.

Turkey has suspended, dismissed or detained at least 110,000 people, including soldiers, judges and teachers, since the coup. Critics of President Tayyip Erdoğan accuse him of using it as a pretext to crush dissent, a charge he denies.

Erdogan says coup was ‘gift from God’ to reshape country, punish enemies

President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan said that Friday’s failed coup (15 July) was a “gift from God”, giving him the chance to re-shape the country, and purge the country’s elite from enemies, who accuse him of creeping Islamisation in the traditionally secular state.

“I am not for the continuation of entry negotiations and I believe that this Turkey does not have a place in the European Union,” said Austrian Foreign Minister Sebastian Kurz.

Austrian chancellor wants EU to end accession talks with Turkey

Austria’s Chancellor Christian Kern on Wednesday called on the European Union to end membership talks with Turkey in the wake of a massive government crackdown following a failed coup.

Luxembourg and Belgium were also critical of Turkey, but the bloc’s most powerful members, France and Germany, support continued engagement, arguing that ending the accession negotiations now would do more harm than good.

“…Turkey is too important to us – not least because of the close personal times between our two countries – that we could afford to renounce dialogue, particularly in these difficult times,” German Foreign Minister Frank-Walter Steinmeier told reporters before leaving for a one-day visit to Ankara.

Boris Johnson, the foreign minister of Britain, which intends to leave the EU, also cautioned against over-reaction to events in Turkey, a large, strategically important, mainly Muslim country on the EU’s southeastern flank.

“We should not push Turkey into a corner, we should not overreact in a way that is against our collective interests,” he said.

Johnson, however, campaigned for a ‘Leave’ vote during the June UK referendum on EU membership partly on a platform that Turkey – a nation of around 75 million people – was poised to join the EU, and its people would be free to settle in Britain.

Despite its increased concerns over human rights and press freedoms in Turkey, the EU has often toned down its criticism of Erdoğan and his government, whose cooperation it needs to keep low the number of refugees and migrants reaching Europe via Greece from Turkey.

More than 1.3 million people arrived in Europe last year, triggering bitter disputes between EU member states over how to handle them. The deal with Turkey, though much criticised by rights groups, has reduced the influx to a trickle.

‘Red line’

An EU official said the bloc’s leaders would review the situation in Turkey at a summit scheduled for 15-16 December. “It would have to be a majority vote to stop the talks and it’s clear there is no majority at this stage,” the official added.

Some EU countries said the bloc would lose any residual influence it has over Turkey if it suspended talks, but also voiced concern over a possible restoration of the death penalty, previously scrapped by Ankara as part of its accession drive.

Mogherini on Turkey: 'No country can become an EU member state if it introduces the death penalty'

EU High Representative for Foreign Affairs Federica Mogherini stressed on Monday (18 July) that “no country can become an EU member state if it introduces the death penalty”, after Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan said on Sunday that the country should reintroduce capital punishment after last week’s attempted coup.

“It is important to keep the membership negotiations ongoing since it is the only way to influence Turkey,” Finnish Foreign Minister Timo Soini told reporters.

“(But) everybody understands that if it goes on like this, Turkey will not become a member of the EU. The death penalty is the absolute red line for the EU.”

Steinmeier said: “We cannot decide for the government in Ankara whether they will slam the door on the EU and turn away from the West. That is Ankara’s responsibility. If they decide to reintroduce the death penalty, then that would be a clear signal that they want to permanently close the ‘EU file’.”

Turkey has often threatened to walk away from the migration deal if the EU does not deliver on its side of the bargain by relaxing visa rules by the end of the year for its citizens visiting Europe.

Ankara has also accused the EU of failing to show sufficient solidarity with it over the failed coup, in which more than 240 people were killed. Erdoğan blames a US-based Muslim preacher, Fethullah Gülen, and his supporters for the putsch. Gülen denies any connection with it.

Diplomats said Johnson spoke out during Monday’s discussions for a transactional relationship with Turkey, which some took as meaning he thought human rights were of secondary importance.

However, a British diplomat said Johnson had wanted to discuss “how we can constructively influence Turkey” in its deliberations over the death penalty rather than alienate it further.

On 9 November the Commission published the so-called “enlargement package“, consisting of the annual accession progress reports concerning Albania, Bosnia and Herzegovina, Macedonia, Kosovo, Montenegro, Serbia and Turkey, as well as the regular “Strategy paper’ regarding the future of EU enlargement.

On this occasion, Neighbourhood Commissioner Johannes Hahn, who is also responsible for enlargement negotiations, said that faced with the pressure of some political groups and some member states to freeze the negotiations with Turkey, he wants a clear mandate to discuss the issue with Ankara.

Hahn wants ‘clear mandate’ to discuss if EU-Turkey relations have a future

Neighbourhood Commissioner Johannes Hahn, who is also responsible of enlargement negotiations, said today (9 November) that faced with the pressure of some political groups and some member states to freeze the negotiations with Turkey, he wants a clear mandate to discuss the issue with Ankara.


Subscribe to our newsletters