Cameron gives no ground before budget summit

David Cameron Dec 2011_Picnik.jpg

On the eve of an EU summit that could see further political isolation for the United Kingdom, officials made clear that Prime Minister David Cameron would not hesitate to use his veto to freeze the EU's 2014-2020 budget and to preserve the UK rebate.




Council President Herman Van Rompuy on 15 November tabled a €973-billion compromise proposal, €75 billion less than the Commission's initial recommendation for the 2014-2020 budget.

“While Van Rompuy's proposals are a step in the right direction, we believe there are still areas where further cuts can be made,” Cameron's spokesman said on the eve of the summit (21 November).

“The Van Rompuy proposal represents the talks starting to go in the right direction, we think that the level still needs to come down appreciably,” an EU diplomat added.

The diplomat said that the UK position is not about reducing actual expenditure, but about spending more efficiently. He added that EU administrative costs could still be reduced.

UK will offer newer member states a payment guarantee

Cameron will be working for an agreement at the summit, the source said, whilst reiterating that the UK will not accept the loss of its rebate.

“We think it [the rebate] is justified. It tries to rectify the low net receipts and that is what justifies those low receipts, and so it is a red line we have made that is clear to people,” said the diplomat.

Discussing concerns that proposals to freeze the budget will hurt newer member states through lost cohesion funds, the diplomat said that Britain was prepared to give a “payment guarantee” to those states.

Such a guarantee would ensure that spending levels under the next budget are preserved at the 2007-2013 rate, even if the overall budget is frozen.

Cameron has spoken to a number of EU leaders on the budget – including Angela Merkel, François Hollande, Mark Rutte, Fredrik Reinfeldt and Donald Tusk – by phone over the past week.

Summit represents another challenge for UK-EU relations

“There is a real prospect of agreement” at the summit, said another diplomatic source, but he added: “Cameron is prepared to say no, and I do not believe he is the only one prepared to say no. He has done it before.”

The sources acknowledged that the summit could represent another watershed moment in the UK’s worsening relationship with its EU partners.

The UK Parliament and press have both given a resounding signal that the British believe that any rise in the EU budget will be viewed as deeply inequitable, one said.

“Across the EU people are facing difficult choices. We are all facing stress and uncertainty and the EU is changing in reaction to the crisis,” said one diplomat.

Cameron does not have much room for manoeuvre in the negotiations, since the UK Parliament has already voted for a freeze in the EU budget.

The right wing of Cameron’s Conservative party is demanding a cut to the EU budget, whilst many believe that both Conservative and Labour parties might offer a referendum on Britain’s EU membership before the next general election, to be held in 2014.

With rumours that the other member states are feeling for ways to circumvent the UK veto, and Germany's Merkel increasing exasperated with British intransigence, the summit has the potential to worsen the UK’s already fraying relationship with the EU.

Germany, which has proposed a budget cut harsher than Van Rompuy’s, may represent Cameron’s only chance of a lifeline if EU leaders hope to agree the budget at this sitting, rather than delaying a budget deal until next year.

“Denmark has made it very clear that [it wants] a correction of the Danish contribution to the EU budget of €150 millions annually,” an EU diplomat told EURACTIV.

“The reason for this is simple: It is not fair that Denmark is to finance other comparable countries’ rebates or corrections. The ideal solution would be to abolish rebates and corrections altogether which would also solve the Danish problem. But this has shown unrealistic. Therefore, we are demanding an end to the unequal treatment of Denmark,” said the diplomat.

“In a further blow to the Prime Minister's credibility and negotiating stance, a majority of MEPs steadfastly refused to listen to anything other than significant multi-billion rises for the MFF today (21 November), citing their desire for "more Europe",” said UKIP MEP Marta Andreasen.

"David Cameron's veto is worthless if nobody respects it. The UK has now been relegated to the sidelines on the EU Budget debate," said Andreasen.

The European Commission presented on 29 June 2011 its proposals for the EU's 2014-2020 budget – the so-called Multi-Annual Financial Framework.

The Commission proposed raising the next budget to €1.025 trillion, up from the current €976 billion. This represents a 4.8% increase, which is beyond the average 2% inflation recorded in the last decade.

The European Parliament had said in a resolution on 23 October that even the original Commission proposal for a freezing of the budget at the level of 2013 ceilings would not be sufficient to finance existing policy priorities in the "Europe 2020" strategy, which comprises the new tasks laid down in the Lisbon Treaty, let alone any unforeseen events. 

The goal of the Cypriot presidency is to reach an agreement by the end of 2012, in line with the European Council conclusions of June 2012 [more].

On 30 October, Cyprus tabled a 46-page paper, called the ‘revised negotiating box’, which follows two previous versions issued by the Danish and the Cypriot presidencies. In advance of today's summit, Council President Herman Van Rompuy issued a further compromise proposal.

  • 22-23 Nov.: EU Heads of State and Government meet in Brussels to broker a deal on the EU's budget for 2014-2020.

Subscribe to our newsletters


Want to know what's going on in the EU Capitals daily? Subscribe now to our new 9am newsletter.