Ayrault seeks to allay German worries over French economy

Ayrault Merkel_smaller.jpg

France's German-speaking prime minister offered a worried Berlin reassurances on Thursday (15 November) that his government would reduce the deficit and prevent France from becoming the next victim of the euro crisis by applying a new economic model.

Jean-Marc Ayrault, making his first visit to Berlin since François Hollande became president, told Chancellor Angela Merkel that France would find its own way to reduce spending and boost economic growth and jobs, rather than copying Germany.

"My challenge, the government's challenge, is to reform what isn't working, to correct what is too weak, but to keep the profound values that make France what it is," he told a joint news conference after talks with the conservative chancellor.

"The job that is under way is constructing the new French model," said Ayrault, a Socialist.

Germans worry second pillar of Europe is buckling

Reports that Merkel's finance minister had asked the German government's economic advisers to consider preparing policy recommendations for France has stirred outrage in Paris.

Deutsche Bank co-chief executive Juergen Fitschen added to German criticisms by urging France to reform. "That is not easy because maybe they have not come to the realisation that they must tighten their belts too," Fitschen said at a business group dinner on Thursday in Frankfurt.

"This must work with France. That is absolutely important for Europe," he said.

But Merkel said she would never dare to evaluate the decisions of the French government and added diplomatically: "We want a strong France just as France wants a strong Germany, so that together we can become a strong Europe."

Ayrault also held a 20-minute meeting with German Finance Minister Wolfgang Schäuble, who emerged saying Germany and France did not "grade" each others' economic policies.

But it was clear French pride had been stung.

French hit back

Ayrault told a conference in Berlin organised by the Süddeutsche Zeitung newspaper that his host country Germany also had its problems.

"The German population is ageing quicker than the French, which poses problems for pensions and social security," said the French premier. "This sort of understanding for other countries' problems – I expect it for my own country too."

Paris is under intense pressure to improve French economic competitiveness relative to Germany and southern European countries that have implemented painful reforms to bring down their own debt in the face of a crippling three-year crisis.

German officials are worried that without bolder reforms, France could get sucked into the crisis – which has forced bailouts of Greece, Portugal and Ireland – in what would be a crushing setback for the bloc's efforts to stem the turmoil.

In response to calls by industrialist Louis Gallois for cuts in labour charges to reverse decades of industrial decline, the French government has now announced plans to grant companies €20 billion in annual tax credits to lower labour costs.

Ayrault cited this as one example of the "courage" France's Socialist government was showing on economic reforms.

His knowledge of Germany and its language may have been one of the reasons for his appointment. Relations between Merkel and the new president are often contrasted with the close partnership – especially on the euro crisis – that she enjoyed with Hollande's conservative predecessor Nicolas Sarkozy.

Hollande criticised Merkel's focus on austerity for the eurozone during his election campaign and the new Franco-German leadership couple have not got off to the best start.

"The main thing is to build a personal relationship," Ayrault said, adding that although the two governments belonged to opposing political factions, their relationship had to be "überparteilich" – the German word for non-partisan.

Ayrault and Merkel both rejected suggestions that the French premier's plans to meet Germany's centre-left opposition Social Democrats on Friday – less than a year before federal elections when Merkel will seek a third term – undermined this ideal.

"The important thing is for us to work together well," said Merkel.

France's new centre-left government started work on 17 May with pledges to combat excessive austerity but better manage public finances.

In October, France ratified an EU fiscal discipline treaty demanded by Germany, amid opposition from leftists in the National Assembly.

The Socialists had earlier opposed the fiscal pact, which holds governments to meet deficit-cutting goals or face sanctions.

Created in March by President François Hollande's predecessor Nicolas Sarkozy and 24 other EU leaders including Germany's Angela Merkel, the fiscal compact requires eurozone countries to slash their public deficits or face legal action and possibly fines.

>> Read EURACTIV's LinksDossier on the fiscal compact treaty

Subscribe to our newsletters