Harmonised EU consumer credit rules one step closer

bank_people_02.jpg

The European Parliament and Council are entering another round of tough negotiations on a much disputed directive on consumer credit, after a Parliament committee voted for some major changes to the draft.

The Parliament’s committee on internal market and consumer protection (IMCO) passed some 236 amendments to the proposed directive in a vote on 10 December.

Key changes include the scope of the directive, advertising, pre-contractual and contractual information and early repayment terms, which have been the main bone of contention in negotiations among member states (EURACTIV 22/05/07).

The new rules will harmonise the €800 billion consumer credit market, allowing consumers to enjoy the same rights and information standards, as well as compare offers across the EU. The rules will apply to consumer loans between €200 and €50,000, as opposed to the Council’s preferred upper limit of €100,000. 

One of the main objectives of the directive is to protect consumers against taking on too much debt. In order to prevent this, the information given by the lender must allow the borrower to make a responsible decision and the lender must also assess the solvency of the borrower.

Under the rules agreed in the committee, lenders will be expected to provide information on the benefits as well as the drawbacks of the loan offered to the consumer. Moreover, the information to accompany the signing of the contract will make it easier to calculate and compare the total cost of loans by using an annual percentage rate of charge (APR) as a basis for calculations. Similarly, definitions for overdraft facilities will be standardised, but the Parliament committee adopted a text that is less strict than that adopted by the Council on contractual and pre-contractual information requirements for overdrafts.

The directive also gives consumers the right to pay off their loans early and sets out rules on the calculation of compensation payments to the lender in this case. The compensation needs to be justified, in line with national rules and should not go beyond the interest charges the consumer would have normally paid. Moreover, a right of cancellation within 14 days is to apply to all member states.

Consumer credit rates currently range from 6% in Finland to 12% in Portugal. However, few European consumers are likely to reap the benefits of harmonised rules, as consumer credit remains a local business, with less than 1% of transactions currently carried out across borders.

Read more with Euractiv

Subscribe now to our newsletter EU Elections Decoded

Liberal MEP and shadow rapporteur Diana Wallis said: "After seven years, it looks as if we are at last on the brink of getting Europe-wide legislation on consumer credit. Most importantly for consumers, they will be given clear information allowing them to compare and choose between the credit deals on offer."

The European Federation of Building Societies (EFBS) heavily criticised the committee agreement, arguing that modernisation and renovation loans would become more expensive. EFBS Managing Director Andreas Zehnder said: "The inclusion of those credits into the scope of the consumer credit directive, to which the parliament committee did not object, will increase their costs significantly."

"European building societies urge the Parliament to avoid this 'red tape monster' in its plenary vote in January 2008", Zehnder added.

The Commission has been attempting to amend the existing consumer credit directives since 2002, but its proposals repeatedly failed to gain the agreement of the member states, who feared that a harmonisation of rules could reduce the level of consumer protection.

Member states finally managed to agree on the amendments in May this year, leaving it up to Parliament to approve the directive. However, after a series of close votes in the parliamentary committee, it is not clear what the plenary will decide in January.
 

  • Dec. 2007: Parliament and Council are to hold negotiations before the end of the year in order to reach a compromise ahead of the parliamentary vote.
  • Jan. 2008: The consumer credit directive will be submitted for second reading in the Parliament plenary.

Subscribe to our newsletters

Subscribe