Stop attacking Commission on fiscal policy, Juncker tells Renzi

Matteo Renzi and Jean-Claude Juncker on 26 May 2016. [Commission]

Italy should stop attacking the European Commission over its fiscal policy, the EU executive’s president said on Monday (7 November), as Rome and Brussels quarrel over an expansionary budget proposed by Italian Prime Minister Matteo Renzi.

Renzi has criticised the Commission on several occasions, saying it applies rules too strictly.

Renzi threatens EU budget veto over migrants

Italian Prime Minister Matteo Renzi yesterday (25 October) threatened to veto the EU’s budget over a lack of solidarity from the rest of Europe as the bloc struggles to manage the refugee crisis.

“Italy is constantly attacking the Commission, wrongly so, and this does not produce the results they want,” Jean-Claude Juncker told a conference, adding that changes to fiscal rules had allowed Italy to spend €19 billion more this year.

“It should no longer be said that this Commission continues the austerity measures applied in the past,” Juncker said.

“If one wants to say it, one can … but, in fact, I don’t care.”

Renzi has proposed a budget for 2017 that would not cut Italy’s structural deficit as European Union rules require and that includes a headline budget deficit figure that is higher than previously agreed with the EU.

Italy warns of disaster if Europe rejects its budget

Italy’s economy minister said yesterday (23 October) the European Union must choose between allowing Rome to raise its deficit to cope with a recent earthquake and the migrant crisis, or the “Hungarian way” of putting up barriers, which he said would spell doom for the bloc.

Replying to Juncker in a speech later on Monday, Renzi said: “We are not making trouble, we are not intimidated by anyone.”

“We can talk about investments but on securing school buildings no one can block us: we will keep that money outside of the Stability Pact,” he added.

Italy’s 2017 budget earmarks more than €6 billion, or 0.4% of its gross domestic product, in additional spending on migrants and to cover reconstruction costs after major earthquakes that have rocked the country this year.

Italy to Commission: Refugees, quakes forced 2017 budget off target

Italy has defended its rule-breaking 2017 budget to the European Commission, saying the migrant crisis, post-earthquake reconstruction and lower-than-expected growth were to blame.

But Juncker said that migrants and earthquakes would have an additional cost equivalent only to 0.1% of GDP.

A Commission spokeswoman did not confirm this figure in a statement later on Monday and added that the assessment of Italy’s draft budget continues.

Separately, commissioner in charge of economic affairs, Pierre Moscovici, told a news conference the Commission would state its position when it publishes opinions on the draft budget plans of Italy and other EU states on 16 November.

The EU executive will release its economic forecasts for member countries over the next two years on Wednesday.

“Then you will have more elements on where we are and what are the gaps to bridge,” Moscovici said in reply to a question on Italy’s budget.

Moscovici and Italian Finance Minister Pier Carlo Padoan discussed the budget plans later on Monday, on the sidelines of a meeting of eurozone finance ministers in Brussels.

The executive Commission is in charge of applying EU fiscal rules in member states and can sanction countries that fail to respect them, although this has never happened.

Italy, the euro zone’s second most indebted country, after Greece, will hold a referendum on constitutional reforms on 4 December, which will shape Renzi’s political future.

Italian constitutional reform referendum to be held on 4 December

A referendum on Italian Prime Minister Matteo Renzi’s flagship constitutional reform will be held on 4 December, the government said yesterday (26 September), with the fate of his administration likely to hinge on the outcome.

If, as opinion polls suggest is likely, he loses the referendum, it may strengthen the eurosceptic 5-Star Movement, which is already the most popular party in Italy according to some polls.

Subscribe to our newsletters