Berlin talks agree on contact group for Ukraine ceasefire

From left to right: Laurent Fabius, Sergei Lavrov, Frank-Walter Steinmeier, Pavlo Klimkin at news conference after Ukraine talks in Berlin [Photo Reuters]

From left to right: Laurent Fabius, Sergei Lavrov, Frank-Walter Steinmeier, Pavlo Klimkin at news conference, after talks in Berlin. [Reuters]

The foreign ministers of Russia and Ukraine agreed in Berlin yesterday (2 July) to hold three-way talks involving pro-Moscow rebels by Saturday, in order to pave the way for a new ceasefire, despite continued fighting that Kyiv says has now killed 200 of its troops.

“It is a clear commitment to a multilateral ceasefire,” said German Foreign Minister Frank-Walter Steinmeier, after talks with Russia’s Sergei Lavrov, Ukraine’s Pavlo Klimkin and French Foreign Minister Laurent Fabius.

Russia and Ukraine continued to blame each other for the violence that marred the 10-day ceasefire, which Kyiv declared over on Monday before resuming its military offensive against separatists in the east, many of whom had ignored the truce.

But Lavrov told a joint news conference alongside Klimkin and the two others that they had agreed to work for a “stable, long-term truce”.

“We propose to achieve this through a meeting soon of the Contact Group, which – we hope – will hold a meeting in coming days and agree on the conditions for truce that would satisfy all sides,” said the Russian minister.

That group, representing Ukraine, Moscow and the rebels, with Organisation for Security and Cooperation in Europe (OSCE) mediation, should meet “no later than 5 July with the goal of reaching an unconditional and mutually agreed sustainable ceasefire”, said a document agreed on by all four ministers.

Klimkin added a note of caution, saying hostages must be released and Ukraine allowed to control its borders to stop the rebels receiving fresh fighters and weapons. The document said Russia made a commitment to allow Ukrainian border guards across checkpoints in Gukovo and Donetsk to control this.

“The de-escalation of the situation will happen when the peace plan of the Ukrainian president is respected in its totality,” said Klimkin.

Lavrov said Ukrainian President Poroshenko’s decision to end the ceasefire had cost “people’s lives and serious destruction of civilian infrastructure […] but better late than never”.

Threat of sanctions

German Chancellor Angela Merkel had warned Moscow shortly before the talks that economic sanctions remained an option unless it backed peace efforts.

“Regarding sanctions against Russia, we have so far reached level two and we cannot rule out having to go further,” Merkel added, referring to measures against Russian officials and firms the West accuses of undermining Ukraine’s territorial integrity.

The European Union has threatened to ratchet up sanctions against the Russian economy unless it reins in the separatists in eastern Ukraine. Moscow denies supporting them.

Separatists fired a shoulder-launched missile that struck and damaged a Ukrainian SU-24 attack plane, a military spokesman said. Five servicemen, including a Ukrainian border guard, had been killed since the renewal of the offensive on Monday night.

This brought to 200 the number of service personnel killed since the start of the conflict, including 150 soldiers, Andriy Lytsenko, a spokesman for Ukraine’s national security and defence council, said.

Hundreds of civilians and rebels have also died.

Poroshenko, under pressure at home to take a tough line on rebels who have been fighting Kyiv’s forces since April, refused to renew the 10-day ceasefire on Monday night and ordered an offensive against “the terrorists, militants and marauders”.

That won backing from the United States, but drew criticism from Russia’s Vladimir Putin who said Ukraine’s newly-elected leader had veered off the road to peace.

Separatism erupted in the Russian-speaking east in April, when rebels seized buildings and strategic points, declaring “people’s republics” and saying they wanted union with Russia.

Ukraine has been in turmoil since a Moscow-backed president, Viktor Yanukovich, walked away from a free-trade deal with the European Union last year. He was toppled in February after street demonstrations. Moscow responded by seizing Ukraine’s Crimea region in March, before the rebels rose up in the east.

On Friday 48-year-old Poroshenko, defying threats by Russia to carry out retaliatory trade action, signed the EU deal. 

Reviving peace talks in Ukraine will be "much more difficult" now that Kiev has failed to extend a ceasefire in eastern Ukraine, Russian Prime Minister Dmitry Medvedev said on Wednesday.

"In breaking the ceasefire, (Ukraine's) President (Petrol) Poroshenko made a dramatic mistake. It will cause more casualties. And he is now personally responsible for them," Medvedev wrote on his Facebook page.

"It will be much more difficult to revive talks. These are the rules of a war," he said, referring to talks between the Kiev government and separatist, pro-Russian rebels in eastern Ukraine.

Medvedev wrote his comments before the results were known of talks in Berlin among the foreign ministers of Russia, Ukraine, Germany and France.

Medvedev also reiterated that Russia would introduce measures to "protect" its economy and mount barriers to trade with Ukraine after Kyiv signed a historic association agreement that brought it closer to the European Union on 27 July.

"Given the circumstances, it will extremely difficult to develop ties with Ukraine, impossible in some areas," he wrote.

The crisis in Ukraine erupted after its former President Viktor Yanukovich cancelled plans to sign trade and political pacts with the EU in November 2013 and instead sought closer ties with Russia, triggering protests that turned bloody and drove him from power.

Moscow annexed Crimea in March following a referendum staged after Russian forces established control over the Black Sea peninsula in the biggest East-West crisis since the Cold War.

Pro-Russian militants control buildings in more than ten towns in eastern Ukraine after launching their uprising on 6 April. On 11 May pro-Moscow rebels declared a resounding victory in a referendum in Donetsk and Luhansk, which the West called illegal and illegitimate. 

Scores of people have been killed and wounded in Ukraine since the rebellions in the two eastern regions. The dead include about 150 Ukrainian servicemen - among them 49 who died when a cargo plane was brought down by rebel fire - and scores of rebels and ordinary citizens. It has been the worst bloodshed in Ukraine since it became independent with the breakup of the Soviet Union in 1991.

  • 5 July: Trilateral contact group to meet and agree ceasefire

Subscribe to our newsletters