The European Commission is appointing its new coordinator on anti-Muslim hatred. This is a key opportunity to re-assess this role and ensure the coordinator has a clear human rights based mandate and meaningful resources to tackle racism and discrimination against Muslim communities in Europe, which have been lacking so far.
By NGOs members of an informal European coalition against Islamophobia.
In December 2015, following the first ever European Commission Fundamental Rights Colloquium, the appointment of a European Commission Coordinator on combating anti-Muslim hatred was a welcome move. This was a strong and concrete commitment to tackle increasing racism against Muslim people in Europe.
The coordinator took some steps to increase the relationship with NGOs and the recognition of anti-Muslim hatred. However, two years after the coordinator’s appointment, this political commitment must now lead to a shift in strategic approach, understanding of the issue and to tangible actions, which have been lacking so far.
The current political context makes this all the more urgent. In several EU countries, islamophobic discourses are being spewed by government representatives and are shaping the way laws and policies are being developed and adopted, but also practices.
The latest example is in Denmark, where the government is introducing a new set of laws dubbed the “ghetto package” to regulate neighbourhoods with a high percentage of low income and Muslim and immigrant families, including mandatory instruction in “Danish values” for pre-school children at least 25 hours a week. In addition, this has an impact on people’s lives and the racist incidents and discrimination they face.
In Belgium this week, a 19-year old Muslim woman was attacked by two men who pulled her headscarf and her shirt off, used a sharp object to cut her body and called her “filthy arab”.
On Thursday 5 July, organisations part of a European coalition against Islamophobia sent an open letter calling on European Commission Vice-President Timmermans and Commissioner Jourová to provide their Coordinator on anti-Muslim hatred with a clear human rights-based mandate and meaningful resources. The European Commission’s decision to appoint a new coordinator is an opportunity to make this happen.
Indeed, there are serious gaps in the mandate and approach of the coordinator to ensure meaningful participation of Muslim communities and anti-racism NGOs and to develop policies to combat Islamophobia. The appointment of one dedicated person does not replace strong political will, actions and effective policies.
Inadequate human and financial resources, expertise, objectives and evaluation processes partly explain disappointing results to date. The lack of transparency concerning meetings with national governments, the failure to organise a meeting between NGOs and Commissioners, the framing of anti-Muslim hatred as a religious and security issue instead of a human rights one, the absence of European Commission representatives at several events on Muslim women’s rights and the engagement of the coordinator with very questionable figures fuelling Islamophobia, are among the most problematic illustrations of these systematic gaps.
In a context of generalised suspicion of Muslims, it is all the more important that EU policy makers advancing equality and non-discrimination see Muslims as human beings who enjoy fundamental rights as any other person. The fight against Islamophobia is about politically addressing structural forms of discrimination and racism affecting Muslims or those perceived as such.
If the European Commission is serious about upholding European core values of equality and non-discrimination, it needs to make important strategic changes and concrete actions including:
- Profile of the coordinator: The coordinator should be appointed based on relevant skills and competences in order to work meaningfully on the issue of Islamophobia as a form of racism. This will also facilitate the relationship and trust with NGOs who have extensive knowledge about the issue and its manifestations.
- Clear mandate: The role of the coordinator should be clarified, in terms of representation, official communication and actions that can be undertaken, also defining the remit of issues to be covered.
- Communication and consultation process: Transparency is key to build trust with civil society organisations who are on the ground in direct relation with communities. Communication and consultation processes need to be clarified to ensure meaningful participation of civil society.
- Concrete objectives and action plan: The role of the coordinator cannot only be about listening and bringing issues to the political level without any accountability. The coordinator needs to set concrete objectives to achieve during their mandate and work on an action plan with evaluation processes.
At a time when parties using blatant islamophobic rhetoric have come to power in a number of EU member states, we need a clear signal from EU policy makers that they are committed to ensuring equality and inclusion for all members of European society.
The signatories are part of an informal European coalition against Islamophobia, a platform of anti-racist/human rights/faith-based NGOs combatting anti-Muslim racism and hatred.
- European Forum of Muslim Women (EFOMW)
- European Muslim Initiative for Social Inclusion (EMISCO)
- European Network against Racism (ENAR)
- European Network on Religion and Belief (ENORB)
- Forum of European Muslim Youth and Student Organisations (FEMYSO)
- Alliance of Inclusive Muslims (AIM)
- Anti-Racist Forum, Finland (ARF)
- CAGE, UK
- Center for Danish Muslim Relations, Denmark (CEDAR)
- Collective against Islamophobia and Discrimination, The Netherlands (CTID)
- Collective against Islamophobia in Belgium (CCIB)
- Collective against Islamophobia in France, France (CCIF)
- Coordination Contre le Racisme et l’Islamophobie, France (CRI)
- Etudiants Musulmans de France, France (EMF)
- Euro-Mediterranean Center Migration & Development, The Netherlands (Emcemo)
- Justice & Liberties For All Committee, France (CJL)
- Muslim Council of Britain, UK (MCB)
- Muslim Human Rights Committee, Sweden (MHRC)
- Muslims for Progressive Values, the Netherlands (MPV Nederland)
- RADAR/Art.1, The Netherlands
- Farid Hafez, editor of the Islamophobia Studies Yearbook and co-editor of the European Islamophobia Report and Salzburg University