The European Commission yesterday (19 July) stepped up a legal battle with Hungary over EU migration rules and denounced as illegal its “Stop Soros” law that criminalises support for asylum seekers.
The move will further sour Brussels’s relations with Hungarian Prime Minister Viktor Orbán who has been one of the strongest opponents of EU decisions for greater cooperation among EU states to handle the migration crisis. The EU executive said in a statement that it had referred Hungary to the EU Court of Justice “for non-compliance of its asylum and return legislation with EU law”.
Great that @EU_Commission initiates legal action on #Hungary's new law criminalizing NGO work with refugees, and sends to EU Court the 2015 & 2017 flawed asylum laws. #EU should not tolerate policies that flouts its basic values.https://t.co/pcvcbNcvvq pic.twitter.com/IV20kdKuYt
— Philippe Dam (@philippe_dam) July 19, 2018
Two EU legal requests went unheeded. This is the third step of a legal procedure that could ultimately lead to financial sanctions on Budapest if the court confirms the commission’s line.
Brussels says the Hungarian authorities have failed to provide effective access to asylum procedures for migrants. Asylum seekers are also held in “transit centres” for more than the maximum stay of four weeks allowed under EU rules, Brussels said.
“The Commission considers that the indefinite detention of asylum seekers in transit zones without respecting the applicable procedural guarantees is in breach of EU rules,” it said in a statement.
Budapest is also in breach of EU rules that require certain guarantees for migrants who are sent back to their countries of origin or transit. Under the Hungarian legislation, “migrants risk being returned without the appropriate safeguards,” the commission said.
No ‘Stop Soros’
The Commission also chided Hungary over a new law that introduces criminal sanctions for organisations providing assistance to migrants for their asylum and residence applications.
Since July 1, it is a crime in #Hungary to help refugees, asylum seekers, or other migrants. Good to see @EU_Commission launch infringement action against this law today, which is designed to intimidate people who work or volunteer for independent groups. https://t.co/CeIENebJkc pic.twitter.com/AcvVR0laIu
— Todor Gardos (@TodorGardos) July 19, 2018
The law, labelled “Stop Soros” because it hits non governmental organisations supported by the US billionaire George Soros, has already been criticised by European rights bodies.
The Commission decided to open an infringement procedure against Hungary saying the new rules curtailed asylum applicants’ right to turn to national, international and non-governmental organisations for help.
The “Stop Soros” bill also introduces new criteria to submit asylum applications which are not in line with EU rules as they limit asylum seekers’ rights, the commission said.
The EU executive sent a “letter of formal notice” to Hungary about the “Stop Soros” law. This is the first step of EU legal proceedings against a member state. Hungary has two months to reply to the Commission’s concerns.