French coalition rift widens over EU budget pact

Cécile Duflot PS.jpg

President François Hollande's government demanded yesterday (24 September) its Green allies fall into line over European Union policy after the ecologist party said it would oppose a European Union budget discipline pact in a vote next month.

While the pact is set to pass with votes from Hollande's Socialists and from the right, the Greens' move is the most open defiance of Hollande's authority yet from within his four-month coalition and comes as his popularity ratings are plummeting.

While no admirer of an EU austerity accord created during the rule of his conservative predecessor Nicolas Sarkozy, Hollande backs the plan to return to balanced budgets as a necessary step to easing the euro sovereign debt crisis.

"I am calling on all members of the EE-LV to show some coherence and, frankly, solidarity," said government spokeswoman Najat Vallaud-Belkacem, referring to the Europe Ecology-The Greens party.

The Greens' national council at the weekend rejected the pact agreed by EU leaders in March as the wrong response to Europe's rising debt burden and called for talks on an undefined "new European agenda" to tackle the crisis.

Although some Green deputies have threatened for weeks to at least abstain in the vote, the decision stunned even some within the party. Veteran ecologist Daniel Cohn-Bendit called the move "dramatically pathetic" and suspended his party membership.

Ties between Socialists and Greens have been strained by a statement by Industry Minister Arnaud Montebourg, a Socialist, suggesting nuclear power was an energy of the future – comments the ecologists feared put in doubt the government's commitment to reducing France's longstanding reliance on the energy source.

Opposition conservatives leapt on the Greens' move on the EU pact as proof of a split within the coalition, and called on their two government representatives, Housing Minister Cécile Duflot and Development Minister Pascal Canfin, to step down.

The two ministers were not immediately available for comment but the Greens' parliamentary group leader François de Rugy rejected calls for them to resign and said the Greens were within their rights to reject a pact they had never supported.

"The European pact was not part of the coalition agreement we made with our Socialist allies. This pact is a legacy of the Sarkozy era, it's even dubbed the 'Merkozy pact'," he told Canal Plus television, using the play on words supposed to show Sarkozy's close ties with German Chancellor Angela Merkel.

A source in Prime Minister Jean-Marc Ayrault's office later told Reuters: "The presence of Madame Duflot and Monsieur Canfin in the government is not open to question."

Bad news to come

A survey by Ifop pollster released on Sunday showed Hollande's popularity fell to 43% from 54% in August, the lowest level since he took office in May.

Hollande issued an ambitious pledge this month to revive the economy in two years, but he also conceded that growth next year would fall short of an existing one percent official target, coming in around 0.8% instead.

August jobless data due on Wednesday are forecast to add to the gloom, showing unemployment, already at a 13-year high, rising above the symbolically important three million mark.

Hollande's government will unveil on Friday how plans to claw in the €30 billion needed to cut its deficit to three percent of gross domestic product in 2013 en route to a balanced budget by the end of his five-year term.

It has ruled out making what would be deeply unpopular increases to value-added tax and the CSG social levy, a tax payable by all employees, to narrow the deficit.

European lawmaker Daniel Cohn-Bendit revoked his membership of the French Greens on 23 September in protest at the party's decision to oppose the ratification of the European Union's budget discipline pact.

The French Greens voted overwhelmingly against the terms of the pact at a grassroots assembly on Saturday, concluding that it would not provide long-term answers to the EU crisis nor help foster environmentally friendly policies.

  • October: French Parliament to vote on fiscal compact treaty


Measure co-financed by the European Union

The content of this page and articles represents the views of the author only and is his/her sole responsibility. The European Parliament does not accept any responsibility for use that may be made of the information it contains.

Subscribe to our newsletters