Italian left mulls 5-Star deal to end deadlock

Italian 5-Star Movement's leader and candidate for the post of Italian Prime Minister, Luigi Di Maio celebrates with his supporters in Volla , Italy, 6 March 2018. [Cesare Abbate/EPA/EFE]

Senior members of Italy’s vanquished Democratic Party yesterday (6 March) eyed a possible deal with the triumphant 5-Star Movement (M5S), following an election that left the country with a hung parliament and anti-establishment and far-right parties vying to form a government.

Matteo Salvini, leader of the far-right League, the biggest party in the right-wing coalition that came first with 37% of the vote in Sunday’s election but failed to win an overall majority, said his team was ready to govern. In the right-wing coalition Silvio Berlisconi’s Forza Italia came second with 14% compared to 17% for Salvini’s League.

“We have a programme, a team. If they call us, we’ll start work tomorrow morning,” Salvini told reporters.

But Luigi Di Maio, leader of the anti-establishment 5-Star Movement, declared his party “the winners”, after obtaining alone nearly 33% of the vote, but M5S would also need to form alliances in parliament to gain a majority.

Meanwhile Matteo Renzi, who announced his resignation as Democratic Party (PD) leader on Monday after his centre-left coalition in the election slumped to third place on 23%, ruled out the prospect of a deal with either the 5-Star Movement or the right-wing alliance.

Renzi quits, populists battle to govern Italy

Former Italian prime minister Matteo Renzi resigned yesterday (5 March) as leader of the centre-left Democratic Party (PD) after a bruising election defeat, but pledged that his party would not strike deals with the anti-establishment parties that voters favoured.

In a Facebook post on Tuesday Renzi said he would not work with those who “have insulted us for years and who represent the opposite of our values”.

“They’ve said that we’re corrupt, mafiosi and that we have blood on our hands due to immigration. I don’t believe that they’ve suddenly changed their minds,” wrote the former prime minister.

“If anyone wants to support the right-wing or the 5-Star Movement they should say so. I personally think it would be a glaring and tragic mistake,” he added.

However, other leading voices in his party disagree and he now faces pressure to bring forward his resignation.

In an interview with Il Fatto Quotidiano daily, Michele Emiliano, governor of the Puglia region and a leading PD member, berated Renzi for not stepping down immediately and “impeding the party from supporting the M5S”.

Watching the third bloc

Italy’s vote has drawn comparisons with the Brexit referendum in Britain and the election of US President Donald Trump because of the anti-immigration and anti-establishment rhetoric, raising concern in European capitals about instability.

Salvini overtook coalition partner Silvio Berlusconi’s Forza Italia (Go Italy) party after promising to deport hundreds of thousands of “irregular” migrants, and railing against the European Union and its “failed currency”.

On Tuesday Salvini said that the right “was the number one coalition and the hope for Italians” and he was open to negotiate with anyone who “shares our programme”.

At the same time, he ruled out any “old-style political or cross-party agreement” and refused any alliance with the M5S.

Berlusconi, who is currently banned from public office, later said he was “happy” for Salvini and for his party, during a video message.

The 81-year-old claimed that, despite not faring as well as the League in the election, his Forza party had played a “determining” role in the far-right’s strong showing at the polls.

“I thank all the voters who confirmed by their vote their confidence in Forza Italia,” he said. “Together we have contributed decisively to the victory”.

However, for some political observers, it appears the Democratic Party could end up the kingmaker.

“The key question for the coming days is what the PD will do,” said Giovanni Orsina, political science professor at Rome’s Luiss University.

“Neither the right-wing alliance nor M5S are able to form a government alone. The question is therefore what the third bloc will do.”

Despite the setback for the centre-left, the high-profile, unaffiliated industry minister Carlo Calenda announced yesterday he was joining the PD. He is expected to quickly carve out an influential position in the party.

‘Nothing will be as before’

M5S leader Di Maio, who later on Tuesday is due to visit his hometown of Pomigliano d’Arco, an industrial base near Naples, will now face a difficult balancing act.

Any perception of cosy deals with other parties following the election risks alienating his core support from Italians angered by traditional politics.

A deal with the Five Star Movement could also divide the PD, where many are smarting from the M5S’s victories in traditional leftist heartlands.

Commentators said any compromise would be far from easy and would take time, at least until newly-elected lawmakers meet for the first time on 23 March.

“The world of Italian politics as we have known it for the last 25 years is over,” wrote Corriere della Sera’s editor Luciano Fontana.

“Nothing will be as before. The players, and the political landscape of the country have changed.”


Measure co-financed by the European Union

The content of this page and articles represents the views of the author only and is his/her sole responsibility. The European Parliament does not accept any responsibility for use that may be made of the information it contains.

Subscribe to our newsletters