Merkel sees ‘no need’ to transfer more powers to Brussels

Merkel Hollande June 2012_Small.jpg

German Chancellor Angela Merkel has come out against handing the European Commission more powers, in the clearest sign yet that she is reining in her ambitions to create a "fiscal union" in which euro members cede control of their budgets to Brussels.

The comments, made in an interview with weekly Der Spiegel, come days after Merkel held talks with President François Hollande in Paris where the two unveiled joint proposals for the future shape of the euro area.

The Franco-German proposal includes some controversial ideas like the creation of a permanent president of the Eurogroup forum of finance ministers, greater convergence on taxation issues and social matters, but the two leaders delayed their implementation until after the 2014 European elections,

>> Read: France, Germany kick plans for deeper union into the long grass

Merkel spoke out strongly in favour of closer fiscal integration last year, but France and some other euro members have deep doubts about ceding sovereignty – a step which would require politically sensitive changes to the EU treaty – and Berlin appears to have realised that this resistance is too great to overcome for now.

With a German election looming in September and a new anti-euro party threatening to eat into support for her conservative bloc, Merkel may also be adjusting her message for voters at home, many of whom are leery about ceding national powers.

"I see no need in the next few years to give up more powers to the Commission in Brussels," Merkel said in the interview, adding that she agreed with Hollande on EU member states cooperating more on economic issues.

"We are thinking for example of the labour and pension markets but also of tax and social policy. Economic policy coordination in Europe is far too weak, it must be strengthened and this is rather different to giving more competences to Brussels," she said.

Broader compromise

For much of last year, when the bloc's debt crisis was raging, Merkel spoke repeatedly of the need to move towards both a fiscal and political union in Europe to end the turmoil.

In October, for example, she said in a speech in the lower house of parliament that European governments needed to go a "step further" in cementing fiscal discipline by "giving Europe real rights of intervention in national budgets".

She also voiced support at the time for a proposal by German Finance Minister Wolfgang Schäuble to create a super-empowered European currency commissioner.

The move away from such views reflects both an easing of the crisis in response to actions by the European Central Bank and a shift in Germany's focus from insisting on deficit reduction in eurozone stragglers to pushing for structural reforms.

It may also be part of a broader compromise with Paris under which Germany drops its push for a federalist union in favour of an inter-governmental approach to integration that France has long supported.

In exchange, Berlin may have received assurances from Hollande that he will press ahead with reforming the ailing French economy, for example by aligning it more closely with Germany in the areas of pensions and labour market policy.

Merkel made clear at her news conference with Hollande last week that France must deliver on reforms prescribed by the European Commission in exchange for granting Paris two extra years to hit deficit reduction targets.

Hollande had infuriated officials in Germany and Brussels by initially suggesting that the Commission had no right to "dictate" to Paris. The Germans believe that a strengthening of the EU's Stability and Growth Pact has granted the Commission that right.

"The chancellor made very clear in Paris that Hollande had an obligation to follow the Commission's recommendations," a German official told Reuters on Sunday.

"We believe he understands what reforms need to be implemented, but he needs to convince a domestic audience that is under the false impression that enough has already been done."


At a summit in October, EU leaders were presented with an interim report by European Council President Herman Van Rompuy, which charts a path towards closer fiscal integration among the 17 countries using the euro.

The interim report followed an earlier draft that Van Rompuy tabled jointly with European Commission President José Manuel Barroso, Eurogroup President Jean-Claude Juncker and European Central BankPresident Mario Draghi – the so-called "four presidents".

The most far-reaching suggestions in the report included:

  • Setting "upper limits" on member states' annual budgets;
  • "Prior approval" for issuing government;
  • debt "beyond the level agreed in common";
  • Issuance of "common debt" as a medium term option;
  • Setting up an EU "treasury office";
  • Closer coordination on "labour mobility" and "tax coordination".


  • 28 June: EU summit to flesh out proposals for a deeper economic and monetary union
  • 22 Sept. 2013: German federal elections
  • 22-25 May 2014: European Parliament elections

Further Reading

Subscribe to our newsletters


Want to know what's going on in the EU Capitals daily? Subscribe now to our new 9am newsletter.