Requiem for a year of hope

epa07143163 French President Emmanuel Macron pays a visit at Novasep, a company specialized in molecule production and purification for the life science and chemical industries, as part of a tour to commemorate the centenary of the First World War, in Pompey, northern France, 05 November 2018. Macron is currently on a six-day tour to visit the most iconic landmarks of the First World War ahead of the celebrations of the 100th anniversary of the 11 November 1918 armistice. EPA-EFE/ETIENNE LAURENT/POOL

“Europe is back”, EU officials proclaimed at the beginning of 2018, buoyed by political impetus and the momentum of economic growth. The optimism didn’t last long. As the year ends, many lament the missed opportunity to deepen monetary union. But 2019 cannot be ‘business as usual’, they warn. The stakes are too high.

The Brief: The divisive solidarity of Europe

More than 7.000 refugees in the Greek island of Lesbos know that something is not working with the EU’s response to migration. While they weather winter temperatures in summer tents, with capacity for only 2,300 people, European leaders will hold tomorrow the eleventh discussion over a fancy dinner to try to fix one of their biggest dares, and yet unresolved.

A senior diplomat says that we should write down the details of the coming period, as we may be witnessing history in the making.

Divisions have not only taken root within the EU family, but also among those who wish to leave the union. In the United Kingdom, the split between those who continue to support Brexit at all costs, and those who want to remain in the EU seems insurmountable, leaving the country in a dangerous stalemate. 

But there is another and still deeper division in Europe and beyond, between the rulers and the ruled, between an elite and a citizenship that feels neglected.

Avoid Brexit-style 'chaos' Dutch PM tells his people

The Prime Minister of the Netherlands, Mark Rutte, has issued a stark warning to the Dutch public, telling them to learn from the mistakes of the British government while the Brexit negotiations continue to be dogged by setbacks in the UK for Prime Minister Theresa May.

The Brexit vote was just the canary in the coal mine, said one European diplomat. 

“Unless we start getting serious about ‘l’Europe qui protege’, voters will tell us the same, only louder”, the official added.

French president Emmanuel Macron’s U-turn following the protests of the ‘yellow vests’ illustrates the zeitgeist of this period.

Reform programmes should compensate low-income workers, OECD says

The Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) has urged governments to pay attention to the consequences of their policies and compensate vulnerable groups that could be hit by new taxes.

The European economy has been growing for almost two years, and public accounts look healthier. But the boom period was not felt by many. In Italy, dissatisfaction brought a  populist and eurosceptic government to power.

On the other hand, member states were incapable of seizing the calm waters to bolster the euro.

Political and geographical centre

While the expansive cycle is running out of steam, EU’s political centre is shifting closer to its geographical one. 

The Franco-German axis continues to lose dynamism, dragged by a defensive French president and a lame-duck German chancellor. 

The traces of what Europe could bring are rather to be found in Hungary or Austria. Hungarian prime minister Viktor Orban appears to see where history is taking us.

Faced with a world of complex problems, growing uncertainties and a clumsy Europe, its illiberal model offers simple solutions and a protective image. Less than 250km away, Austrian Sebastian Kurz whitewashed populist and eurosceptic forces by bringing them into his Government. 

Commission regrets Austria's decision not to sign the global migration pact

Austria will follow the United States and Hungary in backing out of a United Nations pact on migration over concerns that it will blur the line between legal and illegal migration, the right-wing government told media on Wednesday (31 October). The EU Commission regretted the decision. 

Kurz, the youngest prime minister in the EU, was among those to refuse to sign the non-binding UN Migration Pact this month, despite holding the rotating presidency of the EU.

But migration has not been (and won’t be) the only issue responsible for cracking the bloc. Progress on the economic and monetary union with further mutualisation of risks, either with European protection of bank deposits or the unemployed, remains stuck at the member states’ table.

In the first case, Germany represents the only substantial obstacle, while the Netherlands leads a strong group against any eurozone budget that could serve to cushion future economic shocks. 

Against this background, the long-awaited package to deepen the eurozone turned into a minimal agreement this month, after more than a year of lofty speeches and technical discussions.

Leaders wrap up year-long euro reform with face-saving package

EU leaders concluded on Friday (14 December) a year-long discussion to bolster the eurozone by approving extra money to resolve failing banks and additional powers for the European Stability Mechanism, the EU’s rescue fund.

All out?

This depressing landscape should force pro-European parties to go all out ahead of the European elections next May. 

But the combative spirit hardly shines, not even among the most pro-European governments.

”I believe that the EU should be much more ambitious,” said Spanish Prime Minister, Pedro Sanchez, when asked about the lack of progress at the last summit in December.

“Each government defends its national position as a country”, he said. Nothing else to add to drum up support, or to ignite citizens’ spirit in this critical period.

On the opposite camp, those who want to empty Europe from within see a substantial shift within the EU machinery within their reach. No matter if that implies burying their compatriots under a pile of debt, as in Italy, or dismantling the rule of law, as in Hungary.

“Changing Europe is a big goal,” Italy’s Interior Minister Matteo Salvini told Time magazine. “It is at our fingertips”.

“If you follow the trend of what has happened in Italy, Austria, Germany, France and other countries, the European Parliament will change,” Hungarian State Secretary for Communication Zoltan Kovacs told in October.

Orban’s spokesman strips populism of its bad reputation. Because, in his opinion, it simply illustrates the fracture between what people really want and the elite interprets about the European project. Voters no longer want to share more sovereignty, but maintain “effective cooperation between Member States,” he concluded.

But this 2019 will prove how cold it is outside the union. The UK economy will be surpassed  by France, and by its former colony India. The glorious past Brexiteers hoped to recover outside the EU is back, but not as they expected.

However, the bloc has no reasons to boast. The self-searching process to agree on a common vision to complete the European project has failed to bring results. 

Davos waiting to hear 'the EU is back'

As the EU embarks on a difficult year to trace the future course of its existence, the world is growing increasingly anxious at how Brussels and the 27-country bloc will reinvent itself to fully take its leading role in the global order.

A summit planned on 9 May in Romania risks becoming another milestone to nowhere, while the builders still argue about the future they want to share.

More ungovernable

The Union will become more ungovernable next year. Although Eurosceptic parties will not achieve their goal of conquering a third of seats in the next European Parliament in May, few doubt that their position will be strong enough to hamper legislative activity.

European elections amid a looming economic storm

The slowdown of Europe’s economic growth and the risk of a new recession if the ongoing trade war worsens could steer the political agenda in the run-up to next May’s European elections.

More problematic will be the presence in the new Commission of at least a quarter of its members sent by governments allergic to European integration.

As some European officials lament, the common position is no longer the principle of “an ever closer union” carved out in the treaties, but the aspiration to shield this cracking bloc from enormous difficulties.


Europe to push for trade reforms in critical G20 summit in Buenos Aires

European leaders will pursue a last-ditch effort to improve the global trade system during the meeting of the Group of 20 most powerful nations in Buenos Aires (Argentina) later this week, as the dispute between US and China risks breaking the multilateral framework.

Donald Trump does not care about what Europeans may believe or want to defend.

Nor he is concerned about breaking the international consensus on climate change, the other major global challenge closest to the European’s heart.

Trump Administration’s priority is to contain China, in trade, in the economy, in technology.

The confrontation between Washington and Beijing could gain momentum in February if the weak truce reached in December comes to an end. 

Trump and Xi’s truce upholds watered down G20 communiqué

A trade ceasefire agreed between the US and Chinese presidents, Donald Trump and Xi Jinping, helped to sustain the defence of multilateralism included in the final G20 declaration in Buenos Aires. 

Europe could become a collateral victim the same month, if Trump concludes European cars are a threat and imposes new tariffs, as part of his attempts to reshape global trade.


Deeper problems

With so little clarity about the future Europe wants, and even less willingness to advance on the strategic flaws of the bloc on the economy, migration and energy, Europe will fight to keep its two feet on the ground instead of taking a step forward.

But the problems are deeper, and not only for Europe.

The complexity of steering a boat with 500 million citizens, 28 member states and fifty EU institutions and agencies only amplifies the challenges that many other leaders face elsewhere.

The Brief – Bringing back unity and solidarity to the EU

The political mandate that will follow next May’s European elections should be an opportunity to continue opening up the political space for citizens’ engagement, so that democracy is not limited to voting and politics can spread well beyond the parties’ …

Democracy urgently needs fine tuning. Decades of progress and protests extended voting rights to reach universal suffrage. Now the representative system must surpass the ballot box to embrace a greater participatory nature.

”Europe must urgently embrace a new participatory paradigm that puts citizens at the forefront of the agenda and monitoring powers,” says Alberto Alemanno, a Jean Monnet professor in EU law at HEC Paris.

Otherwise, the risk is that Europe will continue to walk toward the darkness corners of its past.

“The answers of the past no longer suffice for the questions of today, let alone tomorrow”, warns a European diplomat.

A silver lining in 'illiberal' Hungary

The looming decision on whether to close the prestigious Central European University (CEU), a symbol of the resistance in Hungary, is bringing together the opposition to forge an innovative plan to end the ‘Orbánian’ state, reports from Budapest.

But there is still hope. In Hungary, citizens are taking the streets like never before against Orban’s authoritarian grip. Opposition and civil society are fighting to erode his control by seeking to engage in new ways with communities in rural areas where Orban remains largely undisputed.

The new Volt movement already brings together almost 15,000 people in some thirty countries, with 10 parties in Member States, attracted by the idea of ​​a united and citizens’ driven Europe.

Volt, the transnational party that aims to take over Europe

Volt, a transnational movement built by young Europeans, aims to take over the upcoming EU elections with a combination of a hyper-localised organisation under a common European vision. spoke to two of its founders. 

“This election should be a fight between old ways of doing politics and a new way of doing politics, a new way that is inclusive, in which people participate, in which people have their voice heard,” Colombe Cahen-Salvador, one of its founders told

Hope was strangled from the top this year. But 2019 could bring fresh energy and ambition badly needed from the bottom. A united Europe without Europeans on board is almost an oxymoron. It may seem complicated today. But the consequences of not exhausting every possible way to relaunch the European project will prove even more disastrous.


Measure co-financed by the European Union

The content of this page and articles represents the views of the author only and is his/her sole responsibility. The European Parliament does not accept any responsibility for use that may be made of the information it contains.

Subscribe to our newsletters