Romanian PM defies Brussels to handpick prosecutors

Victor Ponta.jpg

Romania's prime minister handpicked six new chief and deputy prosecutors yesterday (3 March), defying EU calls for more transparency in a country where concerns about respect for the rule of law are growing.

Prime Minister Victor Ponta, whose leftist alliance alarmed the EU last year by attempting to impeach President Traian B?sescu, its main political rival, announced the nominations which he said would ensure "political and judicial stability".

The EU, which Romania joined in 2007, has put its justice system under special monitoring (see background) and asked Bucharest to pick chief prosecutors through a transparent process of applications and interviews, to ensure they were not political appointments.

Ponta, who is also interim justice minister, went back and forth on the nominations. On Tuesday, after meeting the country's Supreme Council of Magistrates (CSM), he said nominations would come only after a transparent and lengthy process.

But on Wednesday he nominated candidates for the general prosecutor's office, the anti-corruption department and the organised crime unit. They must still be confirmed by the president.

"That the prime minister changed his mind again reflects his contempt for the magistrates council and a lack of political coherence," said Laura Stefan, a legal specialist at the Expert Forum think tank.

"The European Commission has clearly required transparency."

Under Romanian law, the president appoints chief prosecutors who have been proposed by the justice minister and received non-binding approval from the CSM, a procedure many analysts consider to be politicised.

Adrian Basaraba, a political science professor at the University of Timisoara, said Ponta's nominations appeared aimed at easing tensions between and within political parties, but were unlikely to achieve that end.

"The nominations are a political compromise that try to mollify everybody," he said.

"But on the one hand they raise tensions in his alliance and on the other they won't necessarily improve the judiciary."

Ponta's nominee to head the anti-corruption unit – former general prosecutor Laura Codru?a Kövesi who was praised by Brussels – was criticised by a faction of his Social Liberal Union (USL), which said Ponta had struck a deal with their opponent B?sescu.

"For the first time since the USL was created, the prime minister … made a decision without consulting us and with which we fundamentally disagree," said Senate speaker Crin Antonescu, who co-leads the USL with Ponta. He added that the alliance would stick together despite concerns about the decision.

Romania and Bulgaria joined the EU on 1 January 2007, but shortcomings in their programmes for judicial reform and the fight against corruption have raised concerns in Brussels. With Bulgaria, problems have also been identified in its fight against organised crime.

A Cooperation and Verification Mechanism (CVM) was set up to assist both countries with judiciary matters after their EU accession.

The European Commission expressed concern about the ongoing political infighting in Romania in its CVM report published last summer.

A report on 18 July 2012 questioned the country’s ability to comply with the EU's fundamental principles on the sustainability and irreversibility of reform. Commission President José Manuel Barroso said that the political feuds in Romania had "shaken [the] EU's trust" in the country.


Measure co-financed by the European Union

The content of this page and articles represents the views of the author only and is his/her sole responsibility. The European Parliament does not accept any responsibility for use that may be made of the information it contains.

Subscribe to our newsletters