The European Union, the third-largest emitter of planet-warming greenhouse gases after China and the United States, has long been held up as the poster child of efforts to save Earth’s climate.
But after years of taking the lead in talks on a global climate pact, and making tough policy and investment choices to lessen fossil fuel reliance at home, the bloc’s resolve now seems to be flagging, analysts say.
Europe is responsible for about 10% of global emissions.
As the world’s nations meet in Bonn to negotiate a rulebook for executing the climate rescue Paris Agreement, adopted in 2015 to limit emissions from burning oil, coal, and gas, here is a look at Europe’s role.
— UN Climate Action (@UNFCCC) May 17, 2017
Having been at the forefront of the Industrial Revolution that sparked the large-scale carbon dioxide pollution of Earth’s atmosphere now blamed for global warming, Europe took the lead hundreds of years later in shifting to cleaner energy generated by sources such as the sun, waves and wind.
It was instrumental in passing, and keeping alive, the 1997 Kyoto Protocol, the Paris Agreement’s predecessor, despite opposition from the United States and other developed countries.
Europe also created the first, still the biggest, carbon market in a bid to incentivise companies to pollute less.
The Emissions Trading System limits emissions and allows companies to trade in allowances not used.
Then what happened?
The carbon market, which covers about 40% of Europe’s industrial emissions, has proven ineffective, critics say, and needs urgent reform.
Carbon allowances were too generous, resulting in a carbon price too low to encourage savings.
The bloc also took on emissions-cutting targets that analysts say are too low to stay under the ceiling for average global warming set in the Paris pact – no more than two degrees Celsius (3.6 degrees Fahrenheit) over pre-industrial levels.
The EU pledged to reduce its own emissions by 20% by 2020 over 1990 levels – a goal it is on course to exceed.
With three years to go, the target has already been met even if five countries – Austria, Belgium, Denmark, Luxembourg and Ireland – are not on track to achieve their national goals.
The European Environment Agency expects the bloc will reach 24% in 2020.
— EU EnvironmentAgency (@EUEnvironment) April 5, 2017
This goes to show that the target was too “modest” to begin with, according to Celia Gautier of the Climate Action Network, a grouping of NGOs.
By 2020, Europe also seeks to boost energy efficiency (less fossil fuel input for the same energy output) by 20% and ensure that 20% of energy consumed is from renewables.
According to Eurostat, renewable energy consumption in Europe was already 16.7% in 2014.
“In the wake of the Paris Agreement’s entry into force, the EU’s climate policy effort appears to be slowing, and it has not effectively responded” to an aspirational 1.5 C lower limit also written into the pact, according to the Climate Action Tracker (CAT), a tool created by think-tanks to measure countries’ progress.
Europe’s medium and long-term ambitions are even more problematic.
It is targeting a 40% domestic reduction in greenhouse gas emissions by 2030 over 1990 levels, which the CAT says is “significantly behind what is achievable and necessary”.
And it is not on track to meet even that – currently steering for 30-39%.
According to the CAT, Europe needs to reduce emissions by about two percent per year to achieve a 45-50% cut by 2030 – a trajectory more in line with the Paris accord’s objectives.
But emissions are projected to slow only between 0.5% and 1.3% per year.
Europe is not alone – the CAT says all major emitters, the US, China, India and Russia included, need to do much more for the world to stay under 2 C.
— ClimateActionTracker (@climateactiontr) May 15, 2017
For 2050, the European Union has set its sights on an 80-95% reduction from 1990, which the CAT says would require “significant acceleration”.
According to Climate Analytics, a policy institute, 300 coal-fired power stations have to close in Europe by 2030, if the Paris goals are to be met.
— UN Climate Action (@UNFCCC) May 12, 2017
Half of Europe’s coal emissions come from Germany and Poland, the rest mainly from Bulgaria and the Czech Republic – countries with relatively smaller reduction goals than their richer European peers.
“To achieve total decarbonisation of the global economy by the second half of the 21st century (as mooted in the Paris Agreement), Europe must, as an industrial leader, be among the first to achieve it,” said David Levai, a researcher at the IDDRI research institute in Paris.