Watchdog opens inquiry into Commission advisers

Emily O'Reilly [Irish Jesuits/Flickr]

Emily O’Reilly opened an investigation into how the EU executive hires special advisers for commissioners.

The Ombudswoman said she received multiple complaints about the European Commission’s advisers, and will start looking at how the executive checks to make sure the external consultants don’t have conflicts of interest.

Commissioners currently have around 40 special advisers between them. Commission President Jean-Claude Juncker has four special advisers, more than any other members of Commission.

O’Reilly said her office found the executive mishandled the hiring of Edmund Stoiber, a retired German conservative who advised the Commission on better regulation until 2014. O’Reilly is responsible for investigating maladministration in EU institutions.

The executive sent out a press release announcing Stoiber’s appointment three months before he was officially hired, which O’Reilly said “raised doubts” that the executive didn’t properly review Stoiber’s conflicts of interests.

Stoiber was not paid a salary but did have expenses covered during his seven year-run at the European Commission. During the same time, he also earned money as a board member of German insurer Nürnberger Versicherungsgruppe.

Edmund Stoiber: 'I have changed the EU'

Former Bavarian leader Edmund Stoiber was the EU’s “Mr Red Tape”, retiring after seven years of trying to reduce bureaucracy in the bloc. Before presenting his final report, he spoke of a “change of consciousness” in Brussels and called on member states to do their share to cut excessive regulation. EURACTIV Germany reports.

The Ombudswoman said she’ll examine all special advisers who worked with the executive in 2015 and 2016.

O’Reilly said she’ll check whether the Commission does enough to make sure advisers don’t have other jobs that could compromise their work with the executive.

“Whether you’re paid or not, I don’t think it makes a difference. It’s all around access and conflicts,” O’Reilly said.

“They may still have a private interest,” she added.

In a letter to Juncker dated last Friday (27 May), O’Reilly wrote that because of the advisers’ “high-level experience and skills, their advice to these decision-makers may be given more weight than advice from other sources”.

A recent complaint sent to O’Reilly’s office suggested the Commission conducted reviews of advisers’ activities to make sure they don’t have conflicts of interest, but didn’t do additional reviews if an adviser later took on a new job or had a potential conflict after starting work with an EU commissioner.

O’Reilly has separately been pressuring the executive to step up transparency measures that require lobbyists who meet with Commissioners to register their details on a public website.

In another letter to Juncker, she recommended that the European Commission tighten up rules and impose penalties on any lobbyists who don’t disclose accurate information.

“Europe needs to get a lot more serious about this,” she told journalists today.

Earlier this year, she also asked the Commission to publish minutes from meetings held by its 830 so-called expert groups.

The executive responded today (30 May) by setting up a new website detailing its expert groups and imposing diversity requirements and conflict of interest rules for the groups.

The Ombudswoman reported that EU institutions complied with 90% of her recommendations in 2014, according to the most recent figures published by her office.

Publish minutes of expert meetings, Ombudsman tells Commission

The European Commission should start publishing comprehensive minutes of the meetings of the 830 expert groups the executive uses to inform its policy decisions, an EU watchdog has said.

EU Ombudswoman Emily O'Reilly opened an inquiry into the European Commission's special advisers on 30 May 2016. Her office will examine all of the advisers to EU commissioners during 2015 and 2016. The executive currently has around 40 special advisers who have direct access to commissioners. President Jean-Claude Juncker has four special advisers.

O'Reilly said she will focus on how the Commission assesses whether advisers have conflicts of interest, including other jobs.


Measure co-financed by the European Union

The content of this page and articles represents the views of the author only and is his/her sole responsibility. The European Parliament does not accept any responsibility for use that may be made of the information it contains.

Subscribe to our newsletters