Does the European Constitution create a more democratic EU ?

DISCLAIMER: All opinions in this column reflect the views of the author(s), not of EURACTIV Media network.

One of the most frequent criticisms of the EU is that it suffers from a ‘democratic deficit’. But will this be redressed by the Constitution? asks Chris Yeomans, from café babel.


The EU is not a perfect example of participatory democracy since the only directly elected institution (the European Parliament) is largely subordinate to the will of the unelected executive (the Commission). However, it must immediately be emphasised that over the last 25 years, since the introduction of direct European elections, democracy has gradually become more established in the European model. Most recently, this has been shown in the Buttiglione affair where Barroso, the President of the Commission, was forced to back down over his controversial choice of Commissioner by the Parliament. The Constitution will further augment the Parliament’s role, which will increase the democratic legitimacy of the EU for, if managed correctly, it will show that MEPs are in Brussels for more than just the sandwiches and voters can see their vote in action. 

More efficiency means more democracy 

Another key, and very controversial, feature of the Constitution is the extension of Qualified Majority Voting (QMV) to cover areas such as Police and Judicial Cooperation in Criminal matters. Under the current ‘pillar’ system, decisions taken in these areas must be taken unanimously. Although opponents argue that QMV interferes with the sovereign veto right of a nation, it is submitted that this change is essential to improve efficiency and enhance the democratic legitimacy of the EU. To use an analogy, if you house-share with twenty-five people it is going to be difficult to decide who buys the milk if one person alone can frustrate the process. Although the weighting of votes was controversial during the negotiations (particularly in the case of Spain and Poland), it is logical that in a democratic system decision-making operates where possible upon a consensus – rather that upon limited opposition. Other examples of how the Constitution will enhance efficiency, and therefore also democracy, include an elected president for the European Council (instead of the six-monthly rotation under the current system) and a gradual slimming down of the number of Commissioners from today’s twenty-five to a total of eighteen.


Please click here to read this analysis in full.

Subscribe to our newsletters