After Trump and Brexit, EU to launch defence research plan

New research has found that Eurofighters are ready for use 52% of the time, well under the goal of an average 70% readiness. [Eurofighter]

The European Union will unveil its biggest defence research plan in more than a decade on Wednesday (30 November) to reverse billions of euros in cuts and send a message to US President-elect Donald Trump that Europe wants to pay for its own security.

Part of a broader push to revitalise defence cooperation, the European Commission will propose a defence fund and seek to lift a ban on the EU’s common budget and its development bank investing in military research.

The main proposal, to be presented at around noon Brussels time, is an investment fund for defence, which could allow EU governments that pay into it also to borrow, ensuring funds are always available for joint defence programmes such as helicopters or drones.

Germany and France seek stronger EU defence after Brexit

Germany and France have outlined plans to deepen European military cooperation, a document showed on Monday (12 September), as Britain’s exit from the European Union removes one of the biggest obstacles to stronger EU defence in tandem with NATO.

The fund, which could start on a small scale in 2017, could be backed by the European Investment Bank to finance projects if governments agree to remove the ban on backing military projects.

With the Commission overseeing a common EU budget of about €150 billion a year, France and Germany say it is time to allow it to be used for military research.

The European Parliament has approved a €90 million pilot plan for 2017 to 2019 and the Commission could potentially allocate €3.5 billion from the budget between 2021 and 2027, officials say.

Defence research spending by EU governments has fallen by a third since 2006, leaving the European Union reliant on the United States for advanced warfighting equipment.

During the US election campaign, Trump questioned whether the United States should protect allies seen as spending too little on their defence, raising fears that he could withdraw funding for NATO at a time of heightened tensions with Russia.

Trump’s NATO remarks rattle US establishment, allies

Foreign policy experts warned that the suggestion by Republican presidential nominee Donald Trump that he might abandon NATO’s pledge to automatically defend all alliance members could destroy the organization and invite Russian aggression.

France and Germany rely on ageing military transport planes, for example, while some navy helicopters have been grounded because of technical faults related to long years of service.

A report by the German military seen by Reuters on Tuesday showed its Tornado jets had a readiness rate of just 44% and its newer Eurofighters were ready for use 52% of the time, well under the goal of an average 70% readiness.

“Europe has to be very careful that the investment gap is not translated into an ever wider technology gap,” EU foreign policy chief Federica Mogherini told defence contractors and officials at a speech earlier this month.

“If left unchecked, this could translate into a political gap which would clearly not be in our interest,” she said, referring to a potential loss of the EU’s foreign policy clout.

Brexit dilemma

An earlier Commission plan in 2003 failed to win over governments. This time around, France, Germany and Italy are seizing on Britain’s decision to quit the bloc. They see it as removing an obstacle to deeper defence cooperation, given Britain’s fears about a European army run from Brussels.

EU backs minimalist defence plan in effort not to undermine NATO

EU ministers approved a common defence plan yesterday (14 November) despite sharp differences over how far it should go, as Donald Trump’s election win stoked fears about Washington’s commitment to European security.

Britain’s departure removes one of the biggest contributors to the EU budget, although it is not clear if Britain would seek to collaborate on defence from outside the bloc.

“We see EU defence as detrimental to NATO, but if there are major collaborative research projects, we would want to be part of them,” said Geoffrey Van Orden, a former brigadier in the British army and now a lawmaker with the eurosceptic European Conservatives and Reformists group in the European Parliament.

Defence minister: Britain 'will oppose any idea of an EU army'

The UK will oppose all EU plans for increased military cooperation that could interfere with NATO, despite being about to leave the union, Defence Minister Michael Fallon said Tuesday (27 September).

Germany and France say sharing resources may be the only way to sustain adequate military forces. EU officials point to the merger of missile systems companies in France, Italy and Britain in 2001 to create MBDA, the only European group able to design and produce world-class missile systems.

Waste is also a problem, as European governments champion national defence contractors. According to EU data, the bloc has 19 types of armoured infantry fighting vehicle, compared with one in the United States.

Why European defence research matters

Defence can no longer be looked at simply from a national perspective. European defence is stronger than the sum of its parts and it needs greater cooperation in defence innovation, in cutting-edge capabilities, in research and technology. And it needs to happen now, argues Jorge Domecq.

ALDE Group leader Guy Verhofstadt said the EDF is an important tool that the EU needs to improve its defence capabilities:

“Working together on defence will make us stronger, safer and better off. Due to our lack of coordination, we lose up to 100 billion euro a year, while nearly 80% of defence spending in the EU is run on a purely national basis. EU member states together spend nearly half of the American defence budget, yet they have only around 10-15% of US capabilities; we cannot afford such inefficiency any more. The EU is surrounded by a ring of autocrats and can no longer rely on the US for our security- we need to start building a European Defence Union with European integrated military forces.”

Subscribe to our newsletters