Erdogan rebukes Trump’s top security adviser over Kurds in Syria

A handout photo made available by Turkish Presidential Press Office shows Turkish Presidential Spokesperson Ibrahim Kalin (R) and US National Security Advisor John Bolton (L) during their meeting in Ankara, Turkey, 8 January 2019. [Handout photo/EPA/EFE]

Turkey’s President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan rebuked Washington’s national security adviser on Tuesday (8 January) for demanding that his country not attack Kurdish fighters in Syria, accusing him of complicating President Donald Trump’s plan to withdraw US troops.

Erdoğan said John Bolton, who held talks with Turkish officials in Ankara on Tuesday but left without meeting the president, “made a serious mistake” in setting conditions for Turkey’s military role after the US pullout.

The rebuke highlights the difficulties in implementing Trump’s goal of bringing home some 2,000 US troops stationed in Syria. Trump’s plan, clouded by mixed messages from the president and his administration, hinges on Turkish cooperation to secure a huge swathe of northeast Syria as the United States departs.

Pentagon warns Turkey against unilateral military action in Syria

The Pentagon said on Wednesday (12 December) that unilateral military action into northeast Syria by any party would be “unacceptable,” after Turkey said it would launch a new military operation in the region within days to target Kurdish militia fighters.

Bolton made the case to Turkish officials for the need for guarantees that US-backed Kurdish fighters in the campaign against Islamic State would not be harmed after a US withdrawal, a senior US official said. But there were no signs of any agreement between the two North Atlantic Treaty Organization partners, whose relations have been strained over Syria and other issues.

EU urges Turkey to refrain from 'unilateral' Syria move

The European Union’s foreign policy chief on Saturday (15 December) asked Turkey to forgo any unilateral military action in Syria, where Ankara has threatened a fresh offensive against a US-backed Kurdish militia.

Trump’s abrupt announcement last month sparked concern among officials in Washington and some Western allies, and was a major factor in Defense Secretary Jim Mattis’ decision to resign. It also alarmed the YPG, Washington’s main partner against Islamic State in Syria.

But the plan was lauded by Ankara. Turkey considers the YPG a terrorist organisation and an extension of the outlawed Kurdistan Workers Party (PKK), which has waged a three-decade insurgency in its largely Kurdish southeast. Washington’s support for the militia has infuriated Turkey.

Before arriving in Turkey, Bolton said Turkey must coordinate military action with the United States and no US withdrawal would take place until Ankara guaranteed the Kurdish fighters would be safe.

But Erdoğan, who has long argued that the YPG is no different from the Islamic State militants, said the condition was unacceptable.

“If they are terrorists, we will do what is necessary no matter where they come from,” he told members of his AK Party in parliament.

“Bolton has made a serious mistake and whoever thinks like this has also made a mistake. It is not possible for us to make compromises on this point.”

The Turkish president accused members of Trump’s administration of trying to muddy a clear understanding between the two countries over the withdrawal.

“Different voices have started emerging from different segments of the administration,” Erdoğan said.

Focus on YPG

A senior Turkish official said Bolton had asked to see Erdoğan but his earlier remarks may have been a factor in the meeting not going ahead. Erdoğan later told reporters there was no need for him to meet Bolton.

US officials denied that Bolton felt snubbed. “The US Embassy in Turkey requested a series of meetings, but due to scheduling conflicts, one with President Erdoğan was never confirmed,” said Garrett Marquis, Bolton’s spokesman.

Instead, Bolton met his Turkish counterpart Ibrahim Kalin as well as the deputy defense and foreign ministers, while on a quick tour to the region to manage fallout from Trump’s abrupt decision on Syria.

Bolton also told the Turkish officials the US withdrawal would be done in a deliberate and orderly fashion and that at this point the United States had no plans to abandon its Syria base at al-Tanf near the Iraqi border, the senior US official said.

On a visit to Jordan on Tuesday, Secretary of State Mike Pompeo said the withdrawal would not jeopardise Washington’s efforts to counter regional threats from Islamic State and Iran.

Economic friction

The friction with the United States has had economic consequences for Turkey. A diplomatic rift last year – now partly repaired – was one of the factors that sent Turkey’s lira into a tailspin over the summer.

The currency slipped again on Tuesday, weakening some 2% against the dollar.

Ahead of Tuesday’s talks, Turkey’s Hurriyet newspaper said Ankara would ask US officials either to hand over its military bases in Syria to Ankara or to destroy them. It cited unspecified sources as saying Turkey would not accept the handover of what it said were 22 US military bases to the YPG.

A senior Turkish security official told Reuters last week Washington needed to allow Turkey to use its bases in Syria. Kalin said Turkey wanted the bases emptied and handed over to “local elements.”

Following the meeting, Kalin said there was no slowdown in the US withdrawal from Syria and that Turkey was focused on what happens to US bases in Syria and the weapons Washington has given the YPG.

Bolton was joined by US Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff General Joseph Dunford and US special Syria envoy James Jeffrey for the talks with Kalin, who is Erdoğan’s spokesman and deputy head of Turkey’s security and foreign policies board.

Subscribe to our newsletters