Germany says NATO concerned about Trump ‘obsolete’ remark

Boris Johnson [L] and Frank-Walter Steinmeier in Brussels on 16 January 2017. [European Union]

Germany’s foreign minister said yesterday (16 January) that US President-elect Donald Trump’s comments that NATO was obsolete had aroused concern across the 28-member alliance.

Frank-Walter Steinmeier, speaking after a meeting with alliance Secretary-General Jens Stoltenberg in Brussels, said Trump’s remarks contradicted views expressed by designated Defence Secretary James Mattis. He also spoke of “amazement”.

“I’ve spoken today not only with EU foreign ministers but NATO foreign ministers as well and can report that the signals are that there’s been no easing of tensions,” Steinmeier told reporters when asked about Trump’s interview with Bild newspaper and The Times of London.

NATO, Russia, Merkel, Brexit: Trump unleashes broadsides on Europe

NATO is “obsolete”, Germany’s Angela Merkel made a “catastrophic mistake” on refugees, Brexit will be “great” and the US could cut a deal with Russia: Donald Trump unleashed a volley of broadsides on Sunday (15 January) in interviews with European media.

“Obviously the comments from President-elect Trump, that he views NATO as obsolete, were viewed with anxiety,” he said.

Trump, who is due to be sworn in as president on Friday, said NATO was obsolete because it had not defended against terrorist attacks.

He said also he had always had “great respect” for German Chancellor Angela Merkel, but criticised her 2015 decision to allow in a wave of a million migrants as a “catastrophic mistake” that opened the door to terrorist attacks.

US Secretary of State John Kerry said it was “inappropriate” for Trump to weigh directly into the politics of another country by his remarks.

“He will have to speak to that, as of Friday he is responsible for that relationship.”

Russia agrees

NATO has been seen as the keystone of western European defences since the 1950s, extending its zone of activity in the post-Cold War period to the borders of Russia – much to Russia’s chagrin. The alliance’s founding treaty commits members to consider an attack on any one state as an attack on all.

Trump’s NATO remarks rattle US establishment, allies

Foreign policy experts warned that the suggestion by Republican presidential nominee Donald Trump that he might abandon NATO’s pledge to automatically defend all alliance members could destroy the organization and invite Russian aggression.

A Kremlin spokesman said he agreed with Trump that NATO, characterised by Russian officials as a hostile renmant of the Cold War, was obsolete.

Germany’s trans-Atlantic coordinator, Jürgen Hardt, told Reuters he did not expect Congress to allow Washington to give up its leadership role in NATO.

He said key US lawmakers, including Senate Armed Services Committee Chairman John McCain, had told him several weeks ago they expected Washington to remain a reliable partner in the 28-nation bloc, and he did not expect Trump to reverse the deployment of 4,000 US troops to Poland.

NATO reassures Russia over troop deployments

NATO will seek to reassure Russia today (19 December) that its troop deployments in the Baltics and Poland next year are purely defensive, in a rare meeting of the alliance’s and Kremlin’s envoys that is unlikely to resolve long-standing grievances.

Norbert Röttgen, head of Germany’s foreign affairs committee, said Germany should fight to restore Western unity.

“Europe is not able to replace the security role of the United States so there is a lot at stake – the very foundations of liberal order internationally and European security. And for that we should fight because it is our very existential interest,” Röttgen told Reuters.

Trump repeated criticism of NATO members that fail to spend at least 2% of gross domestic product on defence.

Germany is working to gradually boost its military spending, Defence Ministry spokesman Jens Flosdorff told a news conference. Merkel in November said she could not promise the NATO target would be met “in the near future”.

Subscribe to our newsletters