Nuclear sanctions on Iran to be lifted if it meets deal

EU High Representative Federica Mogherini and Iranian Foreign Minister Javad Zarif. [Reuters]

A raft of global sanctions imposed on Iran over its alleged nuclear activities will be lifted over time, if the Islamic Republic sticks to the terms of a final deal with the global powers reached on Thursday (2 April) after 12 years of brinkmanship, threats and confrontation.

The tentative agreement, after eight days of marathon talks in Switzerland, clears the way for negotiations on a settlement aimed at allaying Western fears that Iran was seeking to build an atomic bomb, and in return lift economic sanctions on the Islamic Republic.

The framework is contingent on reaching an agreement by 30 June. All sanctions on Iran remain in place until a final deal, which world powers hope will make it virtually impossible for Iran to make nuclear weapons under the guise of its civilian program.

EU foreign policy chief Federica Mogherini said a “decisive step” has been achieved. Iran’s Zarif, and Mogherini, delivered a joint statement late Thursday following reports of the deal. Mogherini has acted as a coordinator for the so-called P5+1 powers – the United States, Britain, France, China, Russia plus Germany – in the latest round of talks with Tehran.

“In return for Iran’s future cooperation, we and our international partners will provide relief in phases from the sanctions that have impacted Iran’s economy,” said US Secretary of State John Kerry.

The United Nations will also lift past nuclear-related sanctions “simultaneous with the completion, by Iran, of nuclear-related actions addressing all key concerns”, the State Department said in a factsheet.

Celebrations erupted in the Iranian capital Tehran. Videos and pictures posted on social media showed cars in Tehran honking horns as passengers clapped. In one video posted on Facebook, a group of women can be heard clapping and chanting “Thank you, Rouhani,” in praise of President Hassan Rouhani.

President Barack Obama described the agreement as a “historic understanding with Iran” and compared it to nuclear arms control deals struck by his predecessors with the Soviet Union that “made our world safer” during the Cold War. He also cautioned, however, that “success is not guaranteed”.

French President Francois Hollande welcomed the framework, but said France must remain “watchful” to ensure a final agreement prevents Iran from having access to nuclear arms, a comment echoed by British Foreign Secretary Philip Hammond.

Many details still need to be worked out. Diplomats close to the negotiations said the deal was fragile. It could not be ruled out that the understandings reached could collapse between now and 30 June. Experts believe it will be much harder to reach a final deal than it was to agree the framework accord.

Devil in the details

Under the outline deal, Iran would shut more than two-thirds of its installed centrifuges capable of producing uranium that could be used to build a bomb, dismantle a reactor that could produce plutonium, and accept intrusive verification, according to a statement.

The agreement will be in effect for 10 to 15 years, during which there will be strict limitations and oversight of the Iranian nuclear program. Some parts of the agreement will remain in effect for 20 to 25 years.

Iran agreed to significantly reduce the number of installed uranium enrichment centrifuges it has to 6,104 from 19,000 and will only operate 5,060 for 10 years. Teheran will only use first generation centrifuges during that time.

One of the most sensitive issues during the negotiations, Iran’s research and development work, will also be limited.

Iran has also agreed to not conduct research and development associated with uranium enrichment at Fordow for 15 years. Teheran will remove the 1,000 more advanced second-generation centrifuges currently installed at Natanz and place them in International Atomic Energy Agency-monitored storage for 10 years.

High enriched uranium can be used to make a weapon, which they aim to prevent, while low enriched uranium is used in power plants. Iran has insisted it wants it only for a peaceful nuclear energy programme and denies it aimed to build an atomic bomb.

Iran’s breakout timeline – the time that it would take for it acquire enough fissile material for one weapon – would be extended to at least one year, for a duration of at least 10 years, under this framework. It is currently assessed to be two to three months, the US factsheet said.

Under Thursday’s agreement, Iran will gradually receive relief from US and European Union nuclear sanctions if it complies with the terms of a final deal. Some UN Security Council sanctions would be gradually lifted, though others would remain in place, specifically those relating to proliferation.

Not done deal

“We’re still some time away from reaching where we want to be,” said Iran’s Foreign Minister Mohammad Javad Zarif.

French Foreign Minister Laurent Fabius also struck a cautious note, welcoming the framework but adding: “There is still work to do.”

Failure to comply with the terms of the deal will cause the EU and US sanctions to “snap back into place”, the US said. It was less specific on United Nations sanctions, one of the main sticking points in the negotiations, saying only that they could be reimposed in the event of Iranian non-compliance.

Zarif indicated annoyance with the US decision to release it’s own factsheet on the deal, saying on Twitter: “The solutions are good for all, as they stand. There is no need to spin using ‘factsheets’ so early on.”

The Iranian delegation regularly consulted with Tehran, the capital. “They were under tremendous pressure as the Leader’s deadlines were not negotiable,” said an official.

US Secretary of State John Kerry told reporters many technical details needed to be worked out, including the possible lifting of a UN arms embargo and the modernization of the Arak heavy-water reactor and Fordow underground sites.

Officials of Gulf Arab states, traditionally wary of Iran, were silent about the deal. The main evening television news in Saudi Arabia broadcast a segment on the agreement only 40 minutes into its program.

A senior Gulf Arab official said any reaction would come in the days ahead, not from individual countries but from the Gulf Cooperation Council, an alliance of Saudi Arabia, Kuwait, the United Arab Emirates (UAE), Qatar, Oman and Bahrain.

Obama called Saudi Arabia’s King Salman bin Abdulaziz al-Saud to discuss the deal and invited GCC leaders to Camp David for a summit this spring to discuss Iran.

Russia said the agreement would have a positive impact on the security situation in the Middle East, with Iran being able to take a more active part in solving problems and conflicts.

India, which has tested nuclear weapons, but is a non-signatory to the Non-Proliferation Treaty, called the agreement a “significant step”, saying New Delhi had “always maintained that the Iranian nuclear issue should be resolved peacefully by respecting Iran’s right to peaceful uses of nuclear energy”.

Israel, assumed to have the Middle East’s only nuclear arsenal, was not a party to the talks, but views Iran as a mortal threat and lobbied vigorously for an uncompromising stand. In a call to Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, Obama said significant progress had been made toward cutting off Iran’s pathways to a nuclear weapon, the White House said.

The talks were the biggest opportunity for rapprochement between Washington and Tehran since they became enemies after Iran’s 1979 revolution, but any deal faces scepticism from conservatives in both countries. US allies in the Middle East are also sceptical, including Saudi Arabia.

Zarif said that other realms of Iran-US relations had nothing to do with the agreement. “We have serious differences with the United States,” he said.

Kerry said the United States remained seriously concerned about Iran’s destabilising activities in the region. Tehran stands at the centre of sectarian conflicts ranging from Syria and Iraq to Yemen.

US sanctions on Iran for “terrorism, human rights abuses and ballistic missiles will remain in place” under the future nuclear deal, the US factsheet said.

Dutch Member of European Parliament Marietje Schaake (ALDE/D66) responds to the outlines of a deal between the P5+1 and Iran that were announced this evening.

"I welcome the historic steps that were announced this evening. However, hard work remains to be done in order to work out details that should lead to mutual trust that Iran will not pursue the development of a nuclear weapon, and that Europe, the US and the international community will lift sanctions."

"Congratulations go to Federica Mogherini and Catherine Ashton, who represented the EU in these historic and challenging negotiations. I believe Europe must seize this moment to work on other important issues on our agenda, such as countering terrorism in the Middle-East, and the human rights of the Iranian people."

Subscribe to our newsletters