France worried about mental health of its lockdown-stricken citizens

"If no urgent action is taken on mental health care, the demand for psychosocial support will inevitably increase, contributing to the 84 million people suffering from mental disorders in the European Union alone," said Liuska Sanna, acting director of Europe's largest independent mental health network organisation, Mental Health Europe. [SHUTTERSTOCK]

After more than a year of successive lockdowns implemented by European governments to curb the spread of COVID-19, the French authorities are now worried about the mental health of their citizens. EURACTIV France reports.

“Psychiatrists have an influx of people who are in great pain,” Katia Julienne, director-general of the French health ministry’s healthcare services department, warned during a webinar organised by France Assos Santé on 15 April.

While a psychological support unit was proposed in France during the first pandemic wave, psychiatrists preferred to focus on continuing to provide care during the second one. Psychiatrists “adapted” to the situation as they made use of mobile kits and gave consultations remotely, particularly to assist patients with the greatest difficulties, Julienne added.

The practice of ‘telemedicine’ is becoming increasingly popular in Europe.

In 2015, countries like Greece and Spain launched pilot programmes for remote psychiatric care, while Croatia, Italy and Lithuania had more informal initiatives, according to a study conducted by the World Health Organisation’s Global eHealth Observatory.

Operational telepsychiatry programmes only existed in Finland, the Netherlands, and Sweden at the time the study was carried out.

Some European countries with ‘telemedicine’ facilities in the psychiatric field in 2015 – Hungary did not have such a service in 2015 and the WHO did not gather data for other European countries. WHO only gathered data for the European countries cited above. Sources: WHO and Civio.

In Finland, the Netherlands, and Sweden, people are prone to depression, while France is the country with the highest rate of psychiatric disorders.

With the conference on psychiatry and mental health announced by President Emmanuel Macron, and due to start before the summer, this often neglected area of medicine is now one of the government’s concerns.

“If no urgent action is taken on mental health care, the demand for psychosocial support will inevitably increase, contributing to the 84 million people suffering from mental disorders in the European Union alone,” said Liuska Sanna, acting director of Europe’s largest independent mental health network organisation, Mental Health Europe.

Part of the population suffering from depression in 2017. Source: Our world in data.

“Vulnerable groups, including people with psychosocial disabilities, will pay a high price. We cannot wait for another pandemic to apply the lessons learned. Only a proactive response can prevent health systems from being further overburdened and collapsing,” she said.

One way to address the issue is to deal with the staffing situation. Some countries have a severe shortage of psychiatric care providers, particularly Spain, Bulgaria, and Poland, which had only 10.93, 10.31, and 9.23 psychiatrists per 100,000 inhabitants in 2018, respectively.

Part of the population in 2017 with a mental health or substance abuse disorder. This includes eating disorders, alcohol and substance use, and schizophrenia. Source: Our world in data.

Prioritising youth

In France, a national survey focusing on the mental health of young children was launched on 16 April with the meeting of a scientific committee, according to Santé Publique France.

“The first years of life are crucial for children’s psycho-affective development, learning, and their ability to adapt in their future adult life,” said the website of France’s national public health agency.

“The current health crisis has had an impact on young people’s mental health and has shown the need for action on care and prevention based on robust data,” the agency added.

Number of psychiatrists per 100,000 inhabitants in 2018. Source: Civio.

France’s federation of psychiatry stated the importance of not taking children out of school in a press release published on 10 February. “Socialisation experiences are a source of acquisition of progressive autonomy, openness to the world and diversified learning, which are essential for their development and positive projection into the future,” the release said.

Noting “the absence of any serious form of COVID-19 at this age”, the federation deemed it “essential to preserve the mental health of our children by maintaining their schooling at all costs and by offering them places for extracurricular, cultural, and sporting activities.”

Alain Ehrenberg, emeritus research director at the National Centre for Scientific Research (CNRS), explained in an article published on Telos, how the breakdown of social ties due to lockdowns damages people’s health.

According to him, “mass individual existence” leads to “mass personal insecurity that is expressed in terms of mental health and psychological suffering”. This means that as society continues to push for “the expression of individual subjectivity”, “mental health appears as a very concrete aspect of the emotional dimensions of social relations,” he added.

[Edited by Zoran Radosavljevic]

*This article was written within the framework of the European EDJNet project.





A 'marathon' needed to avoid a mental health pandemic

As the infection and death rates from coronavirus continue to decline across Europe, policy makers are beginning to take stock of the widespread impact of the pandemic on mental health.

Subscribe to our newsletters