‘At a crossroads’: Polish PM berates EU ahead of trip to European Parliament

"We are at a crucial moment, you could say at a crossroads in the EU's history," Morawiecki told the Polish parliament. "Democracy is being tested – how far will European nations retreat before this usurpation by some EU institutions." [EPA-EFE/RADEK PIETRUSZKA]

Polish Prime Minister Mateusz Morawiecki accused European Union institutions on Thursday (14 October) of infringing on the rights of member states, as he prepared to present Warsaw’s position in a row over the rule of law next week before the European Parliament.

Poland’s nationalist government has been at odds with the European Commission in Brussels over judicial reforms, media freedoms and LGBT rights since taking power in 2015.

But a recent court ruling that parts of EU law are incompatible with the Polish constitution has brought matters to a head.

“We are at a crucial moment, you could say at a crossroads in the EU’s history,” Morawiecki told the Polish parliament. “Democracy is being tested – how far will European nations retreat before this usurpation by some EU institutions.”

The ruling by Poland’s Constitutional Tribunal, an institution the government’s critics say has become politicised as part of reforms they say undermine judicial independence, challenges a key tenet of European integration.

Poland says the EU has overstepped its mandate by attempting to prevent the government’s judicial reforms, and that the Constitutional Tribunal ruling asserts the primacy of the Polish constitution in a way that is no different from rulings handed down by courts in other European countries.

Polish court rules against supremacy of EU law, deepening row with Brussels

Poland’s highest court ruled on Thursday (7 October) that parts of EU treaties are incompatible with the Polish constitution, challenging a key tenet of European integration in a sharp escalation of a dispute between Brussels and Warsaw.

“Very serious”

Asked about Morawiecki’s comments on Thursday, Commission spokesman Christian Wigand said the EU executive had “the task of safeguarding the proper functioning of the Union’s legal order… and will ensure that the rights of Europeans under the Treaties will continue to be protected…”

He said an in-depth analysis of the Polish court ruling was underway, adding that an initial assessment pointed to “very serious issues in relation to the primacy of EU law”.

The court ruling could put at risk some €23 billion in EU grants and €34 billion in cheap loans that Poland could otherwise count on as part of the EU’s recovery fund after the COVID-19 pandemic.

It has also spurred talk of a “Polexit”, though Warsaw says it has no intention of following Britain out of the EU.

Polish government spokesman Piotr Muller said Morawiecki would attend the European Parliament session in Strasbourg next Tuesday to present Poland’s position in the rule of law dispute.

Poland enters minefield over EU order

In a groundbreaking ruling, the Polish Constitutional Tribunal declared the ultimate supremacy of the country’s constitution over EU treaties, in what some say could mark the start of “the countdown to Polexit.”

The primacy of EU law is no longer unconditional …

Subscribe to our newsletters

Subscribe