The United Nations’ human rights chief voiced alarm Thursday (10 March) over a draft deal between the EU and Ankara that could see “illegal” collective expulsions of migrants from Greece to Turkey.
“The EU’s draft arrangement with Turkey … raises a number of very serious concerns, (including) the potential for collective and arbitrary expulsions, which are illegal,” Zeid Ra’ad Al Hussein told the UN Human Rights Council in Geneva.
“Border restrictions which do not permit determination of the circumstances of each individual violate international and European law,” he said.
Zeid said he planned to discuss his concerns during a visit to Brussels early next week, ahead of a European Union summit on 17-18 March, where the controversial deal is expected to be finalised.
The deal would among other things see Turkey take back all illegal migrants landing in Greece.
Under the plan, the EU would meanwhile resettle one Syrian refugee from camps in Turkey in exchange for every Syrian that Turkey takes from Greece, in a bid to reduce the incentive for people to board boats for Europe.
The EU summit which ended this morning (8 March) failed to reach a deal with Turkey to stem the unprecedented migrant crisis, as many heads of state and government opposed German Chancellor Merkel’s attempt to impose her own deal with Ankara.
Zeid hailed the generosity displayed by countries like Germany and Greece as Europe tries to deal with its biggest migrant crisis since World War II.
But he lamented that “today, in violation of the fundamental principles of solidarity, human dignity and human rights, the race to repel these people is picking up momentum.”
The EU has been locked in dispute over how to stem an unprecedented influx of migrants that has numbered more than a million since the start of 2015, many from Syria, Afghanistan and Iraq and most aiming to reach wealthy Germany, Austria and Scandinavia.
“I must also reiterate my profound concern about restrictive measures such as erecting fences, denying people access to individualised procedures, and arbitrarily denying entry to people of specific nationalities,” Zeid said.
“I am in addition concerned about measures to seize belongings from people who may have already suffered greatly, and to restrict them from bringing in family members,” he said.
His comments came as EU interior ministers were set to meet in Brussels Thursday to discuss the migrant crisis after western Balkan nations slammed shut their borders, and to discuss the proposed deal with Turkey.
If the French government had supported its German partners on the issue of refugees, the European response to the crisis would not have been a failure, according to Philippe Lamberts.
EU leaders will meet with Turkish Prime Minister Ahmet Davutoğlu during a summit on 17-18 March over a plan to stem the flow of refugees arriving to Europe via Turkey. Under the deal that was discussed--but not yet agreed--on 7 March, the EU would apply a so-called “one for one” approach with Turkey. That would mean that if NATO or another force intercepts a boat with, say, 50 people, among whom 10 are Syrian, all of them will be rescued and sent to Turkey. Then the EU will be obligated to take 10 Syrians (not the same people, though) from Turkey and send them by plane to EU countries.
In exchange, the EU would commit to cover the costs of the readmission process, pay an additional €3 billion for refugees in Turkey living outside the camps, speed up lifting the visa requirement for Turkish nationals by June of this year, open five negotiation chapters in Turkey’s EU accession bid and resettle Syrians from Turkey to EU countries under the “one for one” formula.
- 17-18 March: European Council summit on migration with Turkish Prime Minister Ahmet Davutoğlu